Labyrinth (10 page)

“It is my fervent hope,” Trencavel continued, “that the tournament and feast will go ahead at the end of this month as planned. However, today we have received information that is so serious and with such far-reaching consequences, that I believe it right to share it with you. For it affects us all.

“For the benefit of those not present at our last Council, let me remind you all of how the situation stands. Frustrated by the failure of his legates and preachers to convert the free people of this land to show obedience to the Church of Rome, at Easter one year ago, His Holiness Pope Innocent III preached a Crusade to rid Christendom of what he called the ”cancer of heresy‘ spreading unchecked through the lands of the Pays d’Oc.

“The so-called heretics, the
Bons Homes,
were, he claimed, worse than the very Saracens. However, his words, for all their passion and rhetoric, fell on deaf ears. The King of France was unmoved. Support was slow to come.

“The target of his venom was my uncle, Raymond VI, Count of Toulouse. Indeed, it was the intemperate actions of my uncle’s men—who were implicated in the murder of the papal legate, Peter de Castelnau— that caused His Holiness to turn his eye on the Pays d’Oc in the first instance. My uncle was indicted on a charge of tolerating the spread of heresy in his lands and—by implication—ours.” Trencavel hesitated, then corrected himself. “No, not of tolerating heresy, but of
encouraging
the
Bons Homes
to seek a home within his domains.”

A fiercely ascetic-looking monk standing near the front raised his hand, seeking permission to speak.

“Holy brother,” said Trencavel swiftly, “if I may beg your patience a while longer. When I have finished what I have to say, then all will have their chance. The time for debate will come.”

Scowling, the monk let his arm fall back.

“The line between tolerance and encouragement, my friends, is a fine one,” he continued softly. Pelletier nodded to himself, silently applauding Trencavel’s astute handling of the situation. “So, whilst I freely acknowledged that my esteemed uncle’s reputation for piety is not what it might be—” Trencavel paused, drawing them into the implied criticism, “and whilst I also accept that his behavior is hardly above reproach, it is not for us to judge the rights and wrongs of the matter.” He smiled. “Let the priests argue theology and leave the rest of us in peace.”

He paused. A shadow fell across his face. Now, there was no light left in his voice.

“This was not the first time the independence and sovereignty of our lands had been threatened by invaders from the north. I did not think anything would come of it. I could not believe that Christian blood would be spilled on Christian soil with the blessing of the Catholic Church.

“My uncle Toulouse did not share my optimism. From the start, he believed the threat of invasion was real. To protect his lands and sovereignty, he offered us an alliance. What I said to him, you will remember: that we, the people of the Pays d’Oc, live in peace with our neighbors, be they
Bons Homes,
Jews, even Saracens. If they uphold our laws, if they respect our ways and our traditions, then they are of our people. That was my answer then.” He paused. “And it would be my answer still.”

Pelletier nodded his approval at these words, watching as a wave of agreement spread through the Great Hall, sweeping up even the bishops and the priests. Only the same solitary monk, a Dominican from the color of his habit, was unmoved. “We have a different interpretation of tolerance,” he muttered in his strong, Spanish accent.

From farther back, another voice rang out.

“Messire,
forgive me, but all this we know. This is old news. What of now? Why are we called to Council?”

Pelletier recognized the arrogant, lazy tones of the most troublesome of Berenger de Massabracs five sons, and would have intervened had he not felt the viscount’s hand on his arm.

“Thierry de Massabrac,” said Trencavel, his voice deceptively benign, “we are grateful for your question. However, some of us here are less familiar with the complicated path of diplomacy than you.”

Several men laughed and Thierry flushed.

“But you are right to ask. I have called you here today because the situation has changed.”

Although nobody spoke, the atmosphere within the hall shifted. If the viscount was aware of the tightening of tension, he gave no indication of it, Pelletier was pleased to note, but continued to speak with the same easy confidence and authority.

“This morning we received news that the threat from the northern army is both more significant—and more immediate—than we previously thought. The Host—as this unholy army is calling itself—mustered in Lyon on the feast day of John the Baptist. Our estimate is that as many as twenty thousand
chevaliers
swamped the city, accompanied by who knows how many thousand more sappers, priests, osders, carpenters, clerics, farriers. The Host departed Lyon with that white wolf, Arnald-Amalric, the Abbot of Citeaux, at its head.” He paused and looked around the hall. “I know it is a name that will strike like iron in the hearts of many of you.” Pelletier saw older statesmen nodding. “With him are the Catholic Archbishops of Reims, Sens and Rouen, as well as the Bishops of Autun, Clermont, Nevers, Bayeux, Chartres and Lisieux. As for the temporal leadership, although King Philip of France has not heeded the call to arms, nor allowed his son to go in his stead, many of the most powerful barons and principalities of the north have done so. Congost, if you please.”

At the sound of his name, the
escrivan
ostentatiously put down his quill. His lank hair fell across his face. His skin, white and spongy, was almost translucent from a lifetime spent inside. Congost made great play of reaching down into his large leather bag and pulling out a roll of parchment. It seemed to have a life of its own in his sweaty hands.

“Get on with it, man,” Pelletier muttered under his breath.

Congost puffed out his chest and cleared his throat several times, before finally beginning to read.

“Eudes, Duke of Burgundy; Herve, Count of Nevers; the Count of Saint-Pol; the Count of Auvergne; Pierre d’Auxerre; Herve de Geneve; Guy d’Evreux; Gaucher de Chatillon; Simon de Montfort…”

Congost’s voice was shrill and expressionless, yet each name seemed to fall like a stone into a dry well, reverberating through the hall. These were powerful enemies, influential barons of the north and east with resources, money and men at their disposal. They were opponents to be feared, not dismissed.

Little by little, the size and nature of the army massing against the south took shape. Even Pelletier, who had read the list for himself, felt dread shiver down his spine.

There was a low, steady rumble in the hall now: surprise, disbelief and anger. Pelletier picked out the Cathar bishop of Carcassonne. He was listening intently, his face expressionless, with several leading Cathar priests—
parfaits
—by his side. Next, his sharp eyes found the pinched, hooded features of Berenger de Rochefort, the Catholic bishop of Carcassonne, standing on the opposite side of the Great Hall with his arms folded, flanked by priests from the cathedral church of Sant-Nasari and others from Sant-Cernin.

Pelletier was confident that, for the time being at least, de Rochefort would maintain allegiance to Viscount Trencavel rather than to the Pope. But how long would that last? A man with divided loyalties was not to be trusted. He would change sides as surely as the sun rose in the east and set in the west. Not for the first time, Pelletier wondered if it would be wise to dismiss the churchmen now, so that they could hear nothing they might feel obliged to report to their masters.

“We can stand against them, however many,” came a shout from the back. “Carcassona is impregnable!” Others started to call out too. “So is Lastours!” Soon there were voices coming from every corner of the Great Hall, echoing off every surface like thunder caught in the gulleys and valleys of the Montagne Noire. “Let them come to the hills,” shouted another. “We’ll show them what it means to fight.”

Raising his hand, Raymond-Roger acknowledged the display of support with a smile.

“My lords, my friends,” he said, almost shouting to make himself heard. “Thanks for your courage, for your steadfast loyalty.” He paused, waiting for the noise level to fall back. “These men of the north owe no allegiance to us, nor do we owe allegiance to them, except for that which binds all men on this earth under God. However, I did not expect betrayal by one who is bound by all ties of obligation, family and duty to protect our lands and people. I speak of my uncle and liege lord, Raymond, Count of Toulouse.”

A hushed silence descended over the assembled company.

“Some weeks ago, I received reports that my uncle had submitted himself to a ritual of such humiliation that it shames me to speak of it. I sought verification of these rumors. They were true. At the great cathedral church of Sant-Gilles, in the presence of the papal legate, the count of Toulouse was received back into the arms of the Catholic Church. He was stripped to the waist and, wearing the cord of a penitent around his neck, he was scourged by the priests as he crawled on his knees to beg forgiveness.”

Trencavel paused a moment, to allow his words to sink in.

“Through this vile abasement, he was received back into the arms of the Holy Mother Church.” A murmur of contempt spread through the Council. “Yet there is more, my friends. I have no doubt that his ignominious display was intended to prove the strength of his faith and his opposition to the heresy. However, it seems even this was not enough to avert the danger he knew was coming. He has surrendered control of his dominions to the legates of His Holiness the Pope. What I learned today—” He paused. “Today I learned that Raymond, Count of Toulouse, is in Valence, less than a week’s march away, with several hundred of his men. He waits only for word to lead the northern invaders across the river at Beaucaire and into our lands.” He paused. “He has taken the Crusaders’ cross. My lords, he intends to march against us.”

Finally, the hall erupted in howls of outrage.
“Silenci”
Pelletier bellowed until his throat was hoarse, vainly trying to restore order to chaos. “Silence. Pray, silence!”

It was an unequal battle, one voice against so many.

The viscount stepped forward to the edge of the dais, positioning himself directly beneath the Trencavel coat of arms. His cheeks were flushed, but the battle light shone in his eyes and defiance and courage radiated from his face. He spread his arms wide, as if to embrace the chamber and all those within it. The gesture hushed all.

“So I stand here before you now, my friends and allies, in the ancient spirit of honor and allegiance that binds each of us to our brothers, to seek your good counsel. We, the men of the Midi, have only two paths left open to us and very little time to choose which to take. The question is this.
Per Carcassona!”
For Carcassonne.
“Per lo Miegjorn.”
For the lands of the Midi. “Must we submit? Or shall we fight?”

As Trencavel sat back in his chair, exhausted by his efforts, the noise levels in the Great Hall billowed around him.

Pelletier could not help himself. He bent forward and put his hand on the young man’s shoulder.

“Well spoken,
Messire
,” he said quietly. “Most nobly done, my lord.”

CHAPTER 7

For hour upon hour, the debate raged.

Servants scuttled to and fro, fetching baskets of bread and grapes, platters of meat and white cheese, endlessly filling and refilling the great jugs of wine. Nobody ate much, but they did drink, which fired their anger and dimmed their judgment.

The world outside the Chateau Comtal went on just the same. The bells of the churches marked the devotional hours of the day. The monks sang and the nuns prayed, cocooned within Sant-Nasari. In the streets of Carcassonne, the townspeople went about their business. In the suburbs and dwellings beyond the fortified walls, children played, women worked, merchants and peasants and guildsmen ate and talked and played dice.

Inside the Great Hall, reasoned argument started to give way to insults, recriminations. One faction wanted to stand firm. The other argued in favor of an alliance with the count of Toulouse, arguing that if estimates of the size of the army mustered at Lyon were accurate, then even their combined strength was not sufficient to withstand such an enemy.

Every man could hear the drums of war beating in his head. Some imagined honor and glory on the battlefield, the clash of steel on steel. Others saw blood covering the hills and the plains, an endless stream of the dispossessed and wounded stumbling defeated across the burning land.

Pelletier tirelessly wandered up and down the chamber, looking for signs of dissent or opposition or challenges to the viscount’s authority. Nothing he observed gave him real cause for concern. He was confident that his
seigneur
had done enough to bind all to him and that, regardless of individual interests, the lords of the Pays d’Oc would unite behind Viscount Trencavel, whatever decision he reached.

The battle lines were drawn on geographical rather than ideological grounds. Those whose lands were on the more vulnerable plains wanted to put their faith in the power of talk. Those whose dominions lay in the highlands of the Montagne Noire to the north or the mountains of the Sabarthes and the Pyrenees were determined to stand firm against the Host and fight. Pelletier knew that it was with them that Viscount Trencavel’s heart lay. He was cast from the same metal as the mountain lords and shared their fierce independence of spirit.

But Pelletier knew too that Trencavel’s head told him that the only chance of keeping his lands intact and protecting his people was to swallow his pride and negotiate.

By late afternoon, the chamber smelled of frustration and arguments gone stale. Pelletier was weary. He was worn out by picking over the bones, by all the fine phrases that turned round and round upon themselves without ever reaching an end. Now, his head was hurting too. He felt stiff and old, too old for this, he thought, as he turned the ring he wore always on his thumb, reddening the callused skin underneath.