Authors: Matt Potter
Already alerted by the shroud of secrecy around the lake on the night of the crash, Patrick did some digging. What he and his team found was a huge operation, bigger than anyone had suspected: a regular, top-secret trade corridor involving Ilyushin and Antonov crews being commissioned by the army and government to fly between the lawless, warlord-controlled uplands of the eastern Democratic Republic of Congo and Kampala, carrying priceless natural resources that they could sell for cash to line their own pockets. Clandestinely logged timber, gold, and silver, and even animals and animal furs, are all part of the traffic.
“Eastern DRC, which borders Uganda, is a rebel area, there's no military there, no governmentâcompletely lawless,” he explains. “It's almost like Somalia; it's in the hands of warlords. You just deal with different warlords and bandits here and here and here. So you deal with them, and of course you buy the goods cheaply, pay them, and come back. Now, the Ugandan army spent about five years in Eastern DRC, claiming that they were pursuing Ugandan AVF rebels that were based in the Congo. So they captured the eastern Congoâit was actually under the control of the Ugandan People's Defense Forceâand started transporting minerals and wood and so on using these planes. And the UPDF formed alliances with various rebel groups. Eventually, due to international pressure, the UPDF left, but it maintained its ties with those rebel groups, and now they go in on these Russian planes, buy timber from local militia leaders in Congoâand you can buy
anything
âand just come back.”
For insiders, the logistics are breathtakingly simple. You want a local warlord to source the goods for you? Call up an old contact from the conflict, they're all there, and they're all on the same mobile provider as you. You need backup, hired muscle? That's okayâyou're the army, just bring a few colleagues or command a few of your men.
Now, the plane. That's easy, you're the army, you've got dozens to choose from, right? Except you want to do it on the cheap because whatever you spend here is coming out of your own sweet pocket, and you certainly don't want to have to ask too many people's permissionâless still have the UN contingent camped across the grass ask where the plane is they were going to take on an aid drop today. Bad look. So you hire an independent air operator and a team of mercsâprobably one of the Russian, Ukrainian, Bulgarian, or Byelorussian teamsâwith a giant plane that can fit, say, a platoon of men, a couple of jeeps, and a whole lot of contraband timber. Call it an Ilyushin-76, hypothetically, for the sake of argument. And make sure the guys you're dealing with have that can-do spirit Iain Clark mentioned. If the price they quote is $3,000 an hour, offer to double it on invoice if they'll split the difference. If they'll do it, you pay $6,000 from the army's coffers and collect your $1,500 personal cash-back to share among your men, with maybe a crafty $250 for your commanding officer to look the other way while you're gone. Everybody's happy.
Still, the cheapest planes might not always be the newest or the best maintained. They probably wouldn't pass the CAA's airport runway inspection. No sweatâjust use your triple-security, razor-wire, well-guarded, UN-populated air base. And if the CAA boys get uppity on takeoff, that colonel you bunged the hundred-dollar bill to will put them in their place. Hell, cut him in on the proceeds later, why not. With margins this bigâand we're talking hundreds in return for every dollar investedâthere's plenty to share around.
Patrick continues: “That's how simple it is. First, make contact with your rebel leader. Go armedâcontract a local or use your own soldiersâthen come with a plane. Your warlord will be armed, and let's say you want timber, he'll just find a road, and say, âOkay, from here, all this timber, take it.' And your men just roll it and put it on the plane, because these planes are huge.”
In fact, it's quicker and easier to make a private mission for black cargo than it is to go by scheduled civilian airlines: no papers, no passport, no visa, no immigration, no customs, andâbest of allâno limit on what you carry back, says Patrick. It's all very civilized, too. “You can do it all in a day, or you can stay overâall the warlords have comfortable places where they put our guys up when they come overâand to their contacts they're only ever a mobile phone call away.”
Who'd have thought it? In this bright new world of the consumer as king, even the die-hard Congolese guerrillas resisting government forces in the hills and jungles of Central Africa put twenty-four-hour customer service at the very heart of their business plan.
And that's it. Except for customsâand let's even assume you've got some independently wealthy and heroically incorruptible customs guys here for a moment, highly theoretical guys who are immune to bribes. Hmm, could be a problem. Then again, no. Remember, stupid, you're in the army.
“Customs can't go into the military/UN cargo air base,” says Patrick. “It's not civilian jurisdiction. It's army and defense ministry property. Soldiers guard it, and if a customs officer goes there, they just arrest him for trespassing. Trespassing! And”âhe laughs at the irony of it allâ“jeopardizing national security!”
The clock is ticking, Patrick's on deadline, and his editor's getting antsy for this week's news pages to hit the press, so we say good-bye. I decide to walk home and take my chances with the snitches, to see if I'm followed. As I step out into the overcast, red-earth-and-tar patchwork of Kanjokya Street, hobbling between termite mounds and potholes and wondering which of the loiterers in the wet dirt road is the army spy, I'm splashed by a camouflage, open-topped UPDF jeep doing its best to circumvent the foot-deep holes and the Friday rush-hour traffic. In it are four men in tailored suits and jewel-tipped sunglasses carrying antiquated wooden rifles over silk-clad shoulders.
There's no pavement, so I step carefully between road and grass, jeans getting splattered with mud. I turn around at the corner and look back. The guy reading the paper has folded it up and is looking past my shoulder, and there's a man regarding me steadily while he talks away on a mobile phone at the junction. Then again, I'm a wet, muddy
mzungu
on foot in a country where even the hardest-up local trader would rather flag down an illegal
boda-boda
moped ride, so of course
everyone's
looking. Then the rain starts again and I stumble between torrents and traffic, wondering about that anonymous Ugandan voice on the phone who wished me a safe stay. But now there are too many people walking my way to be sure of anything at all.
WHAT ALL THIS means for monitors of illicit activity is something most can't even begin to fight, even though men like Peter Danssaert and Brian Johnson-Thomas have long known it and have seen it again and again, in Belgrade, in Uganda, in Afghanistan.
The problem is this: Mafia activity is by its very nature against the interests of the state. We're used to thinking in terms of “families” and “gangs”âtuxedoed Sicilians making offers we cannot refuse. So when the state itself gets in on the act, as it did in early-1990s Russia, late-1990s Serbia, and in our own time Afghanistan, where President Hamid Karzai's inner circle, including his warlord brother Walid, stand accused of facilitating “Afghaniscam,” awarding contracts, and plundering coffers at will, nobody quite knows the difference anymore between organized crime and economic policy. This appears to be true in Uganda.
A UN report entitled “Illegal Exploitation of Natural Resources and Other Forms of Wealth of the Democratic Republic of the Congo,” published back in 2002, sums up the reach of this private-enterprise shadow state and its devastating effect.
The elite network operating out of Uganda is decentralized and loosely hierarchical, unlike the network operating out of Rwanda. The Uganda network consists of a core group of members including certain high-ranking Ugandan People's Defence Force officers, private businessmen and selected rebel leaders/administrators ⦠The network continues to conduct activities through front companies ⦠Each of these companies may concentrate on one or two commercial niches, though these may change. The role of the companies is to manage their respective niche activities by assembling the personnel, logistics and occasionally the financing for the operations ⦠The network generates revenue from the export of primary materials, from controlling the import of consumables, from theft and tax fraud. The success of the network's activities in the Democratic Republic of the Congo relies on three interconnected features, namely, military intimidation; maintenance of a public sector facade, in the form of a rebel movement administration; and manipulation of the money supply and the banking sector, using counterfeit currency and other related mechanisms.
Everything disappears into the network's ravenous jaws, and then into the holds of the giant cargo planes it charters. Wood from protected plantations; blood diamonds; coltan, a chemical highly prized by African exporters for its value to mobile-phone manufacturers; gold. Local butchers are forced at gunpoint to skin animals and hand over their hides to the network's fatigue-clad soldiers, and even live cattle is rustled, by stealth or force, from herders. And for their complicity, the suppliers, the local warlords, and tribal leaders enjoy the protection of UPDF troops, as well as gasoline, cigarettes, and arms, all exempt from taxation.
Sometimes the logic is so neat that even those most affected can't see it. Later tonight, I'll head to a hotel bar and watch some TVâBBC World, I think, but I can't be sureâand see a documentary on a woman who runs an elephant sanctuary. She's protected by soldiers because of the constant activity of armed poachers in the area and threats to her life, but complains that whenever she leaves her guarded headquarters on the reserve for a trip to town or abroad, “It's as if I'm being followed and spied on by poachers somehow, because they only seem to strike the very moment I go away.” She regularly comes back, she will say, only to find that the soldiers she employs have been outfoxed by heavily armed ivory poachers who've raided the reserve, gunned down an elephant using military-grade Kalashnikovs, and disappeared with the ivory, apparently before the soldiers could locate and stop them. The soldiers keep a low profile in the doc, only to scratch their heads and wonder aloud to the woman how the mysterious poachers keep eluding their grasp. “They must be very clever,” says one.
And I'll stare, and think, surely it can't just be me? Surely everyone here can see the big, bad question hanging in the airâa figurative elephant in the room? But the woman doesn't see it.
It seems to me like the perfect expression of the failure of agencies, NGOs, and law enforcement alike to stop traffickers. In the face of the pursuit of profit by any means necessary, anyone thinking in terms of moral right and wrongâanyone looking for criminalsâis blind. Like government, like reserve stewards: the unthinkable is happening right under your nose, courtesy of regular Joes earning a buck, and you're out looking high and low for the bogeyman. And the planes just keep coming and going, for the UN, the CAA, the military; for aid organizations and businesses. Wholly respectable and above-reproach operators are forced to compete with those who'll do anything, take anything, work for anyone, and artificially lower their prices because they're carrying secret cargo for cash.
Weeks later, in a rare bust, an unaccompanied shipment of two tons of ivoryâ317 elephant tusksâand five rhino horns will be seized at Kenya's Nairobi airport, having flown by cargo plane out of Entebbe in huge crates declared as containing fresh avocados. The prime suspect, an employee of the cargo operation, simply vanishes.
THE FUNNY THING is, I've met a few of these pilots, on both sides of the divide, and some who've moved between them, and they aren't bad guysâon the contrary. They're also pretty anxious to do the right thing if they can. So they're doing what everyone's always telling them they need to do to stay out of trouble, just as they had to back in the air force, and just as we all have to. They're keeping their heads down, working hard, and doing exactly what the authorities ask of them. If those authorities, if the state itself, is doing something wrong, they rightly ask, should somebody important not be doing something about that?
A week on. I'm standing on the wet perimeter track of Entebbe airport, looking out along the runway from which all flightsâincluding, it is said, countless “merc” flightsâdepart and on which they land. To my left, the civilian airport. To my right, the military air base, with its containers stacked and ready for loading by soldiers onto flights to eastern Congo and, cuddled up next to them, its rows and rows of stenciled UN tents. Welcome to the world of advanced globalization. Welcome to the world where a mafia is not a mafia but is reborn as the state itself. Welcome to a place where even what is illegal is not illegal, if the network is doing it. The UN-Ugandan military base is for their use only; but the going rate for bribing your way to use it for a commercial flight is a mere $300 from the pilot.
Then again, if the network doesn't want it doneâpoking around like Patrick over at the
Independent
, or me hereâit'll send someone to put a stop to it right away, legal or not. And right on cue, here's the drab green jeep, purring round the perimeter to check my ID, make a call, escort me away.
The neat rows of UN tents, huts, and offices are so close I could pick up a handful of gravel and break the windows, but uncannily, despite the howling noise of the engines, the unloading of loot in front of them, the soldiers and airmen scattering through the gates, the daily coverage of the smuggling ring in opposition newspapers, nobody in the UN camp seems to notice a thing. The network is, after all, the government. And these people are its guests. So like everyone in every mafia economy, they make nice. Play the game. Make their pacts and deal with their devils. Focus on the always-worthwhile bigger picture. And meanwhile here come the goons with guns and wraparound shades, and here, as we talk, comes another planeload of goodies from the DRC.