Authors: Ariel Schrag
Everyone had also started jobs. Casey was working at a YMCA summer camp and came home each day babbling about how much fun she'd had, demonstrating how a kid named Kelvin had taught all the counselors the Crip Walk, or completely exhausted, tipping like a felled tree, face first onto the futon. “All I want to do is pass out, but I can't stop hearing their screaming voices in my head.”
June had had some trouble finding a job, what with her bull nose ring and shaved head and all. “Fucking homophobes,” she would say, coming back from a failed in-face interview.
“Why don't you just take the nose ring out?” Adam had suggested.
“This is my identity,” June answered, tugging hard on the ring, making Adam wince. “I'm not
removing
my identity for some piece-of-shit jobâI'm a fucking lesbian, and they're gonna have to fucking deal.” Adam hadn't bothered to point out that plenty of lesbians got by being lesbians just fine without bull nose rings.
Eventually, June got a job at a crummy comic book shop where all the employees had labret, philtrum, and other previously unknown facial-part piercings and aggressive tattoos, and the owner paid them five dollars an hour “under the table.”
“Everything about the place is illegal,” June would say, “we make $1.75 under minimum wageâI checked; we never get any breaksâalso illegalâand we have to eat while we're working, but if a customer comes in while we're eating we have to, like, hide our sandwich in the coat check.” Still, all of this was apparently better than removing the nose ring that made her look like a hog.
Ethan still had his job at Film Forumâan art house movie theater in Manhattan. One night they were showing
Touch of Evil
âthis movie Ethan was obsessed withâand he'd invited Casey, June, and Adam and let them all in for free. They'd gotten all the popcorn they wanted, and Ethan had made them foamy chocolate egg creams from the soda fountain. The movie was pretty great tooâone of those that made you feel cool just for watching it. Adam sat next to Ethan in the theater, and every fifteen minutes or so Ethan would go
“uhn”
and punch Adam in the shoulder, like it was just so good he couldn't take it.
It also turned out that Ethan was totally rich. Adam and Casey's family was rich too, but Ethan was
rich
rich. His parents had a trust fund for him that was supposed to be for college, but when Ethan had decided he didn't want to go to college, they'd just let him use the money to move to New York. He wanted to make movies.
Because Adam wasn't eighteen, he needed something that didn't require a work permit. So far, he'd had one job that Casey found for him on a Columbia listserv. The job was stuffing envelopes for a rich artist woman named Mags Mumford, who needed to “remind people that I fucking exist, god damn it.” The job was at Mags Mumford's house on the Upper East Side, and the first time Adam went he had gotten completely lost. Casey had told him to take the green number 4 train to Ninety-Sixth Street, but when they got to Ninety-Sixth, the train just zoomed on past the station and then past the next station, and the next, and before Adam knew it, they were stopped at 125th Street. He'd thought maybe he could just walk back to Ninety-Sixth, but when he got out of the station, he was by some river and there were no white people on the street and he was pretty sure this wasn't anywhere near where Mags Mumford lived. He'd gone back into the station, got on the wrong train again, this time ending up at something called West Farms SquareâEast Tremont Avenue, finally figured out the right train, and showed up at Mags Mumford's apartment an hour and a half late. She didn't even notice. She was on the phone and pointed Adam toward the dining-room table, which was heaped with empty envelopes and shiny cards announcing the words
Mags Mumford.
He was supposed to sit there for six hours and at first felt assaulted by boredom, but as the first half hour turned to an hour, and then the next, the monotonous stuffing and licking ended up lulling him into a pleasant trance. He went back every day for a week, but then Mags Mumford ran out of people to remind and the job was over. He'd made only $275, but it was something, and he still had his savings (from birthdays, Christmas/Hanukkah) to cull from as needed.
Mainly, Adam's favorite thing to do was hang around Ethan, who it turned out did
not
used to be a girl. That Adam had even considered it just made him laugh now. The first week they were all living there, it had obsessed Adam. He kept trying to figure out
how he could tell.
Ethan shaved like a guy, had a flat chest like a guy, sounded like a guy . . . but it was apparently possible to be all those things and still be born a girl. Boy Casey had started coming over to the apartment and liked to go on and on about being “trans”âwhich is what you called it when you were a guy who used to be a girl (and vice versa). Pretty much all Casey and Boy Casey ever talked about was how Boy Casey was trans and how complicated life was because of this. The two of them would lie, intertwined, on the living-room futon, having some variation of this conversation:
Â
BOY CASEY:
“Nobody fucking understands me.”
CASEY:
“I understand you . . .”
BOY CASEY:
“Yeah . . .”
CASEY:
“Nobody fucking understands us.”
Â
And then they'd make out, right there on the futon. It was kind of fucked up. Casey had the biggest room of everyone, but apparently she and Boy Casey just preferred making out where everyone else had to watch.
June, of course, had to pretend as if she
really
liked Boy Casey and was
super
supportive of the relationship. Casey and June talked about Boy Casey nonstop, barely noticing if Adam was in the room too. Which was weird since they could get pretty personal.
Â
CASEY:
“He let me touch him, you know . . . âdown' last night.”
JUNE:
“Really? Has he . . . had bottom surgery, or . . .?”
CASEY:
“No! Most trans guys don't . . . It's too expensive and not even really that good. But you know what the T does to his clit . . .”
JUNE:
“Wait, so that's true?”
CASEY:
“Mmm-hmm.”
Â
Adam wasn't sure what they were talking about half the time, but he was totally fascinated and able to piece together different facts. He'd usually pretend to be engrossed in whatever TV show was on so they would forget about him and really get into the details, but sometimes, if it seemed right, he'd ask a casual question or two. “So, like, how did Boy Casey get to grow a beard and stuff?” Whenever he asked a question like this, Casey would leap at the opportunity to launch into some long, show-offy explanation.
Â
CASEY:
“OK, so the hormone that makes you grow hair on your faceâor one day grow hair on your face, ha-ha!”
ADAM:
“Eat shit.”
CASEY:
“That hormone is tes-tos-ter-one
.”
ADAM:
“Duh.”
CASEY:
“Listen! So you get it naturally in your body, but Boy Casey's body doesn't make it, so he injects it into himself with a syringe.”
ADAM:
“Gross.”
CASEY:
“It's not gross. He's doing what he needs to do to be himself. So, anyway, the testosteroneâTâmakes him grow hair on his face and lowers his voice and makes him lose fat, like, around the butt and hips.”
ADAM:
“Sounds like you need to inject some T.”
Â
Adam didn't ask too many questions, thoughâhe didn't want Casey knowing he actually gave a shit. But how could he not? I mean,
what the hellâ
you could actually transform yourself from a girl into a guy. Adam didn't know what the fuck he'd spent the last few years studying in school when
this
was going on in the world.
One night, when Ethan was out, Adam had decided to just up and ask Casey and June about him. I mean, why not? Casey and June were having a typical gabfest about Boy Casey and whether or not Boy Casey had ever dated another trans guy, when Adam, flipping TV channels, asked in his best verging-on-bored voice: “So, is Ethan, like, trans?” and Casey had answered: “Ethan? No.” And that was that. Adam had felt a flood of warmth for Ethan fill his body. They were brothers, in it together.
Adam tried to hang around the house whenever Ethan was home and would bring up random thingsâ“Do you think this bread is stale?”âbut really he barely knew him. Ethan spent most of his time locked in his room, and there was an understanding that unless it was urgent, you did
not
knock on his door.
Then, one night, it happened.
Casey, Boy Casey, June, and some ugly girl June had found on the Internet were all out on a double date, and Adam and Ethan were alone in the apartment. Adam was watching TV when Ethan poked his head out of his room.
“Hey, can I get your opinion on something?”
“Uh, sure,” said Adam.
Stepping into Ethan's room for the first time was like opening the wardrobe into Narnia. Immediately upon entry the air shifted to clean and cold, the colors relaxed into blues, blacks, and grays. Everything was meticulously organized, rows of DVDs in an as-of-now-unknown-but-certain order, the sheets tucked tightly under the bed. It was hard to believe this room even existed in their apartment. Ethan was fussing with a video program on his giant iMac.
“OK,” said Ethan. “Check out these two sequences and tell me which one you like better.”
Ethan hit
PLAY
. A pretty, dark-haired girl with arched eyebrows was standing in a room, her arms wrapped around herself, staring at the ground. After remaining in that position for about a full minute, the girl brushed a strand of hair out of her eye, looked up at the camera, and said, “I don't want to.” Cut to black.
“Or . . . this,” said Ethan. He clicked
PLAY
on a new file. The exact same video played. Girl staring at the ground. Girl brushing away hair. “I don't want to.” Cut to black.
“Uh, I don't get it,” said Adam. “What's the difference?”
Ethan smiled. “I'm not gonna tell you,” he said. “That's the point. It's not about what's
actually
differentâit's about what you feel. The actual difference is a subtle technical change only film nerds will notice. But for regular people, like you, it's about the
feeling
you get. Which one gave you a better feeling?”
Adam was disappointed Ethan thought of him as a “regular person.” But more than that, he was flattered that he wanted his opinion.
“Uh, the first one,” said Adam. His choice was completely random. They both made him feel exactly the same.
“Awesome,” said Ethan, nodding his head.
“So who's the girl?” asked Adam.
And then Ethan started talking and didn't stop for half an hour straight. The girl was Rachel, and she was the love of his life. They had started dating in high school in Greenwich, Connecticut. He knew, was certain, he would never be able to be with anyone else.
“I know that sounds like dumb kid stuff . . . no offense,” said Ethan, looking at AdamâAdam shook his head, none taken. “But it's true,” Ethan continued. “I just know. It's like she was there while my brain was still developing, and she's part of the way it's structured now. I loved the way she saw. You know how each person sees the world differently?”
Adam nodded, even though he wasn't entirely sure what Ethan was talking about. He just wanted Ethan to keep on talking. Adam was getting this tingly feeling sitting there listening to him, and he didn't want it to go away. It was almost as if Ethan were talking to himself, the way his eyes sort of glazed over as he spoke. But then he'd turn and look straight at Adamâlike he knew Adam was following himâand that Adam
got it.
Ethan went on. “I know it sounds really obvious, like, âOh, people have different personalities, they experience the world in different ways'âbut it's more than that. Imagine how the world actually
looks
to each person. Visually. Physically. It's like this: You know how if you're happy, the street you're walking down can look full of life? The trees glorious and vibrant? The people good and kind? But if you're depressed, the exact same street looks ugly, suddenly all you can see is the trash, the sky is menacing, and the people, grotesque. Our visual worlds are a constantly shifting metaphor for our internal moods. But what about person to person? What about all the time? How do I see the world all the time versus how you see it? The things Rachel would point out . . . I don't wanna repeat them, it doesn't work . . . but her world was beautiful. Mine just felt so bland in comparison. All I wanted to do was live in hers.”
Adam nodded again. He wanted to know how Ethan saw the world. He was positive it was better than the way he saw it.
“That's what I love about movies,” Ethan went on. “Trying to capture all those different viewpoints. Make a movie that literally re-creates someone else's visual world. There's not one world we all live in. There are a billion different worlds overlapping each other. Falling in love is finding the world you want to fuse with your own.”