CHAPTER FOUR. INITIATION IN JAVA
The description of Jakarta and Indonesia in the late 1960s and early 1970s and details of Ann's life there come from interviews with Halimah Bellows, Halimah Brugger, Elizabeth Bryant, Bill Collier, Stephen des Tombes, Michael Dove, Rens Heringa, Ikranagara, Kay Ikranagara, Samardal Manan, Wahyono Martowikrido, John McGlynn, Saman, Garrett and Bronwen Solyom, Sumastuti Sumukti, and Yang Suwan. I also relied on
A History of Modern Indonesia
by Adrian Vickers and
A Nation in Waiting
by Adam Schwarz. On the subject of Ann's employment, I am indebted to Irwan Holmes, Kay Ikranagara, Trusti Jarwadi, Leonard Kibble, Samardal Manan, Felina Pramono, Joseph Sigit, Sudibyo Siyam, and Stephen des Tombes. Information on the Institute for Management Education and Development also came from the archives of the Ford Foundation. For the facts of Lolo's work, I relied on his brother-in-law, Trisulo, and on Sonny Trisulo, Lolo's nephew. Insight into Ann as a parent came from her children as well as from Richard Hook, Kay Ikranagara, Don Johnston, Saman, Julia Suryakusuma, and Kadi Warner, among others.
108
“join in the killings”:
Adrian Vickers,
A History of Modern Indonesia,
158.
111
Indonesia's Prague Spring:
Schwarz,
A Nation in Waiting,
33.
115
“The Indonesian businessmen”:
Obama,
Dreams from My Father
, 43.
124
“They are
not
my people”:
Ibid., 47.
124
Ann's loneliness was a constant:
Ibid., 42â43.
126
“power had taken Lolo”:
Ibid., 45.
128
“She loved to take children”:
Obama,
The Audacity of Hope,
205.
129
“you're going to need some values”:
Obama,
Dreams from My Father,
49.
129
ideal human virtues:
Koentjaraningrat,
Javanese Culture,
122.
133
“I was an American, she decided”:
Obama,
Dreams from My Father,
47.
133
“no picnic for me either, buster”:
Ibid., 48.
134
“in Hawaii very soonâa year, tops”:
Ibid., 54.
134
“never would have made the trip”:
Obama,
The Audacity of Hope,
273.
CHAPTER FIVE. TRESPASSERS WILL BE EATEN
For the details of Ann's 1973 bus trip, I relied on her letter to Bill Byers and interviews with Jon Payne and Arlene Payne. The information on Ann's life as a graduate student came from Benji Bennington, Evelyn Caballero, Alice Dewey, Mendl Djunaidy, Ben Finney, Jean Kennedy, John Raintree, Garrett and Bronwen Solyom, Kadi Warner, and Brent Watanabe. For the sections on her experiences in Jakarta and Yogyakarta in the mid-1970s, I spoke with Rens Heringa, Terence Hull, Kay Ikranagara, Wahyono Martowikrido, Nancy Peluso, and Maya Soetoro-Ng. I also had access to some of Ann's academic records and correspondence with Alice Dewey.
143
“âYou two will become great friends'”:
Obama,
Dreams from My Father
, 64.
143
Obama's account of his father's Christmas visit:
Ibid., 67â69.
146
baking cookies was not at the top:
Ibid., 75.
149
Her most important market informants:
Alice G. Dewey,
Peasant Marketing in Java,
xiv.
150
“the best and most comprehensive study”:
Koentjaraningrat,
Javanese Culture,
176.
154
Her interest was function:
Bronwen Solyom, Symposium on Ann Dunham, University of Hawaiâi at MÄnoa, September 12, 2008.
155
“was interested in the place where vision meets execution”:
Maya Soetoro-Ng, foreword to S. Ann Dunham,
Surviving Against the Odds: Village Industry in Indonesia,
ixâx.
156
course in entrepreneurship:
Interview with Mendl W. Djunaidy, associate dean, East-West Center, October 7, 2008.
157
“I immediately said no”:
Obama,
Dreams from My Father,
76â77.
CHAPTER SIX. IN THE FIELD
Most of the material in this chapter comes from Ann Dunham's field notes, proposals, papers, and drafts, and the unpublished version of her dissertation, “Peasant Blacksmithing in Indonesia
:
Surviving and Thriving Against All Odds.” I also drew on Garrett and Bronwen Solyom's writings on the Javanese kris; correspondence between Ann Dunham and Alice Dewey, and a 1974 edition of
Guide to Java
by Peter Hutton and Hans Hoefer. I used material from interviews with Clare Blenkinsop, Nancy Cooper, Alice Dewey, Michael Dove, Maggie Norobangun, President Obama, John Raintree, Khismardani S-Roni, Taluki Sasmitarsi, Maya Soetoro-Ng, the Solyoms, Sumarni and Djaka Waluja, and from e-mails written by Haryo Soetendro.
172
Clifford Geertz confessed:
Richard Bernstein, “Anthropologist, Retracing Steps After 3 Decades, Is Shocked by Change,”
The New York Times
, May 11, 1988.
173
part-time unpaid cottage-industry workers:
S. Ann Dunham, “Women's Work in Village Industries on Java,” unpublished paper from the 1980s.
175
But Ann intended to expand the concept:
Ann Dunham, “Occupational Multiplicity as a Peasant Strategy,” early draft of dissertation.
176
sounds of forging:
S. Ann Dunham, “Peasant Blacksmithing in Indonesia: Surviving and Thriving Against All Odds,” unpublished dissertation, 1992, 499.
183
One scene of Pak Sastro and his wife:
Ibid., 556â560.
184
“men of Kajar are fated”:
Ibid., 495.
185
“Whenever villagers have a problem”:
Ibid., 533.
185
“There are numerous stories of kerises rattling about”:
Dunham, “Women's Work in Village Industries on Java,” 41.
187
In the acknowledgments:
Dunham, unpublished dissertation, viiâviii.
193
In a haunting scene:
Obama,
Dreams from My Father,
94â96.
CHAPTER SEVEN. COMMUNITY ORGANIZING
The account of Ann's years in Semarang and her work on the Provincial Development Project is based on interviews with Clare Blenkinsop, Alice Dewey, Carl Dutto, Don Flickinger, Bruce Harker, Ann Hawkins, Richard Holloway, Sidney Jones, Dick Patten, Nancy Peluso, John Raintree, Jerry Mark Silverman, Maya Soetoro-Ng, Kadi Warner, and Glen Williams. For the brief history of early credit programs, I also drew on
The Microfinance Revolution: Lessons from Indonesia
by Marguerite S. Robinson and on
Progress with Profits: The Development of Rural Banking in Indonesia
by Richard H. Patten and Jay K. Rosengard. The final paragraph, about the Ford Foundation, is based on documents in the Ford Foundation archives.
209
“they believed that poor village women”:
Letter from Ann Sutoro to Hanna Papanek, July 2, 1981.
211
one-third of the 486 units:
Robinson,
The Microfinance Revolution: Lessons from Indonesia
, 115â118; Patten and Rosengard,
Progress with Profits
, 22â30.
212
providing not only capital but training:
Ibid., 31â35.
215
“Many hours of my childhood”:
Maya Soetoro-Ng, foreword to S. Ann Dunham,
Surviving Against the Odds: Village Industry in Indonesia
, ix.
216
“would be superb”:
Memorandum to the File from Sidney Jones, March 10, 1980, PA 800-0893, Ford Foundation Archives.
CHAPTER EIGHT. THE FOUNDATION
This chapter draws heavily on information from grant files in the Ford Foundation archives. In addition, I had access to some of Ann Sutoro's personal papers, field notes, and correspondence from this period. I've also relied on interviews with Terry Bigalke, Halimah Brugger, Bill Carmichael, Carol Colfer, Bill Collier, Alice Dewey, Michael Dove, Jim Fox, Adrienne Germain, Ann Hawkins, Rens Heringa, Richard Holloway, Kay Ikranagara, Tim Jessup, Sidney Jones, Tom Kessinger, David Korten, Frances Korten, David McCauley, Georgia McCauley, John McGlynn, Paschetta Sarmidi, Adi Sasono, Suzanne Siskel, Maya Soetoro-Ng, Saraswati Sunindyo, Julia Suryakusuma, Frank Thomas, Pete Vayda, Yang Suwan, and Mary Zurbuchen. Some information on the history of the Ford office in Jakarta came from
Celebrating Indonesia: Fifty Years with the Ford Foundation 1953â2003,
published by the Ford Foundation in 2003.
220
“Life in the bubble”:
Interview with Mary Zurbuchen, September 30, 2008.
225
William Carmichael, Ford's vice president:
“Recommendation for Grant Action,” April 18, 1985, PA 800-0893, Ford Foundation Archives, 4â5.
226
Ann wrote in 1981 to Carol Colfer:
Letter from Ann Sutoro to Carol Colfer, February 2, 1981, PA 800-0893, Ford Foundation Archives.
227
“With all this complexity”:
Memorandum to the files from Ann D. Sutoro, November 3, 1981, PA 800-0893, Ford Foundation Archives.
228
“a country of âsmiling' or gentle oppression”:
Memorandum to participants, Delhi Conference on Women's Programming, from Ann Dunham Soetoro, April 18, 1982, PA 809-0878, Ford Foundation Archives.
230
“our best reference on the condition”:
Memorandum to the files from Ann D. Sutoro, March 16, 1984, PA 835-0145, Ford Foundation Archives, 2.
231
“Okay, sport”:
Interview with Sidney Jones, July 1, 2009.
231
“How do you think she felt?”:
Interview with Saraswati Sunindyo, February 17, 2009.
231
“a lonely witness for secular humanism”:
Obama,
Dreams from My Father,
50.
231
her chin trembles:
Ibid., 126.
231
“the unreflective heart of her youth”:
Ibid., 124.
231
“helping women buy a sewing machine”:
Ibid., xi.
253
“looked like a black ball surrounded by a brilliant white light”:
Ward Keeler, “Sharp Rays: Javanese Responses to a Solar Eclipse,”
Indonesia,
46 (October 1988), 91â101.
259
helped shift the government's focus:
Memorandum to the files from Mary S. Zurbuchen, October 29, 1998, PA 800-0893, Ford Foundation Archives, 6.
CHAPTER NINE. “SURVIVING AND THRIVING AGAINST ALL ODDS”
Material in this chapter came from interviews with Jim Boomgard, Alice Dewey, Michael Dove, Ralph Dunham, Ben Finney, Jim Fox, Rens Heringa, Dick Hook, Mary Houghton, John Hunt, Don Johnston, Nina Nayar, Barack Obama, Dick Patten, Sarah Patten, Marguerite Robinson, Sabaruddin, Maya Soetoro-Ng, Garrett and Bronwen Solyom, Eric Stone, Made Suarjana, Julia Suryakusuma, Trisulo, Sonny Trisulo, and Yang Suwan. In connection with Bank Rakyat Indonesia, I spoke with Sulaiman Arif Arianto, Kamardy Arief, Ch. Oktiva Susi E., Cut Indriani, Sriwiyono Joyomartono, Agus Rachmadi, Slamet Riyadi,Tomy Sugianto, Flora Sugondo, and Widayanti and Retno Wijayanti. I also drew on personal papers and field notes of Ann Dunham's, her letters to Dewey and Suryakusuma, her reports to the bank, her unpublished dissertation, and her curriculum vitae.
263
helped make up the difference:
Interview with Maya Soetoro-Ng.
265
“spir. develop (ilmu batin)”:
This appears to refer to spiritual development.
Ilmu batin
is an Indonesian phrase referring to esoteric learning or mysticism.
267
Madelyn would rent a hotel room:
Interview with Adi Sasono, January 22, 2009.
269
first credit project for women and artisan-caste members:
Ann Dunham, curriculum vitae, 1993.
269
In the Punjab:
Dunham, “Peasant Blacksmithing in Indonesia: Surviving and Thriving Against All Odds,” 877â879.
272
“in many ways the most spiritually awakened person”:
Obama,
The Audacity of Hope,
205.
273
Though Ann had been led to believe:
Interviews with Alice Dewey.
274
a rate of 120,000 a month:
James J. Fox, “Banking on the People: The Creation of General Rural Credit in Indonesia,” in Sandy Toussaint and Jim Taylor, eds.,
Applied Anthropology in Australasia
(Perth: University of Western Australia Press, 1999).
276
“probably the single largest and most successful credit program”:
For the history of the microfinance program of Bank Rakyat Indonesia, I have relied on
The Microfinance Revolution,
vol. 2:
Lessons from Indonesia,
by Marguerite S. Robinson; “Banking on the People,” by James J. Fox; and
Progress with Profits: The Development of Rural Banking in Indonesia,
by Richard H. Patten and Jay K. Rosengard. Additional information came from a long interview with Kamardy Arief, the former chief executive officer of Bank Rakyat Indonesia.
277
115,000 loans a month:
James J. Boomgard and Kenneth J. Angell, “Bank Rakyat Indonesia's Unit Desa System: Achievements and Replicability,” in Maria Otero and Elisabeth Rhyne, eds.,
The New World of Microenterprise Finance: Building Healthy Financial Institutions for the Poor
(West Hartford, CT: Kumarian Press, 1994).
277
helped the bank weather the crisis:
Richard H. Patten, Jay K. Rosengard, and Don E. Johnston Jr., “Microfinance Success Amidst Macroeconomic Failure: The Experience of Bank Rakyat Indonesia During the East Asian Crisis,”
World Development,
29, no. 6 (2001), 1057â1069.
277
more than four thousand microbanking outlets:
Interview with Sulaiman Arif Arianto, managing director, Bank Rakyat Indonesia, January 14, 2009.
278
“the finest development worker”:
Interview with Mary Houghton, November 14, 2008.
282
“a little of his magical power had managed to rub off”:
Dunham, unpublished dissertation, 285.
293
“is one of the richest ethnographic studies”:
Michael R. Dove,
Anthropological Quarterly,
83, no. 2 (Spring 2010), 449â454.