Authors: Cynthia Voigt
Toby gladly started in again. James listened, carefully, thinking of Toby as just one brief life, but thinking how Toby was all
wrapped up in something much larger than himself, something that really interested him. Toby was doing all right by his life.
“Do you know?” James interrupted. “I wouldn't be at all surprised if you turned out to be really famous. One of the pioneers of astrophysics. One of the really big men, the men who really contribute something.” He said it because he meant it.
Toby's eyes got watery for a minute, but James didn't mind. Even if Toby had burst into tears, what did tears weigh in all the time that had passed? If Toby felt like crying, and cried, that was what was important.
S
ammy cut James off in the middle of asking “Do you ever wonderâ?” with “You know I don't.”
He'd about had it with James standing around as if he didn't have two hands like everybody else, standing around while somebody else did the work. It wasn't that Sammy didn't like hard work, or this work. In fact, kneeling there in his grandmother's vegetable garden, pulling out weeds, loosening the soil around the plants, his hands covered with dirt and the sun hot on his bare back, on the soles of his bare feet, too. There wasn't much he liked better.
Then why was he getting angry at James? If James helped, it would just be more work for Sammy. Sammy knew how James worked at things he didn't likeâcarelessly, that was how. If James were to help out, Sammy would have to watch him, to be sure his brother was thorough enough, getting the tiny new weeds as well as the bigger more full-grown ones. He'd have to check that James picked them all up, because if you left any behind they'd just root where they lay. That was the way weeds were. Weeds would just root down wherever they found themselves. Like the Tillermans, Sammy thought. That idea made him smile.
“We're like weeds,” he said, over his shoulder to James's legs. James had just returned from the long Saturday hours at his job, where they paid him for sitting down.
“No, we're not,” James said.
“Maybe
you're
not,” Sammy said. And maybe James wasn't, maybe James wasn't strong enough and needed more careful tending. For sure, James didn't want to be a weed. He wanted to be a lawyer and wear three-piece suits and rake in the money.
Not Sammy. Sammy just wanted to be left alone, like a weed to grow on his own. Into whatever he was going to grow into. Something that had sunlight and sweat, he thought. Like a tennis player. His fingers dug down around the wide-spreading root system of some grassy weed, loosening its roots. Sammy pulled the thing out of the soil and tossed it into the heap he was making. He looked back up the row of eggplant bushes. Their long leaves were opened now to the sun, like pairs of hands cupped out to catch the heat and light.
Or an astronaut. In his own way, even though he lived in an enclosed environment, an astronaut worked with sweat and sun. Or a farmer, too, he thought, moving on his knees to the next plant. He picked up the clawed cultivator and dug into the tight soil around the plant's slender stalk. James wouldn't even offer to gather up the piles of weeds. James just stood there, thinking. Not doing anything. Just standing there, probably thinking about this father business again. He'd never told Sammy what he found in Annapolis. Sammy hadn't asked, either. He wasn't going to askâthis was James's fixation, James was the one interested. But he wondered what had been so bad that James had found out, so bad that he wouldn't even tell Sammy. Who didn't even care.
James sat down on the long grass at the edge of the garden, at the end of the row Sammy was weeding. The grass needed mowing, too, but James would never think of doing that until you told him he had to. James picked at the soles of his sneakers. Sammy pulled at weeds. The sun poured down. Inside the house, Maybeth and Gram were working on the upstairsâopening
windows, emptying closets and drawers to wash everything out. If James wasn't going to work out here, he should go help them. From the garden, Sammy could sometimes hear their voices, sometimes a distant car, or gulls a way off, fighting over something. The buzzing drone of insects was the only steady noise on this windless day. Sammy straightened back and wiped the sweat that was rolling down his forehead. He could feel the way his hands left another smear of dirt along his face.
He liked dirt, liked being painted up with it. He liked sinking down into a tub full of warm water to get clean again. Even if he'd rather be playing tennis right now, if there was only somebody he could play with, there wasn't anything he'd rather be doing right now than what he was doing. It was contradictory, he knew, but it was true, both of it.
“In Annapolis,” James began. Sammy looked over at his brother. With his narrow face and thick dark hair, something about the way the button-down shirt looked on the slender body, James looked like he came from an entirely different family from Sammy. Sammy waited.
“When I was there,” James said. He was watching his own clean hands pull grass out of the ground.
If he was going to pull things up anyway, Sammy thought, why not weeds. He waited. Finally, he asked, “You never told me about Annapolis.”
“It wasn't a big success. The Hall of Records didn't have anything, or, if they did, I couldn't get in to find it. So I just hung around most of the day. We've been there before, do you remember?”
“Yeah.” Sammy remembered. Except for the worry about Momma, he'd enjoyed that wild summer, or a lot of it.
“It was weird, being back there, with everything so different. But there was a library full of booksâ”
Sammy didn't want to hear about books.
“And it made me wonder aboutâall the different lives people have lived, all the different things there are to be. It's really amazing, how many different things there are to be in your life.”
Sammy returned to the work at hand.
“Because he was smart, they said, they both said.”
“Who?”
“Him. Our father. And he had a regular family even if they weren't having an easy time of itâbesides, I don't think much of anyone who had an easy time during the Depression. But out of all the things to be, he turned out a sailor. He wasn't even an officer. And before that he was some kind of crook.”
“A gambler,” Sammy corrected. “Not even a real professional gambler.”
“Yeah, but he was crooked. The thing isâ” Out of the comer of his eye, Sammy saw James lean forward, the way he did when he was having ideas and trying to tell you about them. “It makes me wonder if there was something in him, some character flaw. Something wrong about him.”
“He just sounded to me like someone who always tries to find the easy way out,” Sammy said, thinking that there was a lot of that in James.
“But don't you see? If he was so smart, he couldn't kid himself about that. Because it takes just as much work to figure out and then take the easy way. Anybody knows, there isn't any easy way.”
The way James handled ideas, following them down like fingering loose the root systems of weeds, that wasn't any easy way. So Sammy guessed maybe he didn't have to worry about James.
“Maybe he just liked trouble,” Sammy suggested.
“Yeah. That's what I wonder. But you know you told me to be myself?” Sammy didn't remember, but it sounded like something
he'd say. “You were rightâdon't look so surprised, you're not stupid. You were right about that, because it doesn't matterâif you imagine all those lives over the thousands of years, any one little life doesn't matter a bit.”
Why, Sammy wondered, did James find that such good news? What was so great about not being important at all? Sammy was pretty important to himself.
The sun was getting hot, which made him think of summer, which made him remember the end of school coming up and the question of how to get someone to take James's place crabbing, which made him remember the projects that teachers seemed to like to have due right at the end of school. “James? You had an English project, didn't you? When you were in seventh grade?”
“Yes, why? Do you?”
“A'course, and in science, too. What did you do?”
“When?”
“For your English project.” Teachers tended to repeat assignments from year to year. The English was anything you wanted to do, but you had to write a five-page report, with a list of the books you'd read, and you also had to stand up and talk about it in front of the class for about five minutes. Sammy wasn't worried about the talking. He knew he could fool around for five minutes easy. He wasn't worried about the writing, once he sat himself down to it. But he couldn't think of anything to report on.
“I did a report on Ursula LeGuin, the science-fiction writer.”
“I remember.” Sammy got back to work. His hands were clearing the soil of any weeds which might choke the growth of the vegetable plants. “That was the year you and Toby read all that science-fiction stuff.”
“And fantasy.” James wasn't paying attention.
“What happened to Toby? I haven't seen him forâages.”
“Nothing. He's still around.”
“I kind of liked him. He was weird. You must have had other ideas, though, didn't you? What were some of the ones you didn't do?”
When James didn't answer him, Sammy turned his head to see why. James had leaned to crouch forward on the grass, he looked like some dog at the water's edge the way he was crouched there next to the garden. James lookedâbad. He lookedânot exactly sick, and not exactly frightened, not exactly furious, butâbad.
“What's the matter?” Sammy had his hands full of weeds.
“Don't you do that,” James said. Sammy didn't know what James was talking about. “Don't you dare ask me to do that report for you.”
Sammy didn't even
want
him to and he'd never said that. He opened his mouth to inform his brother of just that, but James stood up.
“You tell me, and you act like all you do is just be yourself, but you aren't being as much of yourself as you can. So don't ask me.”
Sammy dropped the weeds and stood up to face his brother, because he didn't know what James was talking about, but James was spitting words at Sammy like Sammy had done something awful. If it was a fight James wanted, he'd get one.
“Listenâ” Sammy warned.
“No,
you
listen. You act like you're so stupidâ”
“I do not.” He did not.
“Like you're not smart, then, and you are, but you never get around to using it. Your brain. You just let it sit there in your head, lazy. And ask me to do the work for you. That's cheating, Sammy. Don't go lazy-brained kidding yourself about that.”
“I don't cheat,” Sammy said.
James didn't listen, as if he were talking to himself, not Sammy, or talking to somebody who stood where Sammy stood but wasn't Sammy. “Like our father,” James said.
“I don't cheat,” Sammy repeated stubbornly. “And you know it. Take it back, James.” Nobody could say something like that to him and not have a fight coming. Sammy watched James figure that out, and back off, the way he knew James would.
“It sounded like cheating to me.”
“That's because you weren't listening. I don't want you to do the report, just suggest some ideas. I don't have any idea what to write about. I'm not the one with ideas, you are. Remember? So don't go throwing all this cheating stuff at meâand where you got it from I don't know, but it's from you, not meâwhen all I was asking you for was what you thought might be good topics.”
James stood, and stared, and said nothing.
Sammy was ready to fight, but he was just as ready to get worried. Here he'd been thinking that James was cruising along, a little conceited about his job, maybe, but feeling okay. Then it was as if Sammy had opened a little door just a tiny crack and all this dark poisonous stuff came pouring outâand it stank, too, whatever it was. James should know better than to accuse Sammy of being a cheater, like their father. James should know better and probably did. Then what was all this stuff about?
“Just possible topics?” James finally said.
“Yeah. But never mind.” Sammy hunkered back down to work. He almost didn't want to talk to James anymore, again. He didn't even care if James took it back or not. It was scary, all that stuff pouring out of him.
“I'm sorry, Sammy. I really got it wrong, didn't I?”
“Yeah. You did.” Sammy looked at James. Their glances connected, and Sammy was glad of that because James was worried too. “You don't often get things so wrong.”
“Tell that to some people I know. Or, people I don't know, that's more true.”
“Whaddayou mean, you mean girls?” That would make senseâmaybe; James and girls, or a girl.
“Oh, girls, who ever knows what they think.” James sat down again. “I'm really sorry, Sammy. I didn't mean it.”
“Okay,” Sammy said. “It's okay.”
“Except about selling yourself short,” James corrected himself. “That part, I think I do mean.”
Sammy didn't let his face show that he'd heard, but he had. He just didn't want to talk about it.
“I thought about doing a history of Crisfield,” James said, then. “For my report.”
What a snore, Sammy thought. That was a snore and a half.
“Or Tolkien, because we'd been reading him, too. And I really wanted to do Plato, but that was just to show off because nobody, not even Toby, knew about Plato.”
“Probably the teacher didn't either.” The only reason Sammy knew the name was because James had talked on and on about the guy for a while.
“Yeah. So, anyway, I didn't. Or mythology, I considered mythology, too. Toby thought about doing the tarot cards, you know?” Sammy didn't. “Fortune-telling cards, they're really old. I think they're Egyptian in origin, and there are some strange stories about them.”