Two Cowboys in Her Crosshairs [Hellfire Ranch] (Siren Publishing Ménage Amour) (23 page)

“Isn’t going to happen,” he interrupted. He picked up the can and shoved it in one of his bags. “I’ve wanted Olivia for a long time. After the ambush and she was gone, I kicked myself every day for not making the right moves then.” Living with regret was something he’d become damn good at. It was also something he was tired of. “I’m not going to make the same mistake again.”

Hudson studied him for several long, silent moments before nodding slowly. His wide grin dimpled his bronzed cheeks, and Jake knew Olivia wouldn’t be able to resist.

At least, he hoped she couldn’t resist the two of them.

“Agreed?”

“Hell yeah.” Hudson shifted his burden. “Let’s do it.”

Anticipation skittered along his nerves as they walked back to the house. He didn’t know if Olivia would go for their crazy idea, but he sure as hell planned on using every means he had available to convince her.

All they had to do was start with one night. One night of seduction and they had a chance at something special.

When they walked in, they found Olivia half-buried in the pantry with her lush ass sticking up in the air.

“Now that is a mighty fine sight,” Hudson said.

She straightened and spun around with two cans of green beans in her hands. She dropped her defensive stance almost immediately. “You startled me.”

“Sorry,” Jake said. “We’re pretty secure up here. No one will get through Tag from the road, and our surrounding land is backed by rugged mountains on two sides and a deep gorge on the other.”

Her look was a mix of skeptical and wistful. “Could a marine get through?”

He chuckled ruefully. “Yeah.” Jake started pulling groceries from the remaining bags and tossing them her way while Hudson took care of the fridge and freezer stuff. “We’re on high alert, Olivia. The house is also on lockdown. Hudson set the alarm when we came in.”

“Yep,” Hudson chimed in. He held a gallon of Blue Bell Banana Pudding ice cream in the air. “No one’s getting my sweet cream.” Then he winked.

Jake knew she’d caught the innuendo because her cheeks flushed a lovely shade of rose while her eyes darkened into pools of desire.

Olivia hadn’t lost a shred of her sensuality in the three years they’d been apart. He walked the last can over to the pantry and set it on the shelf behind her head. He crowded his chest against hers on purpose.

She didn’t give him an inch but held her ground.

He felt her nipples pebble and push back on him beneath her orange T-shirt.

He looked down and found her staring up intently. Her nostrils flared when he cupped her jaw. “You’re so beautiful, Livvie.”

She tried to look away, but he wouldn’t let her. “It’s true. I’m not the only one who thinks so, either.”

“What do you mean?” she whispered.

He dropped his hands to her hips and backed out of the pantry, pulling her with him as he went. “Hudson thinks you’re pretty spectacular, too.”

He spun them around, and Hudson caught her from behind. He winked at Jake. “Yep, I sure do.”

Her gasp turned into a sweet moan as Hudson’s lips found her neck. Olivia clutched Jake’s shoulders. “What are you doing?”

He swept a tendril of hair from her eyes then trailed his finger over her lips. She licked at it then stilled. Hudson’s hands sneaked around to cup her breasts.

“God,” she muttered. Her expression was conflicted as she battled the desire.

“Don’t fight it,” he said. “Enjoy it.”

“Ah,” she gasped and arched.

Hudson had found his way inside her sassy new bra. He tugged the T-shirt down and bared her left breast while he tweaked her nipple.

“I don’t understand,” she said.

“We want you to feel good,” Jake said. “Both Hudson and I want you very much, Olivia.”

Her hand covered Hudson’s, and her breath came in ragged little gasps. “You do?” She craned her head up to look at Hudson.

He nodded.

She looked back to Jake. “But…both of you?”

He smiled and pulled her hand away. “Both of us.” He grabbed the hem of her shirt and dragged it over her head. Hudson immediately loosened her bra and pushed it down her shoulders. She caught the cups and held them to her breasts. Her hands splayed over her chest, and the straps dangled down. Jake thought she looked sexy as hell.

“Wait a second. Wait.”

“Okay.”

She rolled her eyes and stepped out from between them. She leaned against the counter and stared at one then the other. “Let me get this straight. You two”—she waggled her finger at them—“both want
me
?”

“Yes,” they said in unison.

Her eyes narrowed. “At the same time?”

“Uh-huh,” Hudson replied.

Jake saw the dawning understanding in her brown eyes. Saw the lustful flare she didn’t conceal.

“You’ve done this before?”

He hesitated, but Hudson elbowed him in the side. “A few times, yes.”

“Good.”

“Good?” Her relief shocked him.

“Yes,” she said. “I have been torn by the two of you. You’re very different and yet both so damned sexy.”

“Torn how?”

She bit her lip and the blush reappeared. “Last night was incredible, Jake. Just like before. Hot, intense, and a month’s worth of orgasms.”

Hudson elbowed him again but harder. “Knock it off,” he muttered.

Her eyes swung to Hudson. “But when you kissed me, it felt different. Just as mind-blowing. I wanted more. And I think you knew that.”

Hudson crossed his arms. “I did. It’s why I left.” His glance slid to Jake. “I don’t poach.”

She nodded. “Admirable. So, now you two have talked and decided to share me so there won’t be any poaching?”

Jake straightened at the slight edge in her voice. “Well, uh, it wasn’t exactly like that.”

She snorted. “I think it was exactly like that.”

He cast for a way to ease the rising tension. “Let’s not get all crazy, sugar.”

“So now I’m
sugar
?”

“Yes?” Jake didn’t know what the hell she wanted him to say. Hudson stood grinning like an idiot and eminently unhelpful. “Because you’re so sweet and stuff.”

Olivia’s lips twitched before turning down.

Jake narrowed his gaze. “Wait a minute.”

“No,” she said. “You wait a minute.” She pushed away from the counter and stalked forward. Olivia poked him in the chest. “Lucky for you I happen to want both of you, too.” She dropped her bra. Her hands dropped to the fly of her new jeans as she turned around. “Who has the biggest bed?” she called out over her shoulder.

Jake stared slack-jawed at her sleek, naked, and retreating back. Hudson’s expression mirrored his own. “I’ll be damned.”

Hudson grinned at him and started unbuttoning his shirt as he took off after her. “If you don’t hurry your ass, you sure as hell will be.”

Jake hied after them. “My room,” he yelled as they reached the hallway. He stopped by the couch and tugged off his boots and socks.

The door to his room was open when he arrived. Olivia stood clad only in her red lacy panties. She was poised by the bed with one hand on the covers and her entire body bathed in the fading evening sun. She looked like a fiery version of Aphrodite sent to entice them both.

Hudson was in the plump reading chair in the corner. He was unlacing his tennis shoes and doing a lousy job of it because he couldn’t take his eyes off of Olivia.

“Livvie?” Jake said.

“Yes?”

He stepped into the room. “You’re sure about this?”

Her smile was a mysterious and sensual invitation. “Oh, I’m positive.” She licked her lips. “What girl hasn’t dreamed of having two luscious and handsome men at the same time?”

His heart tripped. “Positive?”

“Yes, Jake,” she said. She dropped the comforter and skirted the end of the sleigh bed. Her small fingers curled around his jeans waistband and tugged. “Why are you talking instead of undressing?”

Jake couldn’t stop the groan that welled in him as she touched his skin. Her fingertips skimmed along the hair-roughed flesh of his abdomen as she worked her way up his chest. “I know you can get naked, so do it. Now.”

Hudson finally toed off his tennis shoes and bounded to his feet. “Ha, I didn’t realize she was such a bossy bit of goods.”

Olivia turned to him. “I’m also demanding. And have high expectations.” She grinned over her shoulder at Jake. “I know how good he can make me feel, Hudson. How are you going to fare?”

Jake laughed as he shucked his jeans and underwear at the same time. “I’d be careful about tweaking that tiger’s tail, Livvie.”

She glided toward Hudson and pushed his hands away from his belt. She jerked and tugged and finally got it open. Then she dropped to her knees in front of him and slowly pulled down his zipper.

Jake moved beside him and looked down. All the air in the room whooshed out at the sight of her kneeling before them. Her voluptuous tits, hips, and ass were on full display. Her mouth was pursed and gilded with moisture from her tongue.

“It’s not his tail I want to tweak.” She grabbed the edges of his jeans and inched them downward.

“I love your hands on me, darlin’,” Hudson said. “But you’re going too slow.” He stepped back and shucked his remaining clothes.

Jake kept his gaze on Olivia’s expression. Her eyes widened, and her mouth dropped open. “Oh my.”

He chuckled and leaned down to help her up.

She swayed a bit as she rose, and her tits slid along his chest. He caught a globe in his palm and squeezed then moved around behind her. “Like what you see, Olivia?”

“Uh-huh.”

Hudson strolled forward. His friend had a tight, lean body with muscles honed by years of cattle work. But Jake was pretty sure it was Hudson’s long cock that held her enraptured.

“He’s as big as you are,” she whispered.

“Thank you for thinking so.” Jake chuckled and cupped her other breast. He rolled her flesh in his hands, learning their weight and finding all the points that drove her crazy. He sought her nipples and held them lightly between thumbs and forefingers.

Olivia’s hands reached behind and stroked his stomach. “It’s true,” she said. Her voice quivered a little bit.

Hudson stopped in front of her. One hand encircled his dick and the other lifted her chin. “What are you thinking about?”

She tried to move her head away, but he wouldn’t allow it. Jake tightened his fingers. “Answer his question.”

“I was thinking about taking…taking both of you. At the same time.”

Jake’s cock jerked and rebounded against her ass. Hudson’s eyes narrowed as a wicked grin spread across his lips. “What, you can’t take me in your sweet little pussy and Jake in your mouth?”

She shuddered but didn’t say anything.

“Hm, I don’t think that’s what she was pondering, Jake,” Hudson said. He crowded her even more, and his hand dropped between her legs. “Tell us what naughty thoughts made you shiver like that, darlin’.”

Jake heard her swallow.

“I just, it wasn’t anything.”

Jake pinched her nipples hard. She cried out and arched against him.

“Fuck, she’s already sopping wet,” Hudson murmured. He pulled his fingers from between her legs, and Jake saw them glisten in the overhead light. Hudson smeared the moisture along her lips. “Try again and this time, don’t lie.”

Something in his hard tone must have gotten through, because Olivia bucked and shook then nearly collapsed against Jake. “I was picturing something different,” she murmured at last.

Jake panted and worked her hard nipples some more. “Tell us,” he ordered.

Olivia tried to wrench away, but they held her fast. “Please, can we get on the bed?”

With one final tug, Jake released her nipples and slapped her ass. “Fine, crawl up there.”

When Hudson stepped back, she bolted for the bed and dove under the covers. Jake smiled and approached from the left.

Hudson took the right side, and as he hoisted himself up on the king-sized bed, he stripped the covers away.

Olivia gasped again.

Hudson lay down at her feet and stroked her calf while Jake slid beside her. “What were you thinking Olivia?”

Her eyelids lowered as her hips undulated. “I wasn’t thinking of one of you in mouth and one in my pussy.”

His cock contracted again at her mouth forming the dirty word “pussy.” “No? Then what?”

Her nostrils flared, and her legs spread a little wider. She met his gaze square on. “I was thinking of you in my pussy and Hudson in my ass.”

“Oh, fuck,” Hudson said on a long sigh. He rose to his hands and knees and crawled between her legs. “Darlin’, I’ve waited my whole life for a woman to say that.”

She looked at Jake, and he nodded. “Well, at least since he was legal.”

She giggled then stilled. Hudson wrapped his hands at the hem of her panties. “Lift your hips, Olivia, or you’re going to wish you had all ten panties.”