The Spare (29 page)

"The day of my arrival at Pennhyll," Fitzalan said, "three different servants made a particular point of warning me the fourth earl yet walked the castle halls. I think they must have taken lessons from Price." He paused. "Your cousin is watching you again." Her feeling of unease increased, for indeed, Hew stared at her, eyes narrowed. "I do believe he's jealous."

"Of what, my Lord?"

"Me."

"Who wouldn't be?" She laughed. "With the wealth and position that is yours, you are to be envied, indeed."

He gave her a dazzling smile. "If you mean my position next to you, you're quite right."

"Ridiculous." But she burst out laughing despite not meaning to. They'd reached a set of stone stairs, and Price waited for them to assemble before leading them upward. Fitzalan moved closer, speaking in a low voice.

"I would not for the world have you uncomfortable, Miss Willow. But I confess he's made me wildly jealous."

The others started up the stairs. She stopped at the first step and faced him. Fitzalan kept his distance, for which she was grateful. "You have no cause for jealousy. Nor does my cousin."

"Don't marry him." He grabbed her hands and went down on one knee. "Miss Willow. Olivia. I must speak."

"Pray do not."

"Whatever Sebastian told you about me, he was wrong." Fitzalan tightened his fingers around her hands. "He wasn't once, but my feelings are not what they were. I admire you and respect you. You're a lovely, lovely woman, and I am out of my mind with love for you. Olivia, I want to marry you. The honor would be mine, I assure you. I will cherish you to the end of my days."

"For pity's sake, stand up."

"Olivia. I adore you. I want you to be my wife."

"Stand up."

He did, thrusting his hands deep into his pockets. "I love you."

"That's nonsense."

He stepped toward her, too close, slipping an arm around her waist. She retreated. Her stomach pitched. "All I ask is that you not reject me out of hand."

She laughed because the scene was so horribly accurate. Exactly what Tiern-Cope had warned. "Someone once told me never to trade a present liberty for a promise."

"Sebastian told you that, didn't he?"

"He was right."

Some of the light went out of his eyes. "If I even try to kiss you, you'll think he was, and that I'm trying to seduce you."

"Aren't you?"

"It's only natural I'd want to kiss the woman I love. The woman I intend to make my wife."

"Shall we go? Before we're missed."

"Olivia, I love you."

"I am not much amused."

"For once, I don't mean to amuse you. I am free to marry where I choose. There is no impediment. No reason in the world why I cannot marry you and no reason for you to marry your cousin. Not when my heart is yours." He took her arm. "I won't badger you, but I promise you, you'll make me the happiest man in the world soon."

Olivia looked pointedly ahead of them. "Shall we?"

"The fourth earl," Price was saying when she and Fitzalan rejoined the others, "whom some call the Black Earl, died before his time, found dead in a pool of blood that to this day stains the floor of the lord's chamber. Neither soap nor lye can remove that mark of unholy death."

They were, she realized, not just in the north tower, but heading toward the stairs to her room.

Tiern-Cope turned his head toward them, catching Olivia in the act of tucking a curl into place at the back of her head. Fitzalan stood close behind her, and the earl's cold gaze flicked from her to Fitzalan. She felt a rush of heat because she knew what he thought had just happened.

Single-file, they ascended the stairs and exited on the floor below her room. They halted midway to the parlor. The air felt cooler, and she shivered again. With two long strides and a flourish of his hands, Price threw open the parlor door. "Behold, my Lords, ladies and gentlemen. The scene of the Black Earl's murder most foul."

"I thought you said this was the earl's chamber," said Diana, who was the first to enter after Price himself.

"Not the present earl's chamber, of course," Price said. He walked farther in, turning to the guests. "The family now resides in a more modern wing. Five hundred years ago this was the earl's chamber. You must imagine not this gilt-edged desk but an oaken table, thick and solid enough to withstand use by a warrior knight of the realm. No delicate sofa or book-lined shelves, but an enormous black wardrobe and a carved chest. There a stand for a knight's sword. Imagine, if you will, silk hangings surrounding the bed. Rushes cover the floor and firelight flickers over the walls. The air, despite the fire, chills. Imagine not this exquisite marble mantel straight from the finest quarries in all of Italy, but the stone hearth beneath. Captain Egremont, perhaps you will be kind enough to stand just here. Facing the fireplace, just off the carpet, as if back from a melee." Egremont shrugged and moved into place.

As one of the last in, Olivia stood farthest from the fireplace. No one paid her the slightest attention, not even Fitzalan who, at the moment, stood next to his sister and Mr. Cage. Not Hew either, for that matter.

"Listen for the sound of treacherous footsteps," Price said standing behind Captain Egremont. "The door makes no sound, for the hinges have been well oiled against this night's dark deed. A soft padding behind the Black Earl who stands unaware the sanctuary of his rooms has been breached. He contemplates his day, thinking perhaps of his lady wife, or planning a campaign for the next." Egremont put a booted foot on the grate. Suddenly, Price bent and grasped the edge of the carpet. "Imagine murder." With a practiced motion, he threw back the carpet, baring the stone floor to Egremont's right. An irregular stain marred the floor. Diana threw herself against Tiern-Cope's chest. He patted her shoulder, then put her into the care of Mr. Cage. He backed away to let others examine the floor.

While awaiting her turn to look, her eye was caught by something glittering in the darkened angle where the wall met the floor. Intrigued, Olivia stooped and peered into the corner. She stretched out an arm. Her fingers closed on something small and cool to the touch. The object felt like a bit of sharp-edged ice. Her blood ran cold when she saw what it was; the urge to throw it back to its shadowy corner made her fingers twitch. She stared at the letter engraved on the surface, then closed her hand around it.

Dr. Fansher leaned toward Olivia. "Have you found something, lass?" His eyebrows shot upward when she opened her fingers. "What is it?"

Behind them the others crowded around the stained floor, oblivious. She knew what she held and even, it seemed, how it came to rest in the corner. Not a dream. Gracious, she and the earl— Oh, heavens.

"A cufflink." Dr. Fansher took it from her. "A for Alexander. Captain Alexander?" He bowed. "My Lord, is this yours?"

Tiern-Cope took the cufflink. The center of Olivia's palm tingled when the earl's gaze lifted from the bit of metal and landed squarely on her. "Where did you find it, Ned?"

"Didn't. Miss Willow did." He cleared his throat. "Ah, I want a closer look at the floor, and I can see Captain Egremont is wanting a word with me. Do excuse me, Captain. Miss Willow."

Tiern-Cope pocketed the bit of metal when Fansher took his leave. "Did we?" he said.

"Onward," Price said. "If the ladies dare—"

On cue, Diana said, "Where?"

"The dungeons, Miss. Where the Black Earl once imprisoned his own dear Lady wife."

People shifted position, moving toward the door. Fitzalan joined Tiern-Cope and tucked Olivia's arm under his, obstructing Hew's attempt to join Olivia. "Hullo there, Mr. Willow. Chilling sight, wasn't it? Come along, Miss Willow. You, my dear Captain, most shamefully neglect my sister. Shall we, Olivia?"

The dungeons extended the length and width of the north tower, but were reached via stairs from the Great Hall. Bare stone steps descended to blackness. Price, lamp held high, led the way. At the bottom, he distributed oil lamps to several of the gentlemen. Within the circle of light, the corridor was comfortably bright but ahead lay impenetrable darkness. "Stay close to the gentlemen, ladies." Price laughed. "If we lose you in here, the only way we'll find you again is by the gleam of your bones in the darkness."

Olivia wished her cloak was warmer as Price ushered them down several steps into a chamber that angled back into solid darkness. Cell doors opened to enclosures no larger than a carriage. The smell of decay and damp and of things left to rot made the air heavy. Several of the ladies pressed handkerchiefs to their noses. Walls glistened with blackish-green mold. Frost and ice clung to the stone. Manacles hung from the walls, a gruesome reminder of the former use of Pennhyll's dungeons. Olivia could not help thinking the lanterns did not entirely relieve the dark. Blackness waited to reclaim its own. A shiver crawled up her spine at the thought of being trapped here, closed in by a brute of an earl.

Price took them down another flight of stairs to a cell no less cold and dank than the others, but smaller yet. He pushed on the black metal door, opening it wide. "We stand at the extreme rear of the castle in Pennhyll's most infamous cell.
La Morte Froide
," he said. " 'The Cold Death.' Where the Black Earl imprisoned his countess. Come in. Come in. No more than five at a time."

Olivia was in the last group to enter to cell. Price pointed to an opening high up the wall. "That aperture admits air. And snow or rain or water. And— other things. Disagreeable things. No fewer than six gutters converge there and empty into this cell. A prisoner held here during a winter storm might well drown, if the cold did not kill him first."

"But could he not escape?" Hew asked. "The hole seems rather generous. Could not a prisoner climb out that passage?"

"Indeed, sir." Price nudged a manacle hanging beneath the opening. The metal scraped against the stone. "He could if the guard forgot to secure him. But, I assure you, no one at Pennhyll was ever so forgetful. And if one was, the prisoner who managed to navigate the tunnel would likely fall to his death on the rocks below, for beyond this wall lies a sheer drop down the mountain."

Upon their exit, Olivia was at the back of the group because a jagged bit of metal from the manacles snagged the hem of her gown. She tugged. This was her only dress. If this one were damaged, quite literally, she had nothing else to wear. She tugged again, fingers searching the snarl of fabric in the hope of avoiding a tear that couldn't be easily mended. Metal sliced her fingertip. The cell door screeched on its hinges. She cried out, and jerked her skirt. The muslin ripped free. Olivia turned in time to see a flash of bright fabric disappear into darkness.

"Wait." She dashed for the door but slipped on the slime-coated floor. Her arms flailed, and she teetered disastrously close to falling flat. The time it took to regain her footing cost her. The door closed with a resounding
clang
and trapped her in a world without light. In the blackness, she felt for the door. There wasn't any handle on the inside. She hooked her fingers in the gap between the door and the stone wall, but it was jammed too tightly to open. With a fist, she pounded on door, bruising the side of her clenched hand on one of the metal cross struts. "There's someone here. Open the door!"

Thunder boomed, drowning out her voice. The heavens opened. Five minutes later, water and melting sleet poured through the grate and cascaded to the floor. The stench overpowered her. Frantic, she thumped on the door again. She could hear nothing through the walls. A sense of unreality took hold, deepened by the darkness.

Couldn't this be a dream, too? Just as she'd imagined the earl back there in the library kissing her or the Black Earl leading her to Tiern-Cope's private quarters, mightn't she now be imagining herself trapped in this cell? The cold felt bitterly real. Her eyes adjusted to the black. She could see the walls now, dank with mold. A glimmer of gray came from the opening in the far wall. Runoff converged at the hole in a collision of water and granite. She leaned against the door and waited. Forever, it seemed. Her shawl did not protect her from the cold. She shivered. The water seemed to be coming down faster now.

Before long, water lapped over her feet, covering her boots. The stench choked her. She waded toward the duct, one arm extended until she felt the wall. Her skin crawled at the contact. Two feet above the tips of her extended arms, she could see a shimmer of light. Water cascaded onto her with force that whipped away her shawl. With leverage from one foot on the iron-fitting that secured the manacles to the wall, she stretched and jammed her fingers into a seam in the wall. Her shoulders and ribs protested, but she hauled herself upward. She held her breath against the onrush as by dint of sheer desperation, she clawed her way into the tunnel.

She shimmied forward. The wetter her clothes got, the harder it was to move. The tunnel angled upward. Every so often, she had to push herself up to release dammed up water, letting it rush beneath her. She focused on the light. The opening narrowed, and for a panicky moment she could not move in any direction. Water splashed into her face. Her feet scrabbled, sliding off the walls, but at last the toe of her boot caught a seam in the stone. She exhaled every last bit of air in her lungs, pushed with all her strength and slid forward. One hand extended outside. She inched her way forward until, like a snake, she slithered out. Shards of rock bruised her feet and the wind blew so fiercely that if she hadn't flung her arms around a boulder protruding from the foundation she'd have been blown off the mountain. A gust caught her hair and sent her cap whirling into the sky.

«
^
»

Sebastian closed the cell door, giving it a push so that with a sigh of putrid air, iron fittings ground against stone. He shook off a shiver of unease. At his side, Diana shivered, too. Lord, that door sounded like death. What must hapless prisoners have felt to be on the other side when they heard that sound? Thunder roared, a tremendous clap to be heard from so deep within Pennhyll. Diana cringed.