Carnal Isræl: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture (178 page)

Read Carnal Isræl: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture Online

Authors: Daniel Boyarin

Tags: #Religion, #Judaism, #General

BOOK: Carnal Isræl: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture
7.95Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
< previous page
page_83
next page >
Page 83
but even that no longer obtains for those who stood at Sinai, both male and female and their descendants. As xenophobic as this tradition is, with its implication that those who did not stand at Sinai are still impure, it is not misogynistic.
12
"Woman," in Bible and midrash, is almost never essentialized as something evil and dangerous, as a snare to man.
13
According to the Rabbis, there was no Fall into sexuality in the Garden of Eden. On the rabbinic readings, Adam had had intercourse with Eve from the beginning. Their intercourse is not associated in any way with the snake, the "forbidden fruit," or a Fall or expulsion from the Garden (Anderson 1989 and Pardes 1989). Licit sexuality, the intercourse of married couples, belongs not to the demonic realm of the snake but to the innocent realm of the Garden of Innocence itself. Indeed, according to Genesis Rabba 18:6 (Theodor and Albeck 1965, 168), the snake became inflamed with lust for Eve because he saw Adam and Eve having intercourse with each other, and according to 19:3 (17172), he came and spoke to Eve while Adam was sleeping after having had intercourse with her. This narrative idea is plausibly interpreted as a quotation and reversal of prevailing pre-rabbinic interpretations by which the snake taught Eve and Adam about sex in imitation of the animals, interpretations that assimilate sexuality to the bestial and fallen (Brown 1988, 94 n. 43). This interpretation is in line with my understanding of rabbinic culture as in part a resistance movement to forces within the dominant Hellenistic formation. There is, indeed, explicit evidence of this reversal, for in another passage of the same midrashic text, we are told that the verse "Adam knew Eve his wife" means that he and she
taught the animals [caused them to know] about sex
(20405). The snake is the aggressor. While there is illicit sexuality involved"the snake had intercourse with Eve''it is not female sexuality itself that is identified with the snake, as it was in Philo.
12. Indeed, I am tempted to suggest that the statement by the third-century Palestinian Rabbi Yohanan is in response to the doctrine of Original Sin, as if to say, you believe in it, you have it. Alternatively, it might represent a triumphalist claim on the part of the Rabbi that Pagans are more given to sexual immorality than Jews area fairly frequent rabbinic charge. In support of this latter interpretation is the fact that the Talmud cites Rabbi Yohanan's statement to support a claim by Mar Ukba bar Hamma that Pagans frequent the wives of their neighbors, and when they don't find them, they find an animal and have intercourse with it (Baylonian Talmud Avoda Zara 22b. See also Romans 1).
13. For other views, see Bal 1987. See also Mordechai A. Friedman 1990.
 
< previous page
page_83
next page >
< previous page
page_84
next page >
Page 84
Pandora's Jar in Midrash: Eve as Victim
Although several rabbinic texts (some of which we shall see below) put the blame for the sin and its punishment on the woman, equally as many say the exact opposite. The most interesting of these is a text that is apparently an allusion to the Pandora story of the jar, but it assigns the role of Pandora not to Evebut to Adam. A comparison of the story in Hesiod (the ostensible model or source of our text) with the midrashic story will provide rich material for analysis. The salient elements of the Pandora story as narrated in Hesiod's
Theogony
and
Works and Days
14
are: Zeus becomes angry at Prometheus, whereupon Zeus hides the celestial fire. Prometheus steals fire from Zeus and brings it to men. In order to punish men for having received this illicit gift, Zeus counters with the creation of
anti pyros,
anti-fire, a "beautiful evil," who is a continuous source of harm to men (
pêma mega thnêtoisi
) (
Th.
56191). In
Works and Days
she is called Pandora (All Gifts), because the gods give her gifts to make her a beautiful pitfall and deception to men. "Her beautiful exterior, enhanced by those adornments which in Greek thought are externalized tokens of sexual allure, proves only to be a snare and a delusion" (Zeitlin 1990). Then, reports the
Works and Days,
she is sent to Prometheus's brother Epimetheus (Hindsight), who foolishly accepts her as a gift from Zeus. She opens up the jar of evil, "releasing all the evils and diseases that now silently and invisibly wander over the earth'' (
WD
56104). Only Hope (Elpis) is left behind. Here I will compare the last part of the
Works and Days
version with its midrashic parallel. I will read the Hesiodic original first:
And Epimetheus took no heed of Prometheus's advice not to receive any gift the Olympian Zeus might send him but to reject it lest some evil should happen to mortals. So he received it and learned by experience the evil he had. For the tribes of men had previously lived on the earth free and apart from evils, free from burdensome labor and from painful diseases, the bringers of death to men.
14. There is an entire scholarly literature devoted to the "contradictions" between these two accountstypically for nineteenth-century scholarship, much of it is devoted to proving that one is authentic and the other spuriousbut as Zeitlin remarks, "Although the two versions differ in some important details and are used to serve the differing purposes of each text, . . . they can and have been taken together as forming two halves of a single extended narrative, each providing a gloss on the other" (Zeitlin 1990). My summary, then, is a conflated version.
 
< previous page
page_84
next page >

Other books

At the Heart of the Universe by Samuel Shem, Samuel Shem
Caught Stealing (2004) by Huston, Charlie - Henry Thompson 01
The Triumph of Seeds by Thor Hanson
Clay: Armed and Dangerous by Cheyenne McCray