Forsaken Soul (5 page)

Chapter Eight

Thomas twitched. His eyes opened wide. Had he fallen asleep?

His arms were stretched out in the shape of a cross; his feet were folded on top of each other, all in imitation of the crucified Jesus hanging upon the cross on the altar in front of him.

None of this brought the comfort he longed for, or even the condemnation he expected. All he felt were the sharp edges of the rough, uneven stone floor pressing into his body.

He rose awkwardly and carefully stretched the stiffness from his legs. His arms tingled as they recovered from their numbness. “Might I do better if I went back to the hospital and served the sick?” he asked the twisted figure above him.

After waiting for some response, he shook his head at his obviously vain hope and left the chapel.

Had he truly slept? He asked the question again as he shut the door to the church behind him. If so, the sleep was not restful, images from the inn last night flashing in his mind like a hobby-lantern in the fens. Each time he had breathed deeply, the dead man’s stench assaulted his nostrils, and the figure of trembling Ivetta filled his heart with a troubling, albeit vague, apprehension.

Now that he was awake, however, what bothered him most was a change he had seen in Ralf. Although the pair had worked together in the past, and even called each other
friend
, this was the first time Thomas had noted deliberate callousness in the man. The crowner was harsh with scoundrels, and his rough ways had often caused unintended offense or hurt feelings, but the monk had never seen him act with cruelty to an obviously frightened witness.

The cooper’s death quite literally reeked of murder. Why, then, would Ralf dismiss a good witness like Ivetta with such mockery when he had always sought as much information as he could obtain? Surely he knew that scorn would only silence her? Ivetta might be a prostitute, but the crowner had never cared much about such things, especially when he was in full cry after the truth of a crime. Yet last night he had acted no differently than his brothers might have done, either sheriff or the churchman.

As for Ivetta, she had good reason to assume that any representative of the king’s justice would treat with little kindness those who plied her trade. Her expectation that a crowner would simply cart her off to some dank place, where she might rot of the damp long before she ever came to trial, was not unreasonable. Thomas had expected Ralf to calm her fears, at least long enough to get her tale, even if he suspected her of murder. Instead, he had rained abuse down on her head, effectively stopping any attempt at defense she might make or willingness to give information pointing to a killer.

On the other hand, Ivetta and Ralf had surely known each other from childhood. Thomas had come but recently to Tyndal. Perhaps the crowner had reason to assume her guilt—and maybe she had cause to mistrust him. Whatever the truth, Ralf had been gentler to the innkeeper.

Since the monk had stayed last night to assure the crowd outside the inn that the Devil had been permanently routed back to his home in Hell, Thomas heard the outraged roar from the merchant when he was told that the room upstairs must remain untouched, corpse included, until further notice.

“Do you have any idea how this will affect my purse?” the innkeeper shouted.

In the past, Ralf would have had little patience with anyone who worried more about coin than solving a murder—and taken less care to hide his contempt. Instead, the formerly gruff crowner eased the man into agreement with smooth grace.

Had his friend chosen to learn the delicate skills of diplomacy during his time at court? Or had his nature changed? Was there a side to the man that Thomas had never seen, one that others, who had grown up with him, knew well?

If the crowner did have a part touched by the Devil, why had Tostig remained his devoted friend—or Sister Anne for that matter? The brewer of ale might be called a good man, but the monk believed the sub-infirmarian to be most saintly.

Thomas frowned in perplexed thought as he trudged along the path to the hospital. “None of this is my worry,” he concluded at last. The murder may have sent a spirit to God’s judgement uncleansed, and he might even pray for the cooper’s soul, but the crime itself was a matter for secular justice.

“Nonetheless, I am uneasy,” he whispered, “although I do not understand why.”

Thomas turned and gazed back at the dark-stoned church he had just left. Although the shimmering white sun had not yet reached its zenith, the air was growing thick with damp heat. The black curtain in Sister Juliana’s anchorage window barely moved with the weak sea breeze, and the white cross emblazoned on it almost sparkled in the sunlight.

What was she doing? he wondered, distracting himself from his troubling thoughts. Was she in prayer, or had she sought rest on her stone bed after her night vigil?

Ever since he had met the woman at Wynethorpe Castle, he had felt both attraction and revulsion whenever he was in her presence. These warring emotions were complicated by his inability to decide whether she was simply mad or truly touched by God. Even his astute prioress might have no answer to this debate either, or so he suspected. She and Juliana may have been girlhood friends, but Thomas guessed much had changed between them in the intervening years.

Whatever his opinion of her, Sister Juliana had arrived here in the spring and was permanently entombed as an anchoress. Soon after the last rites were performed to symbolize her death to the world, and the door to her small cell slammed shut, the distressed from the village began arriving at her window.

This was not unusual. Anchoresses often received those tormented by their sins, but they did so primarily during the daylight hours. This anchoress received only at night.

He had learned of this quite early on. When he had grown weary of his nocturnal pacing around the silent walkways of the monks’ cloister garth, Thomas went to the church to beg for comfort. Her anchorage was near the path he took, and he grew much amazed at how many others were rendered sleepless by their sorrows. There was always some shadow pressed against the wall, whispering at the curtain. Once he caught himself concluding with some irreverence that the Church might soon proclaim her the patron saint of the sleepless.

Yet, for all his discomfort with her, he had been tempted to kneel at the window himself and seek what she might advise. Then a dark shape would approach, and he had scurried off to the gloomy chapel. At Wynethorpe, he feared she had glimpsed his soul in all its pitiful nakedness. If that were the case, he wondered what her response would be if he came to that small and curtained opening. Would she offer gentle comfort or call for God’s flaming wraith to scorch his soul? He shook these musings aside with a shiver and turned his thoughts to those who had visited her.

Sister Juliana did not seem to mind if someone came more than once. Thomas had seen the baker’s wife every night for awhile, although not of late. Hadn’t Signy approached her for some reason, and maybe old Tibia as well? And now that he thought more on it, he wondered if he had seen Ivetta at the window too. Tostig had sought her advice, although fewer men than women came to the anchoress’ window.

Why did women seem to come more often than men? Was the cause to be found in their greater mortal frailty? Nay, as he thought more on it, he realized that men were more likely to seek wisdom from pious hermits while women sought out the anchoress’ window. God must not care who gave moral direction as long as souls were saved.

But what could an innkeeper’s niece and a village whore have sought from an anchoress? Ivetta had continued her trade. Her soul was as fouled by lust as it had ever been, so the road to chastity had not been her concern. And what had troubled the innkeeper’s niece? Signy seemed no more sinful than any other woman in the village. On the other hand, the baker’s wife had certainly found some answer because her husband’s bread began to rise again shortly after her visits to Sister Juliana—or so the story went. Perhaps Signy’s woes had more in common with those of the baker’s wife, something to do with stews and ale.

“Ah, well,” Thomas said, entering the hospital courtyard. “I have sins enough of my own with which to struggle. Whatever problems bring Ivetta and Signy to see the anchoress are not mine to solve. It is time I got back to His service.”

But the monk, like any other man, was still nibbled by curiosity. As he started down the rows of straw beds, filled with bodies whimpering in pain and terror, he caught himself asking again why Sister Juliana sat by her curtain only after the sun set. Unlike most mortals, she must be very bold to defy the Prince of Darkness, when he tortured man’s spirit the most, and offer refuge to quivering souls during such bleak hours.

As he recalled his meeting with her, in the swirling snow on the walls of Wynethorpe Castle, he decided Sister Juliana most certainly did have that courage.

Chapter Nine

Sister Anne agreed to visit the inn.

Eleanor chose to accompany her.

When the prioress heard the growing rumor that many had seen Satan swooping about the inn when the cooper was murdered, she decided that an immediate monastic presence was required to calm village fears. Of course, this vigorous foray against the Fiend would not only drive panic away, but it might also free the villagers from thoughts about malign imps and thus send them back to memories or observations that should help find mortal killers.

As a result, when the religious contingent from Tyndal Priory walked to the inn, Sister Anne may have borne her worldly knowledge of herbs and potions, but Prior Andrew carried a large cross.

Eleanor left the good prior downstairs to speak with the fearful and curious while she and her attendants accompanied the sub-infirmarian upstairs with the innkeeper and Ralf. With one hand on the door, she suddenly realized what might be seen in the room behind it and shuddered. Death might mean that a soul had taken flight from earthly ills, but slaughter never brought any spirit delicate wings.

“Stay back by the stairs,” she commanded the two beardless novices beside her.

Except for those cursed with sensitive noses, few noticed the common odors of everyday life, but murder exuded a fetid stench. Even Sister Anne, used to the overly sweet stink of mortal decay, hesitated at the door to the room where Martin’s body lay rotting in the heat.

Both Eleanor and Anne covered mouth and nose with their sleeves before stepping into the room. The innkeeper was willing enough to stay without. Once Ralf had joined them, Eleanor shut the door, deciding that she and Anne were sufficient attendance on the other. “No one else need suffer this,” she said.

Anne stepped over dried excrement and around stains where urine had darkly colored the wooden floor. When she reached Martin’s corpse, her expression grew thoughtful, then sad. She knelt by the body and began her examination, raising the eyelids, opening the mouth, peering in, sniffing, testing limbs for rigidity, and feeling flesh for marks or other signs.

At last she rose, looked about, and walked around the room. After examining excrement and vomit, she went to the table where a jug lay on its side next to an upside-down pottery cup. She bent and looked into the jug but quickly saw it was empty. She sniffed at it, then finally studied the stains left by what had been spilled. Anne frowned and ran her fingers over the dark marks.

“This was most certainly not a natural death, Ralf, a finding you did not need me to make. Clearly Martin suffered convulsions before he died. His pupils are dilated, and his mouth is blue.” She pointed to vomit, smears of excrement, and the table. “You were right to leave everything in place and let me see all this. One thing by itself might mean many things. It is the entirety that points most accurately to a conclusion.”

“A poison?” Ralf asked.

“So I would say.”

“Which one?”

“I suspect yew, but I would like to ask for more detail from any witnesses before I settle on that one in particular. Precision in this could speed discovery of the killer.”

“The only witness was Ivetta, a woman…”

“…who practices a most sinful trade,” Anne finished.

“If you will tell me your questions, I will ask her myself.”

“Surely you questioned her last night,” Anne said. “What did she tell you?”

The crowner’s face turned scarlet.

The prioress raised an eyebrow but said nothing.

“She refused to talk to me, Annie.”

“That has never stopped you before, Ralf.” Anne bent to closely study a rough spot on the table.

“Your offer to protect our virtue is both admirable and kind,” Eleanor said.

Realizing that she was letting him save face, the crowner nodded with a sheepish look.

“As you have said yourself, justice must be served with efficiency,” the prioress continued. “I believe it would be best if Sister Anne asked her the questions directly. If Ivetta’s testimony raises other questions, then our sub-infirmarian can resolve discrepancies immediately. Otherwise, there might be much going back and forth which consumes valuable time.”

“Could you bear to do this?” Ralf asked, looking over at Anne who had returned to communing only with the dead man.

Anne smiled at his question, then nodded at the corpse. “Methinks you should know my answer.”

“Remember that the sainted Magdalene is one of our especial protectors,” Eleanor said. “I am sure she would be pleased if we exposed this poor sinner to the joys of a more prayerful life. I will ask Brother Beorn to accompany Ivetta to the priory. Sister Anne can question her in my presence.”

“I will await your news, my lady,” Ralf said.

“Then let us leave and give back this room to the innkeeper. If the corpse has surrendered all the secrets he ever shall, methinks it is time enough to send the cooper to his grave.”

“I will not argue that!” the crowner said, then swung open the door and immediately took in a deep breath of fresh air.

Chapter Ten

Had she been unwise to volunteer help in this matter of murder, Eleanor asked herself as she hurried along the path to Sister Juliana’s anchorage. Did she not have problems enough of her own, especially with Sister Ruth’s ongoing complaints about the anchoress? As for the revelations about Brother Thomas, she was still unable to force her mind firmly to the dilemma with full reason intact.

She quickly exiled that second thought before tears as traitorous as her monk once again breached the weakened walls of her resolve. The cooper’s murder was easier to contemplate.

Most would argue that this crime was no concern of those enclosed behind monastic walls. They might well be right, but if honest men saw Satan strutting amongst them because of this misdeed, then surely the religious of Tyndal were duty bound to help send him back to Hell.

Besides, Ralf had asked for her aid. Not only was he crowner but he was also her friend, a king’s man who always honored her authority at the priory and had helped her two years ago when she had needed a favor, one that might have caused the crowner much grief had his brother, the sheriff, ever learned of it. She owed him something in return. The least she could do was interview two women.

“A simple enough thing to accomplish compared to what I must do now,” the prioress sighed as she approached the anchorage door. There were times she wished she had never agreed to the admission of Sister Juliana as anchoress at Tyndal. Today was one of them.

The lay sister who had most recently, and even more reluctantly, agreed to serve Tyndal’s recluse stood next to the anchorage entrance. The firmly bolted door was very thick, a precaution suggested by the bishop who had performed the entombing ceremony. Some women had chipped their way out, he said, when this austere life had begun to drive them mad.

Eleanor nodded to the lay sister.

“She often barricades this from the inside, my lady,” the woman said, unbolting the door.

“I sent word that I wished to speak with her.”

The lay sister knocked.

The great door squeaked open.

With head bowed, the woman inside fell to her knees, her hands steepled in an attitude of submissive prayer.

How gaunt Juliana has become since her arrival at Tyndal Priory, Eleanor thought as she stepped into the tiny room. On those occasions, when she had brought Brother John for spiritual advice and discussion, she had asked if anything was needed. The only thing the anchoress ever requested was time for confession.

Although Eleanor knew that any mortal, who vowed to resist all evil, was tormented by Satan with exceptional vigor and vivid temptations, she found herself asking how many lusty imps the Devil could possibly send to a room barely large enough for an altar and small bed.

“You have rejected yet another servant,” the prioress said. “May I know why?” Space for an even smaller servant’s room had been included when the anchorage had been built, but Juliana had refused any resident attendant. Instead she was using the space to dig her future grave in the floor with her bare hands.

“I am sure Sister Ruth has given reasons, my lady.”

“I would hear the cause from you.”

Juliana’s lips twitched into a humorless smile. “I do not wish anyone to attend me.”

“You have no choice in this. Your duty is to pray, seek God’s wisdom, and comfort those who are compelled to seek your advice. Another must cook, clean, and care for you should you fall ill.”

“When I begged an anchorage, I asked to be granted a forest hut where I could tend to my own needs. There, apart from all other mortals, I would have had the silence to hear God’s voice even while I tended to those few vegetables needed for my daily meal.”

“That was rightly denied by the bishop. No woman may be granted a hermitage.”

“Then permit my only other request.”

Eleanor threw up her hands in frustration. “As you should know well, I shall not assign a monk or lay brother to care for you!”

“I cannot pray with women in my room.”

“You could not pray if a man was left alone with you! How dare you even ask that I permit such a thing?”

“What if I told you that God demanded it?”

“You cannot, for He would not.”

“As Brother John told me, Robert of Arbrissel went to brothels. When he emerged, he did so cloaked in greater virtue than when he entered. I do not ask that a manservant enter my room, only that he serve my needs through that tiny space.” She pointed to a small opening in the wall that provided a view of the church itself.

The prioress went to the curtained window in the other wall and glanced outside. No one was there to hear what she had to say. “As you should understand, your demand is outrageous. Why not permit a sober, modest, and elderly woman to perform the same service?” She gestured at the empty servant’s room. “You have always refused to allow anyone to stay there. What quarrel do you have with someone who lives without?”

“As I told you long ago, apart from your own, I cannot abide the sound of a woman’s voice. I would not speak to those who come to my window if God did not command it as atonement for my sins.”

“Not even the voice of Sister Anne who has had to come often enough to treat your wounds when you beat your head against the wall?”

The anchoress bowed her concession in silence.

“Juliana, you are taking advantage of our friendship in the world by continuing to insist on such a shameful thing. No prioress, or prior in any other double house, would listen more than once to such a proposition. If they were merciful, they would set you a severe penance. Most would conclude you were possessed by Satan. I would prefer to do neither. If I continue to hear complaints, however, I may have little choice except to take harsh measures to end them.”

“I have never wished to couple with any man. As you know, I did not have to take a nun’s vows to become an anchoress. I chose to do so, and my vow to remain chaste is a true one.”

Eleanor spun around. “I may believe that, although many would not. Even if your chastity remained inviolate, you must understand that such an arrangement would be a cruel test of any man’s vows?”

“There are those who would either welcome it as a test of their virtue or else not find it troubling at all.” Juliana flattened herself on the floor. “My lady,” she whispered, “you know me well. Believe me when I swear my plea has no taint of wickedness.”

“I might indeed,” the prioress sighed as she took her childhood friend by the arms and raised her. “That said, there is another reason to deny your plea. The sons of Adam rarely allow the daughters of Eve authority, for it was our ancient mother who took the apple from the serpent, offered it to Adam, and gave God cause to slam shut the gates of Eden. Men need little to remind them that tragedy results when women are not closely ruled; therefore, the virtue of our Order, where Eve has power over Adam, must remain undoubted. Even if I wished to do so, I could never grant your request.”

The anchoress’ eyes turned dark.

“I promise that I shall persist in searching for a woman who will serve you with the silence you require and who will not otherwise trouble you. In the meantime, the current lay sister will continue attending to your needs twice a day, and I command you to cease barring your door to her.”

Juliana covered her eyes and groaned.

“As you said, you willingly took a nun’s vows. Need I remind you that one of those was obedience? Do not attempt to take any further advantage of our old friendship. Not only do I command you to stop begging me to grant this wicked plea, but I order you to treat all women who serve you with the sweet kindness Our Lord embodied.”

The anchoress bowed her head but remained silent.

“On the other hand, I must ask if any of these women has done you harm? If so, tell me for I shall not tolerate that.”

“Their only vice lies in their sex, my lady.”

“Then you owe them the compassion God grants all women, for you share their frailty.”

“I shall obey, my lady,” Juliana whispered.

“There is one other matter.”

“I beg that you teach me all my sins.”

“The visitors to your window. They are mostly women and come only at night, when they should be safe in their beds. It is the hour the Devil loves most…”

“No one at my window has been attacked by imps, my lady. If God had not taken away what desire I might have for sleep, these mortals would have no one to bring His balm to their battered souls. Show me the possessed, if I speak with the Fiend’s tongue. That is how I answer those critics who wish to cover innocence with the stench of their own filth.”

For a long time, Eleanor studied the bent figure of her old friend, then blessed the woman and left without speaking further.

The door slammed shut. The bolt was drawn.

Sister Juliana remained on her knees, staring in silence at that heavy wooden door which had failed to protect her from the world she hated.