Authors: Anton Myrer
The industrialist glanced at him savagely, twisting his neck inside his collar; but he volunteered nothing more. “I don't think my loyalty needs to be questioned here,” Damon went on. “I don't think anyone will. I have served my country in fair weather and foul for forty-three years, and that is a good deal more than you can say, Mr. Beemis. But I can respect the patriotism of men from other landsâwho are every bit as loyal and self-sacrificing and earnest as we are ourselves. They do not happen to believe what we believe; but have we been given some irrefutable proof that our way is the
only
way for all the rest of the world?âa world that is not as much in awe of us as we'd like to think. Not nearly as respectful and friendly toward us as it was fifteen short years ago ⦔
“Samuel,” Massengale said in the icy, menacing tone he remembered, “if you find that you shrink from the necessary meansâ”
“Yes, I shrink from them,” he answered, and now he could not keep the heat out of his voice. “I shrink from them ⦔
“That isn't the way you operated on New Guinea,” Brokaw observed with a quick sardonic laugh. “I read Marv Randall's columnâhe said there wasn't anything in the book or out of it you wouldn't pull ⦔
Randall: yes, he would read Randall like holy writ. Beemis and Brokaw. God, they ought to be a vaudeville act. “Yes: once you are in battle all means are at hand. Who is going to debate niceties of design, degrees of ferocity then? Flamethrowers, napalm, phosphorus, crossbows, poisoned stakes, shu-minesâdon't expect men caught in the desperate straits of war, crushed with a thousand hellish decisions, to resort to Marquis of Queensberry tactics then, Mr. Brokaw. Once that word is saidâthat one, final, utterly irrecoverable wordâthen there is no turning back: the wraps are off, the game is on, all manner of deviltry is unleashed ⦠And so I shrink from the saying of that word. Yes.
I know everything it means.
” He turned and faced the Undersecretary, whose face now showed a marked agitation. Damon suddenly remembered he had been a communications officer with the Fifth Army in Italy. Very softly he asked: “Do you want to be the one to say that word, sir?”
The Undersecretary pulled feverishly at one drooping wing of his mustache. “That's not for me to do,” he said in some confusion. “You must realize that. Of course I can recommend certain courses of action ⦔
“This is getting us exactly nowhere at all,” Beemis came in hotly. “Talk about prima donnas! You figure you're too good for it all, Damon, is that it? Look, we've all got a job to do. Mine is to run Competrin. Yours is to carry out what's been decided.”
“Correction,” Damon retorted. “My job is to give advice. I'm giving it.”
“Samuel.” Massengale was chewing on his jade holder, waggling it up and down rapidly between his teeth. “Are you trying to advance the theory that Communist China is
not
an enemy of the United States?”
He looked back levelly, his chin on his thumb. All these years: ever since St. Durance, in the blood-red sunlight, by the well. Ever since Dormer, when Tommy had danced with him, and over Irene Keller's shoulder he could see her lovely little face flushed with excitementâand watching, he had felt suddenly afraid. Here Massengale was still, brandishing the authority, the charm, the verbal facility, the astonishing intellectual prowess like some jeweled sword. He would always be there: he would always be in command.
But it didn't matter. This crazy, trumped-up assault on the Chinese mainland, using Chiang's demoralized, superannuated, tatterdemalion army wasn't for the good of the service, or the country, or the world.
“I don't know, General,” he said quietly. “It's so hard to keep abreast of things. Back in 1950 you and Bliss and Mr. Beemis here were all telling us the Soviet Union was the real enemyâyou were calling for war with them, predicting the terrible disasters that would befall us if we didn't bomb Moscow. We didn't take your advice; and the disasters didn't take place. Now you tell me that
China
is the real enemy, the blackhearted aggressor we must battle, right down to the last GI ⦠” He glanced around the ring of faces, letting the scorn show in his eyes. “What a pity, gentlemen, if we had all of us died in a preventive war against the Russians in 1951âa war that obviously didn't need to take place at all! ⦠”
They were all silent: he was a magnet, drawing their hatred toward him, polarizing them all. But none of them spoke. What was it Tommy had always said: “Nobody can say no to you, Sam ⦔ A kind of loving despair in her voice as she said it. Well, so be it, then. He would make one more try.
“Sir,” he turned to the Undersecretary, “I beg you to reconsider all of this most carefully. This venture General Massengale is proposing will not prosper; it will undo us. Taipei will use us coolly for their own purposes, the Chinese will fight skillfully and bravely. We will be drawn into a sea of sacrifice and blood: two divisions, ten divisions, forty divisions and what will be gained? There will be no end to it, and we will wither away like the Japanese in the great Hwang Ho Valley ⦠This is not a heaven-sent opportunity: it is a siren song. It is still, as a very fine soldier said some years ago, the wrong war in the wrong place at the wrong time. It will be the greatest catastrophe our country has ever known.”
He sat back and locked his fingers at the edge of the table, and looked at the others. Some avoided his eye, others glowered at him. Massengale smiledâthough Damon knew it was not a smile at allâand said:
“Have you finished your peroration, Samuel?”
“Yes,” he said, “I've finished.”
They went on talking about strategic hamlets, economic reforms, the problems of security in Cau Luong. He stared at the blank pad in front of him, and drew a circle, and inside it a square, and inside it a circle, and inside it a square; and surrounded the figure with a crazy scrawl of concertina wire. Swan song. Famous last words. Well, at least he'd had them. He would be recalled now, without fanfare: a rather dim, dull ending, his only souvenir a galloping case of gastroenteritis, now fortunately more or less under control. Only the Undersecretary's face was unmarked by anger or resentment; the narrow-set gray eyes were pensive, absorbed. His glance rose thoughtfully once to Damon's, slipped away.
Well: he was tired. He was too old for all this Jungle Jim jazz, as Tony Giandoli put it. He'd had his day in court and to hell with them: let them whip up their artful, murderous little folly. It was time to go home, anyway.
In the center of the monotonous colophon he placed a tiny five-pointed star.
“It was quite
bad,” the Undersecretary said. “Really quite bad.” He raised the white linen handkerchief to his mustache and patted it gently. “The whole front of the building was smashed in. They had them laid out on the street outside. Nine dead, eighty-four injured. Weren't those the figures, Gil?”
“Yes, sir,” one of his assistants answered quickly. “But they said they hadn't finished digging out.”
“It's amazing what two hundred pounds of plastique can do,” Massengale observed, looking off at the trees at the edge of the pool, drooping now in the still heat of noon. “Amazing and shocking. When it's in the wrong hands.”
“Isn't it possible to set up tighter security measures?” the Undersecretary asked, with a trace of irritation. “We talked about that at the conference Tuesday, I know.” The dawn bombing of the Rigord, which he had passed on his way in from the airport, had apparently shaken him up a good deal. Massengale could imagine the scene readily enough: the fine white French colonial facade pocked and blackened, the wailing ambulances, the medics groping around in the rubble, the heaps of pulverized glass that gritted savagely underfoot, the supine figures, the blood. All this in the soft rose-and-lavender light.
“We've increased guards and set up new posts in various places,” he answered, “and we've taken various other security precautions. But three or four members of a Hai Minh suicide club bent on taking out a restaurant or hotel are pretty hard to stop. With fanaticism of that caliber there's not an awful lot one can do. We're still here in what's little more than an advisory capacity. If we were here in force, with the corresponding authority ⦔
He let the phrase hang in the air and signaled to Phat to bring them all another round. It would be good to let the air clear a little. Graulet was on tenterhooks and he threw him a covert, forbidding glance. Overanxiety was the death of the diplomatic process. There was some inconsequential small talk and then Massengale asked lightly, “And what was the decision about our little Chinese excursion?” although he sensed what the answer would be.
“⦠The decision was no.” The Undersecretary seemed oddly apologetic. “The Secretary felt it would involve us in a greater commitment than we could sustain at this time. The current thinking is that Russia and China are at present nonimminent enemies, and that it would be ill advised to bring one or both of them in as active belligerents, particularly with regard to an operation involving so many intangibles.” The Undersecretary paused thoughtfully. “Actually it's considered more important at the moment to negotiate with General Hoanh-Trac and secure his support, if we can. Our government will support a UN resolution to expedite the removal of the Chinese Nationalist divisions.” The Undersecretary seemed still more apologetic. “In point of fact I've been instructed to pick Damon up at Pnom Du and fly on up to Plei Hoaâor as near as we can get to Plei Hoaâto confer with Hoanh-Trac tomorrow.”
Massengale studied the end of his jade holder intently for a moment. So there it was. Fantastic. That bastard Damon. They were going to pass up a crystal opportunity like this because that sanctimonious old woman had started invoking doom and destruction. Disgusting! He puffed swiftly at his cigarette, sent smoke swirling around him.
“The Generalissimo will take a very grave view of that,” he permitted himself to say.
“I know.” The Undersecretary smiled ruefully. “So did Vu Khoi. I've just spent most of the morning squaring it with him.” He set down his drink and leaned forward. “I hope you won't be put out at not being brought in on these negotiations, Courtney. It was felt that yourâuh, concern for the Generalissimo's position might militate against a favorable settlement.”
“I quite understand.” That was that. It was out. That filthy swine Damon. Rusticating away nicely in Carmel and then dropping in here out of the blue and wrecking everything, in one stupid swipe.
Everything.
And so they were going to knuckle under to the milksops and mollycoddles in the Administration. The idiots! A priceless chance to put Chiang back on the mainland, throw the Communists off balance, seal off Indochina in toto. What the devil did it matter if that simpering little monkey was or was not drifting into the hands of the Reds? Tell the world he
was
one, and let him worry about it. If they were to mount an attack in force he'd see the light soon enough, never fear. But noâthey were all wound up in scruples and panics over that damned bomb. God, what a red herring. What earthly difference did it make? In war, as in diplomacy, you used what means would accomplish your purposes. But they were scared witless of the namby-pamby liberals, the ADA types who read the
New Republic
and the
Nation,
who wanted to integrate schools and worship the Negroes andâ
But that Damon should have done this! That stolid, quixotic, stubborn numbskull â¦
Never kick over the pail: you might need the milk for breakfast yourself.
Uncle Schuyler's line: nice and folksy. Well, he was probably right at that. Perhaps something could still be salvaged. It was possible: it was always possible.
He suppressed his rage without a tremor. “Well,” he said, and gave a regretful smile, “that's it, then. I won't pretend I'm delightedâyou know me better than that.”
“I realize how much confidence you had in the plan.”
“In point of fact I'm a touch mortifiedâI've always looked on myself as a rather persuasive type. But Damon seems to have put me in the shade ⦔
The Undersecretary twisted in his chair. “Well, the decision was necessarilyâand quite properlyâthe Secretary's, of course.”
“Of course. But I imagine the phrasing of the report had something to do with it, too.”
Had he gone too far? The Undersecretary's glance was filled with resentful candorâthe sixth-form boy accused of coming unprepared to recitation. “I think I can say it was a substantially impartial report, General,” he said a bit stiffly.
Massengale laughed and nodded. “I'm sure it was. See it as the measure of my confidenceâI was so certain this plan of mine would solve so many problems for us. At one blow. Well, opportunity once forsaken is opportunity lost forever, as the adage goes.” The Undersecretary looked mollified, and a bit guilty. “Of course this will place Competrin in a very serious situation.”
“There's a good deal of concern over that.”
“I earnestly hope so. The rate of infiltration from the north is increasing alarminglyâhave you talked to Brokaw?”
The Undersecretary nodded. “There's a good deal of discussion going on about that now. If the negotiations with Hoanh-Trac fail to accomplish the desired results, there is every indication we will increase our troop commitment in Khotiane.”
“I see.”
“We may in any event. But we certainly will if HoanhTrac proves difficult.”
Something could be salvaged, then. Yes, there was always the chance: it only needed the timing, the wit to find and exploit the moment.
He rose nimbly and threw open his hands. “Come and have lunch with us and we can go into things further.”
The Undersecretary looked at his watch. “Oh, I can't, Courtney. I'd like to. I've arranged to meet Damon at Pnom Du at four.”
“Ah, but you must⦔ Massengale put his hand on the younger man's arm. “I've laid on a delightful little lunch for you. Nothing elaborate, but I want to show off my chefâhe's first rate, really. It'll be a lot more convenable than some catch-as-catch-can mouthful at the Splendide, or the Rigord. But nobody will be eating at the Rigord for quite a while, I suppose.” He paused. “Have you had the drippy tummy yet?”
The Undersecretary, still thinking of the Rigord, shook his head somberly.
“You don't want to get it. Does he, Stuart?”
“No, sir,” Graulet said with a grin, “he certainly doesn't.”
“Say you'll join us,” Massengale went on, his hand under his guest's arm, easing him toward the dining room. “You can leave whenever you like. It's the least you can do after dashing all my hopes so cruelly⦔ Subtly he changed tone. “And you really ought to let me give you a quick briefing on the Night Clerk, since you're going up into the wilds with him. We're old comrades-in-arms, you know.”
There: that had iced it. When all else failed, one had only to proffer powerâor knowledge, which was power. The Undersecretary had paused in surprise. “Oh, did he serve with you, Courtney?”
“Oh my, yes. Indeed he did. Indeed he did.âSit over there, won't you? I want you to have the view of the Bay. I must apologizeâmy domestic ménage has been rather informal since my wife passed on.”
He indicated places for the Undersecretary's two assistants, nodded to Graulet and seated himself, and rang for Phat. Cau Luong was what he had sought and not found in the Islands. The Bay swept away in a pretty little circle of the purest white sand, and the trees were feathery and towering, the most plangent green against the blues of sea and sky; the fine resort buildings of the French occupationâthe Cham Bau section of Cau Luong had been a playground for the Parisian planters and bankersâgleamed like alabaster in the still, flat air: festive, exotic, beguiling. Massengale's suite was at the top of the old Dauphinâhe was far too wise to use the Palace for anything but his working headquartersâand possessed a stout, imperturbable Khotianese chef who was a Cordon Bleu graduate and whose cuisine Massengale could not fault; a Borzoi named Alexander; and a Khotianese girl named Tuyet, who kept to her own quarters on occasions such as this. The apartment was completely air-conditioned: he'd had some of his choicer pieces of furniture and much of his library shipped out from the States. But it was the French heritage that delighted him about Cau Luong: a charming little Gallic island in the farouche Indochina sea. One evening, sitting before the great window, brandy glass in one hand, watching the fishing chulucs drifting toward the harbor like frail caravels discovering a continent, while the sky exploded in flamboyant streaks and whorls of vermilion and amethyst and ultramarine and the sea sank rapidly toward infinity, he was surprised to discover that he almost didn't want to go home. Almost â¦
“The thing you want to bear in mind with Samuel is that he's a mustang,” he was saying, between spoonfuls of an excellent caviar madrilene. “He went in as a private, and he was a buck sergeant at the Marne. Old Caldwell, his father-in-law, got him a field commission. This set the pattern for the early part of his career, and dominated his attitudes: he's always been an EM at heart. He was forever in and out of hot water between the warsâon the cliff-hanging edge of insubordination half a dozen times: highly unorthodox positions balanced by that astonishing combat record. Don't misunderstand meâhe was a splendid field commander. First rate. He served under me in the Visayas and on Luzon, and as Graulet can tell you, incompetent line officers in my command don't last very long. But like most strictly combat types he lacks political savoir faire.”
He took a sip of wine. “Alas, it's not Bernkasteler Doktor, but it will have to suffice.”
“It's extraordinarily good,” the Undersecretary murmured.
“It's a pleasant little Moselle and that's about all you can say.âThat brings us to the second stage,” he went on, “and it's the only part of Samuel's life I can't figure out precisely.” He paused and raised his spoonâsomething he never did. Graulet was watching him in astonishment and it amused him. “Something happened to Samuel on that China tour. I never found out what it was, and I should be surprised if anyone else did. It was nothing so trivial as a womanâSamuel never looked at another woman, not in
those
daysâand it wasn't simply that he contracted trachoma and some undiagnosable fever, and had a couple of bad brushes with Japanese patrols. But he came back another manâchanged utterly.”
“In what way?” the Undersecretary asked with interest.
“It's hard to put simply.” He was in his element now. Things could always be retrieved, where there was the requisite skill and imagination. He said: “He seemed to haveâlost his sense of proportion. His awareness of how things work. The art of the possible, as the worn old phrase goes. I don't know how to put it better. It just didn't seem to have any meaning for him anymore. Oh, a smart psychoanalyst would call it anxiety neurosis or incipient paranoia or God knows what evacuation tagâand he'd be right, as far as he went. Though to tell the truth I don't think it was anything more or less than an early onset of the male climacteric. This malady seems to hit army people earlier than their civilian counterparts. I've often wondered why that isâthe isolation perhaps, or maybe the incessant drain on the adrenalin. I suppose there are physiological reasons galore. I've been brushed by it myself: a mountainous weariness laced with a trembling, almost tearful exasperationâthen it passes nearly as quickly as a yawn. And usually the problem resolves itself fairly readily: you catch your wind, so to speak, and go on.”
Phat had served with unobtrusive deftness the sole aux amandes. The Undersecretaryâan inveterate gourmet, he knewâpraised it without reservation; and pleased, he acknowledged it, and signaled to Phat to refill their wine glasses.
“But with Samuel it effected a permanent change: he became irascible, choleric, rebellious without point. He got embroiled in two ungodly rows at Ord, then snatched at that regimental command under Westerfeldt. His coup at Moapora, as you probably know, was the result of direct disobedience of orders. He seemed to need to purge himselfâhis very soul, punish himself with a hundred and one acts of defiance. On Désespoir he got himself involved in a way I'm not going to tell you about; but suffice it to say it was very much part of the syndrome, and caused his superiors a lot of worry.