Plea of Insanity (46 page)

102

Ladies and gentlemen of the jury, I understand you’ve reached a verdict.

The judge’s words sounded thick, as if they’d been dipped in molasses. All around him, he noticed, time had somehow suddenly slowed to a virtual stop. Seconds had stretched into hours, like a bad movie with too much slow motion in its direction. He heard the restless crowd around him suck in a collective breath and then hold it as the judge spoke. The moment seemed so fragile, as if he had just watched someone drop an expensive glass vase and was just waiting for it to shatter into a thousand pieces. He imagined, as he looked straight ahead at nothing, that if they did sentence him to die, this might be what his final moments alive would feel like. The last few hours lasting as long as days; final seconds becoming an eternity, until, he suspected, there’d come a point he’d actually be anxious for it to just end. His body was physically tingling, from both the terror and the excitement, as a million little fingers delicately crawled across his skin under the ill-fitting, cheap black suit his attorney had made him wear. The prickly feeling was at once euphoric and also insatiably itchy and uncomfortable, and he resisted the urge to claw himself out of his restless skin. It was imperative that he remain here, in the moment, no matter how anxious he might be. The end was almost here.

Will the defendant please rise …

They were all here for
him,
he knew as his eyes took in the room without ever moving. Not for his brilliant father or his cold, society mother or his sorry-ass, tragedy of a brother. This time it was for
him.
They had traveled from as far away as China and France and Germany – all around the world – to see
him.
To hear
him.
To watch
him
with their cameras. And as he sat there, waiting to rise up and hear his fate, suspended in this fragile moment, he knew that in dozens of countries, millions of people, right now, were talking about and shedding tears over
him.
Of course, the attention was never his intention, yet he couldn’t help but find it funny how things worked out sometimes. And he couldn’t help but be more than a bit proud of himself at how far he’d come with this. At how far he’d made it. But, of course, it was not time for smugness. The vase was still out there in mid-air.

His attorney gripped his arm and leaned into his ear. ‘David, David, listen to me,’ he whispered sternly, hoping to get through. ‘If the verdict is guilty, say nothing. Do nothing. Everything you say and do can be used against you. I will come see you across the street as soon as they complete the booking and the paperwork, and I will try to have you placed back on nine, so you can continue your meds. The penalty phase will not be for a few weeks, probably.’ Mel lifted him by the elbow, encouraging him to stand up now. ‘So say nothing, that’s very important to remember.’

He stood.

Will the clerk please publish the verdict …

The judge kept up his angry stare as the clerk rose, unfolded the paper and finally put on her reading glasses. Sitting up stiffly in his seat, he moved closer to the bench, tapping his wrinkled fingers impatiently on the wood, and surveying his courtroom with a suspicious, anxious stare.

And that was when he saw the judge blink.

It had happened so fast, he was sure no one else had noticed. But he’d played enough poker in his life to know a tell when he saw one. Judge Farley, with the flicker of panic in his cold, angry eyes, had just choked right in front of him and given away his hand. And in that brief, fragile instant, he knew what the clerk was about to say.

He felt everything inside of him relax, and he bit his cheeks as the clerk began to read aloud the words he already knew were coming. He bit them hard until they bled. The pain kept him from moving. From cheering. From sighing. From smiling. From laughing.

We find the defendant not guilty by reason of insanity …

He’d wanted to scream, or jump. Even hug his attorney back. He’d wanted to reach over the gallery rail behind him and hug his crying father, too, before he finally smacked that pitiful, profound look of despair and disappointment off the old man’s face. It was the same familiar look his face slipped into whenever he got within ten feet of Darrell after he’d been diagnosed. That’s why he wanted to remove it. His mother had always been far more discreet, reserving her looks of disappointment and shame and despair for more private moments, when the cameras were off and the guests had gone home, but there was no need to look behind him to know that she was gone already. There was no way she could handle the failure of being the mother of two schizo sons, the mother of an insane murderer, no matter how well she’d played the supportive role these past few months. The label alone would probably kill her. Good.

The men and women who judged him were still sitting in the box, shifting uncomfortably in their seats, the cameras were still set upon him. So, of course, he didn’t slap his father. Or yell at his mother’s shadow. And he didn’t hug anyone. He didn’t do anything. He just swallowed the blood from the chewed wall of his cheek and he stared straight ahead.

The shouts and screams erupted everywhere, all around him. He heard the cheers of those who had made him their cause. The Pro-Life poster boy. The champion of the Treat People With Mental Illness In A Fair And Decent Way groups. And he heard the cynical jeers of those who thought him the devil incarnate. Of those who believed him a malingerer. A faker. A murderer.

Amidst all the noise and shouts and clutter, from somewhere behind him, he heard them call her name.

‘Ms Valenciano, are you happy with the verdict?’ ‘Was justice done?’ ‘Have you spoken to David Marquette?’

His miracle worker. His Anne Sullivan. She who had made the blind see his illness; who had made the deaf hear the voices only he heard. Assistant State Attorney Julia Valenciano. They continued to shout their questions, but she never answered them. He didn’t hear her sweet, defiant voice. Even so, he
knew
she was there, somewhere behind him, waiting. He could feel her. He could even smell her perfume. Their electric
connection
was still there, as it had been since the beginning, and he knew she would not leave him until it was all over.

I find that the defendant most definitely meets the criteria for involuntary commitment, and as such, am hereby committing him to the custody of the Department of Children and Families … I will review the hospital’s report on your client’s progress and we will proceed from there with any further extended commitment …

He owed her big-time. He owed her, perhaps, his life. And it was time to let her know just how thankful he was to have it. It was time to let the world in on the proud little secret that he had been keeping all to himself. Well, maybe not all to himself, he thought with a chuckle. There was one other out there who was very good at keeping secrets.

As they came for him with their shackles and chains and handcuffs, he patiently held out his arms, because he knew it would not be long before he was free of them. Before God miraculously healed the sick and he would be well again and they would have to regrettably let him out. The time was sure to quickly fly …

He let them lead him away, but he knew she still waited. Until the last second, she waited for him. So he turned around and he made sure he thanked her for all she’d done for him with a big, friendly smile.

Damn, she sure was pretty.

To God

Why have you made life so intolerable
And set me between four walls, where I am able
Not to escape meals without prayer, for that is possible
Only by annoying an attendant. And tonight a sensual
Hell has been put upon me, so that all has deserted me
And I am merely crying and trembling in heart
For Death, and cannot get it. And gone out is part
Of sanity. And there is dreadful Hell within me.

Ivor Gurney – English composer, poet and patient,
The City of London Mental Hospital

103

It was strange, she thought, to hear the birds chirp and sing outside. From her window, all Julia could see across the neverending empty field that stretched past the parking lot was a blanket of white snow. And looming in the not-so-far distance, underneath a veil of gray clouds, the majestic chocolate mountains were still wearing white caps. It looked cold and abandoned and desolate. But right next to the window, in a naked Honeylocust tree sprinkled with snow and crusted with ice, a pair of cardinals was busy building a nest for their babies. Even snow in May couldn’t stop the tiny green buds from pushing through the snow dust, or the birds from building their family a new home. It was a sign of spring, John had told her.

‘The positive thing that we can look to here, if it can be said that there is anything positive about your condition, Julia,’ Dr Ryan was slowly saying, ‘is that you actually recognize the signs of your illness. And, as you know, that is a good sign indeed, in terms of predicting an outcome here.’ A badge clip on her white jacket said Marie G. Ryan, MD Psychiatric Services. ‘And, of course, there is the possibility this is an isolated psychotic episode, although given the family history, I am not holding out much hope that’s going to be the diagnosis.’

She knew she should be listening harder, but she couldn’t focus. The birds were chirping so loudly, it was almost as if they didn’t want her to hear anything but them. Their chirping seemed to fill her brain, so that there was no space left for anything else to be heard. She picked certain words that the doctor was saying to concentrate on, thinking that might make it easier.
Positive. Condition. Predicting.
She couldn’t let herself lose the words. They were the only rope she could cling to now and she couldn’t let them go, no matter how loud the chirping became. No matter how hard it was to focus. She knew what would happen to her if she got tired and let them go. That was what was so …
positive. She knew what would happen to her, and that was a positive predictor.
It all suddenly snapped into place and made sense. She breathed a silent sigh of relief.

‘There are other positive factors to consider as well. You’re female. Statistically, females have a more favorable outcome – one, five, ten years down the road – than men. You’re first showing signs of the disease at the age of twenty-eight, which is also good. The older the age at onset is positive. Prior to only a few weeks ago, your behavior, your thinking, as you and John have both related to me, and as your medical history presents, was considered to be relatively normal. You did not suffer from bizarre thinking or associations as a child. No delusions, or hallucinations, no prior psychiatric hospitalizations. That, too, is good for a couple of reasons.’ Dr Ryan looked over at Lat. ‘Individuals who have led a normal childhood,’ she said, holding her fingers up like quotation marks when she said the word normal, ‘and who then have a rapid, sudden onset of the disease, as opposed to one that develops slowly over months or years – well, statistically speaking, those patients have a better long-term prognosis. Of course, everyone is different, and Ido have to stress that that is only statistically speaking.’

‘But what about what happened with her brother? Her parents?’

‘The murders were definitely a traumatic event, no doubt, but by normal childhood, I mean that her development – emotionally, socially, behaviorally – was normal. There were no emotional-development issues reported. And given just how traumatic and stressful that event was, it is remarkable that she did not have a psychiatric history after that. While stress is no longer considered to be the cause of schizophrenia, it may be the proverbial straw that breaks the camel’s back in individuals who may be genetically predis-positioned. In other words, the fact that Julia did not develop schizophrenic or psychotic symptoms long before this suggests she’s very strong.’

It’s as if a cataclysmic earthquake has happened inside her head. The mountains are falling, the seas are opening. The landscape will never be the same.

Julia’s eyes darted to the window again. She watched as the male cardinal, with his brilliant red feathers and black crest, suddenly flew off by himself into all that white. She followed him until he became a small red dot and finally disappeared out of sight. The female stayed back in the branches, next to the window. Julia noticed that she stopped chirping.

‘But we do have your family history to consider, Julia, and that, unfortunately, is not so good.’ The doctor’s soft, tan face changed a bit. It grew more intense and serious, almost as if it were brittle. ‘Again, as you already know, statistically speaking, the more relatives in the family tree with the disease, the poorer the outcome tends to be. You have a father and a brother, both in your direct line of consanguinity, who have developed the disease. And we don’t know about the rest of your lineage, as there’s no one left on either side who can relay that history. But you are responding to the medication nicely, and that
is
positive, and you are no longer hearing the voices, is that correct?’

The female looked around anxiously for her mate now. She started to chirp again, but it was a different type of chirp, Julia thought. It was a ‘Hey, where’d you go?’ chirp, and it grew a little more insistent. Finally, she left her nest-building behind and began hopping from branch to branch in the sprawling tree.

‘Julia?’

Dr Ryan was looking at her. For how long, she didn’t know. How long had she been gone this time?

‘Julia? Are you still hearing the voices?’ Her voice was slow, but the tone was raised, as if she’d asked the question a few times already.

Hold on to the words.
Medication. Positive. Voices
. She shook her head. ‘No. They’ve stopped, I think. Sometimes …’ Her voice drifted off. The room was very hot.

‘They stop sometimes?’ Dr Ryan tried not to frown. ‘I thought you weren’t hearing them anymore.’

Julia shook her head again. ‘No. I don’t. I don’t, I don’t hear them anymore. Sometimes I get, ah, I get nervous again, like they …’ She took a deep breath. The room was so hot now. And the words felt thick as they came out of her mouth. She could feel both of them watching her, studying her, analyzing what she was doing and saying and comparing it to normal reactions, sentences, emotions. To be sure, Dr Ryan was more clinical in her observations, comparing her to her other psych patients, or maybe to a textbook. But John was more personal. She assumed he was comparing her to the ‘old’ Julia that he used to know. The Julia that didn’t babble sentences which made no sense or hold her head like it hurt. Or drift off somewhere where no one could find her. She looked at the floor, embarrassed that he had to hear her say these things. ‘Like they might come back. Like I won’t know it if they do.’

Like a cancer patient in remission or an MS patient in between episodes, everything now related back to her disease, as, she suspected, it always would. Was she exhausted because she hadn’t slept well or was her brain throwing another white spot? Did her back hurt because she’d pulled a muscle, or was it the cancer cells back, building another complex tumor somewhere in her body? She had to analyze every thought now to see if it was indeed normal, or if she was being tricked by her own mind. Would she know if the voices came back? Would she be
aware
next time that something was horribly wrong in her head? Or would madness consume her completely on her next go-round and she would be too sick to help fend it off again?

She knew all about the disease, all about the prognosis. She’d studied it for months. From how she remembered it, the odds weren’t looking so good. And unfortunately, her awareness of being sick was the one reality she hadn’t lost yet. It was the one thing she clung to. Like a drowning pathologist lost in the middle of the Atlantic without a lifeboat, she would know the clinical experience of her own tragic demise before it took her under.

Almost as if he had read her mind, Lat leaned over and grasped her hand, rubbing it gently. ‘People beat this, you know.’

‘John is right, Julia,’ Dr Ryan said slowly. ‘With the help of medication, some people do go into full remission. I know you’ve had a horrible experience with your own family, and I know that you’re familiar with the disease in a negative, forensic setting. But more than two million people
live
with schizophrenia in the United States, Julia. With treatment, some of them fare quite well. They have jobs and families. They don’t all live on the streets or commit homicide. Forget what you’ve seen in a courtroom, or watched on TV. They’re not all violent and they’re not all homeless. There is hope.’ She finally smiled and then looked over at Lat. ‘You have many positive predictors for a good outcome. And, perhaps more importantly, I can see you have a wonderful support system. I think you’re more than ready to continue treatment on an out-patient basis.’

She smiled and stood up from the seat that she’d pulled up next to Julia’s. ‘The most important thing will be for you to continue to make sure you take the medication. Even when you’re feeling completely normal again, for lack of a better description.’

‘I get very tired,’ Julia said.

‘Yes, well, the Mellaril seems to be working for you right now, and I’m hesitant to change that. The other antipsychotic drugs can have some very serious side effects, including the second-generation antipsychotics. I don’t think we should change what’s working. And the Elavil will help with anxiety and depression. That takes a bit longer to see results.’ She headed to the door, opened it and turned back to Julia with a final, soft smile. ‘I’ll see you in three days in my office and we’ll look at how things are going for you. Good luck to you.’ Then she disappeared out the door and they were alone.

The chirping and singing started again. Julia looked back out the window. The male was back, his beak filled with twigs and brush.

‘When can we go home?’ she asked softly. ‘I …’ she tried to finish the thought, but it got stuck somewhere, so she just stopped.

‘I’ve rented a house in Anaconda,’ he said, his eyes following hers out the window. ‘It’s only a few miles away. It’s laid-back and ultra-quiet, so don’t expect South Beach and the hootchie mommas.’ He smiled. ‘’Cause I didn’t pack your leopard pants. Or mine.’

She finally smiled and laughed a little.

‘I think we’re going to stay out here for a while, though,’ he said quietly.

‘Lay low,’ she whispered, growing serious again.

‘That’s what the cowboys and criminals do. Welcome to the Wild West. Everyone lays low out here, separated by a few hundred acres of land.’ He followed her gaze out the window. ‘It’s beautiful, isn’t it, though?’

She nodded, but his words slipped off and she blanked out yet again. Her mind kept doing that. Taking short catnaps without telling her. When it woke up, everyone and everything seemed to have moved on without her.

‘What do you think?’ he asked softly, trying to find her again. He waited a few moments before trying once more. ‘What do you think? I sn’t it pretty country?’

‘Yes,’ she said, biting her lip and looking at the cardinals building their nest together in all that snow. ‘Is it really cold?’

‘Everyone says this was just a late-season storm. Spring’s here, that’s for sure,’ he said, tapping on the window. The birds ignored him. ‘It’s so peaceful out here. I think that’s what you need right now, Julia. That’s what I know I need. Get away from all that craziness and get you better.’

All that craziness
. The last few weeks were a blur. Maybe that was a good thing. She couldn’t remember exactly when she’d figured out her head was not working right anymore. Even with all the medicine, and the whispers in her head now gone, she couldn’t figure out what
had
been real. The phone calls, the protesters, the reporters following her … It wasn’t like she now saw the past clearly and lucidly. It was still deceptively foggy. David Marquette’s smiling face flashed in her mind too many times. Over and over. Had she been wrong all along about him? Had that really happened? Had the devil really smiled at her? It was the one thing she was afraid to ask John about. So she lived with it.

He insisted no one else knew what had happened with her. He’d told her there was no public breakdown. Nothing made the papers. In the days after the trial had ended, she’d gotten progressively worse – strange and reclusive – and he’d known something was going really wrong. When he’d finally sat her down and asked her, she could remember telling him that something was not right in her head. That her thoughts were not sounding like they used to. That they sounded like they belonged to someone else. That they sounded like they were coming from the TV sometimes. It was probably the hardest thing she’d ever had to say to someone, much less someone she knew she was falling in love with – but she’d wanted it to stop so bad. She’d wanted to be normal again. And she was so scared. She didn’t know where to start or what to do. And she didn’t want anyone to know.

That very night, he’d gotten on a plane with her and taken her here – far, far away from the spotlight of Miami. She hadn’t known where they were going. She hadn’t known where they were for a few days. She’d signed whatever papers he put in front of her; she’d taken whatever medicines he fed her. She remembered crying when they pulled past the sign for Montana State Hospital. Here, in the middle of the Rocky Mountains and the snow and the quietness, finally no one knew her name. That’s what he’d told her.

‘… before I plunk down any money, I want to make sure I actually like it out here. Real estate’s always a good investment, I think, even if retirement is a long while off. I’ve been thinking of looking at Bozeman. That’s where Montana State University is. One of the Robbery guys went there. Talks it up all the time. Nice college town. Not too far from Helena. Or maybe Jackson Hole, Wyoming. You’d be a cute ski-bunny, I bet.’ He turned away from the window and took her hand. ‘So what do you think, pretty lady? Would you like to raise some horses out here with me someday?’

‘What about work?’ she asked. ‘Don’t you have cases?’