Tyrant of the Mind (12 page)

Chapter Twenty

The body of the murdered man lay covered on a trestle bench in the sanctuary of the castle chapel. Thomas looked around on the vague hope that someone would appear to order him off or perhaps bring him the comfort of companionship. He was, however, quite alone.

He stood quietly beside the corpse for a moment, then pulled back the cover to reveal the butchered body of a man who was once a son, a brother, and perchance even some woman’s lover.

Although the chapel was bitterly cold, the smell of decay was unmistakable. The sickening sweet odor of overripe flesh from the corpse’s pale skin drifted into his nostrils. Thomas coughed. He wanted to vomit but would not allow himself such a weakness.

“Courage, man!” he muttered to himself. “You may have taken monastic vows, but you are no less a man than you were before them.” He shrugged. “And the man you were probably wouldn’t like this any more than the man you are.” Thomas smiled at his weak attempt to draw bravery into his heart.

The corpse lay on its back. Thomas held his breath and bent to examine the body. There were marks on the face. Scratches perhaps. Thomas could count three, perhaps four, jagged lines along the left cheek. There was also a deeper cut on the left side of the face. That wound had bled freely but would not have been fatal unless it had festered. It looked cleanly done. A sharp knife perhaps?

Gingerly, he turned the body over on one side. “Here the killer plunged the knife into Henry’s left side just under his arm,” he noted aloud, the sound of his own voice echoing back at him from the crudely rounded roof over the sanctuary. “A short slice on the face from ear to jaw. Then a blow to the left side? Might there have been two men who attacked him? One behind him who held a knife under his chin, thus cutting him in the struggle, and one who delivered the blow from the front and under his arm?”

Thomas frowned in thought. If Henry had been surprised by the attack from behind, the assailant could have slit his throat easily. There would have been no need for the second wound. Had Henry become aware of the threat in time to struggle free after a slight wound to his face, he would have called out. From the rooms along that corridor, the baron, the priest and Thomas could have rushed to his aid and frightened the assailants off before a fatal wound was struck against a man who was fighting back. Neither sequence of events matched the wounds. Why?

The wound in the side was a strange one as well. If he had been facing his murderer, surely he would have been stabbed in the heart. Had he twisted somehow? Thomas turned this way, then that. No motion quite fit the blow.

Finally, there were the scratches on his face. What were they from?

Thomas flipped the body all the way over. In the back of the corpse was yet another very deep wound. “If he had been killed with the blow under the arm, why stab him again in the back?” he wondered aloud. He bent down and looked more closely at the wound. He made a fist as if holding a dagger and pretended to strike at the corpse. This wound seemed to have been made by a blow from above; the cut was higher on the right and slanted down to the left. Why would someone have faced Henry only to reach around him and stab him in the back?

He looked again at the side wound and compared the size of that entry wound under the arm with the one in the back. The one in the back was large enough to suggest that a blade had been plunged all the way into the body. The smaller wound in the side indicated one of two things: a very small blade had been used or only part of the knife had entered Henry’s side. More likely the latter, Thomas thought. “The knife may have entered Henry’s lung at the side wound, but it would not be deep enough to reach his heart. It surely would have been fatal eventually,” he whispered, “but the one in the back would have killed him at once.”

Thomas spent another few minutes looking over the body but saw nothing else of interest. Then he stood back to get a cleaner breath of air before he turned the corpse over on its back, an act he did with as much gentleness as if Henry had still been alive. He carefully pulled the cover up to hide the man’s body from curious eyes and fell into silent thought.

As with any man, Henry would have had his faults and perhaps even deserved punishment for them. But this? Thomas looked at the outline of the corpse under the sheet. No man or men had the right to murder him. Indeed, what right had any imperfect mortal to steal another’s life?

His own time in prison might have made him more hesitant than others to conclude that any man had the right to decree how another should die. That Thomas freely admitted. If he were yet more honest with himself, he would acknowledge that he secretly thought that only God, not men, should decide fit punishment for crimes that now required the burning, hanging or quartering of a fellow man. Since one mortal’s idea of fair punishment was another’s definition of excess, or laxity, could either be right?

Last summer, he had seen human judgments rendered. One he had even abetted. Now, looking at Henry’s mutilated body, he wondered if he had been right to do so. Might not severe penance have been the better choice until a natural death took the person to face God’s justice? He hesitated. And should the sinner himself have a choice?

“If the sinner understood the depth of his sin, might he not have the right to seek God’s eternal judgment quickly?” Thomas immediately dismissed the idea in fear. “May God forgive me for such a thought! That path suggests that self-murder would not be sin if it would allow a man to face God sooner, a most heretical idea indeed!”

He turned away from the body. He should not be thinking on any of this. Such questions were better left to philosophers and saints. In too short a time, he had been faced with much violent death, and he had been graced with neither the calm faith of a monk called to the vocation nor the temperament of a soldier hardened to such things.

Thomas walked away from the body on the trestle, then stopped. Surely, he had seen something move. Just in front of him toward the door.

There it was again. He was sure of it. Something had moved in the shadows. Then he heard a light scuffling sound.

Taking care not to let whoever was watching him know that he was privy to their presence, he crossed himself as if he had been in prayer, then bowed his head and walked on, slowly, meditatively, toward the chapel door.

As he reached the place where he had noted the movement, he bent down to examine his shoe, meanwhile shifting his eyes to peer carefully into the darkness. A darker shadow moved once again. Thomas stood up and turned toward the shifting gloom.

“What are you doing here, Richard?” he asked.

Chapter Twenty-One

“My grandson was doing
what
?” Adam’s mouth twitched with irrepressible glee. Although he ran his hand down his mustache and over his mouth, hoping to hold the laughter back, mirth bested his efforts with ease. “And in the chapel?”

“Indeed, my lord. Hunting dragons in the chapel was what he told me,” Thomas replied.

“Did he find any?” Eleanor asked.

“Only me,” Thomas said with a grin. “I told him it is not in the nature of dragons to be about chapels in winter so he does understand now how profitless such hunts would be.”

“Just how did he escape his room?” The baron’s smile faded.

“It seems he crept out with his hobbyhorse…” Sister Anne began.

“…down the stairs and into the snow and freezing wind.” A flush of anger spread over Adam’s face. “Nay, sister, do not say it was your fault. I said myself that his nurse was responsible and you could leave him in her care. I curse my judgment and place the blame on her. Where was she, I’d ask? Curled up asleep, snug and comfortable most likely, while the boy risked death making his way from the warmth of the hearth to the cold chapel.”

Anne shook her head. “Indeed, my lord, I swear the boy is made of iron. One day he is at death’s door and the next he is racing through the castle corridors like a wild man.”

Eleanor nodded. “Just like his father.”

“Be that as it may, she was too lax and shall be punished for such carelessness in her duties.” Adam raised his hand to beckon a page.

Eleanor reached over and caught his arm. “Be kind, father, and forgive. She has been most diligent and loves the boy beyond reason. He has so progressed in health that we all thought him past danger. Her short nap was no abandonment of duty. She had the right to it for Richard himself was sleeping when Sister Anne gave him up to the good woman’s care.”

“Or pretending to do so,” Anne said in a low voice to Thomas.

Having overheard them, Adam glanced at the two and smiled with concurrence.

“Any of us might have made the same mistake,” Eleanor continued.

“That I doubt, my child, but I will be merciful for your sake. Indeed, he came to no harm.”

“At least he did not see the corpse,” Thomas whispered with more care into Sister Anne’s ear. “My first fear was that, but he told me he had just come to the chapel as I was leaving.”

Eleanor nodded in the direction of the monk. “Brother Thomas has, I believe, frightened him off from further adventures in the chapel, or anywhere else unattended.”

“I did my best, my lord. I told him that he had endangered Gringolet’s safety by taking such a young horse into unknown territory without proper training. I allowed him to ride forth only with proper attendance and within the living quarters until his steed has gained some experience in the skills of hunting dragons in dark places.”

“When will Gringolet have gained such prowess?” The baron’s smile had regained a hint of amusement.

“Your grandson asked the same question, and I told him he could ride unattended when I have done the proper training and confirmed that the horse was skilled enough in such pursuits.”

Adam nodded. “That may work. My grandson has heard tales of the warrior monks and thus has no difficulty accepting a cowled man with knowledge of horses and battle strategies. Were I Richard’s age, I would find the argument sufficient, albeit hard to accept.” Then his face lost all joy. “Setting that aside, you had something to tell me, daughter, something about this foul murder?”

“I do, father.” Eleanor proceeded to tell them what she had learned from Isabelle, omitting only the woman’s cruder insinuations and softening the more tactless remarks. The dream she mentioned not at all.

“If I may say so,” Thomas said at the conclusion of her story, “that would give Sir Geoffrey’s wife good reason to kill Lord Henry.”

Adam shook his head. “I have never approved of my friend’s choice for a second wife, if the whore may still be called that considering Henry’s prior knowledge of her. Now rage at what she has done to a decent man blinds my judgment even more.”

Eleanor bit her tongue. Her father’s easy equation of the violence of rape with the bland “prior knowledge” might strike her woman’s heart sharply, but now was not the time to argue the point. That he listen with a clear mind to what Thomas had found after examining Henry’s corpse was of greater importance. After all, he would not be pleased that she had maneuvered around his prohibition against Sister Anne doing the same, and she feared his displeasure over Thomas’ examination might take precedence over the importance of his findings. She forced her anger into firm retreat.

“How I handle this ugly truth of her deception,” the baron continued, “and what I say to Sir Geoffrey are issues I must decide after a cooler reason returns. Nonetheless, even now, when I would love to concur with the possibility of her guilt in this murder, I confess I hesitate to conclude that a woman could have done this deed.” Adam looked over at Thomas. “She might have wounded him, if she surprised him, but not with a deep or fatal blow. I cannot see her successfully stabbing him to death except by stealth. The body would tell some of the tale, of course.”

“Brother Thomas did examine Henry’s corpse, my lord,” Eleanor said. She could not tell if her father’s surprised look held anger or not, but she knew better than to think she had won any easy victory over the man.

“Indeed,” he said at last in a dangerously composed voice, “and what expertise does a contemplative man bring to the study of wounds gained from violence?”

“If I may speak on the good brother’s behalf, my lord?” Sister Anne said quickly.

The baron’s smile was grim. “Why not?”

“Brother Thomas regularly assists me at Tyndal’s hospital. We often have cause to treat knife wounds when men from the village drink too deeply or find they share the favors of the same woman.”

Adam leaned back in his chair, his expression unreadable as he looked back and forth between the nun and his daughter. “Sister Anne, I respect both your skill and your plain speech,” Adam said at last. “When I denied my daughter’s demand to allow your examination of the corpse, I did so to honor the request of my grieving friend, not to insult you.”

“I took no offense at your words, my lord.”

“And respected them more than did my own child,” he said with a side-glance at the prioress. “Yet your strategy worked well, Eleanor. I give you due credit for that and for coming to a solution which may be the most useful and equitable. Despite having far greater knowledge in such matters from my days on the battlefield than either Sister Anne or Brother Thomas could possibly have, I cannot look on Henry’s corpse with any impartiality. It was, after all, my son who held the bloody dagger. Neither Sir Geoffrey nor any of his men has the requisite detachment either, for it was his son who was killed. He and I may not put the burden of impartiality on anyone under our respective commands since it is a man’s nature to look first to his master before he looks to the facts.”

Eleanor resumed breathing.

The baron turned to Thomas. “We must therefore trust you, as a man whose only true master is God, to give an objective and informed opinion while the body is still uncorrupted and until this snow storm ceases and the sheriff comes.”

“May God be merciful and this storm continue,” Eleanor said under her breath.

“So, brother, what did you discover?” The baron sipped at his wine and nervously rapped his knuckles against the underside of the table.

“Henry suffered several cuts and abrasions on his face and under his arm, although the deepest wound was in his back.” Thomas continued to describe the wounds in detail.

Adam shook his head in thought. “Not a clean killing then. Perhaps Henry was grabbed from behind but struggled free before his assassin had time to cut his throat? I also find the wound under his arm troubling. It would appear that one man attacked in front and one from behind Henry? Could there be two men? Robbery perhaps. Nor can I understand the scratches on his face. What is your conclusion, brother?”

Eleanor began to allow herself hope that her father shared her confidence in Robert’s innocence. Although she instinctively believed he must share her conviction, she did not know that as a fact. The circumstances were so very damning, but for the first time his words suggested that he might entertain the idea that another had done the deed. If convinced, he would work hard in his son’s defense.

“Sir Geoffrey would know best if anything had been stolen,” Thomas was saying, “yet I saw a gold brooch on Henry’s cloak while his body lay in the corridor. I could not check for his purse at the time, of course, but surely a thief would have taken the brooch. It would have been so easily removed even if the thief had been frightened away before he finished plundering the corpse.”

“You must be with me when I ask Sir Geoffrey what might have been taken from his son,” Adam said, his fingers now tapping impatiently on the top of the wooden table. “His wounds. What is your interpretation of them?”

“Some would certainly suggest a woman’s hand, my lord: the scratches on his face, perhaps even the wound in his side.” Or so Sister Anne had thought when he related his findings to her. However, he did know better than to reveal his consultation with Tyndal’s sub-infirmarian. “The latter was a small and a shallow one, I believe, although the knife may have punctured a lung. More I cannot say. A strong and angry woman could definitely stab a man deeply in the back. I saw such done once, but she was successful only because she surprised him. He had not seen her knife when he so unwisely turned his back on her.” Thomas glanced quickly at Sister Anne, who concurred with an almost imperceptible nod. “No man would turn his back on a woman with a knife in her hand,” he continued. “He would disarm her. I thought there might be two assailants as well, but the sum of the wounds does not point to a clear answer.”

“If I may say something, father? The Lady Isabelle may have had enough anger and cause to kill her stepson, but she would not have had success unless Henry had turned his back to her. Henry might have been a small man but he was quick with his sword, according to Robert, and fast on his feet. Nor, may I add, did she mention he had visited her.”

“Now if she had been the one to kill him, she would not have done so, would she, daughter?” Adam rose, wincing as he flexed his bad leg.

“Two questions, if I may, my lord?” Thomas asked.

Adam nodded.

“There was only one knife found at the site?”

“Yes. I have it locked away. There were no identifying marks, if that is your second question.”

“What was the size of the knife?”

Adam frowned in thought. “Now that you mention it, the knife was a small one. The size one might take to table, not to war.”

“Then it could have been a woman’s dagger as well as a man’s.” Eleanor frowned.

“Again you point to Sir Geoffrey’s wife. However agreeable the thought and as much as I may hate her, I would still conclude that two men attacked Henry,” he said. “We will handle this matter with the utmost fairness, no matter what the consequences. I have, of course, arranged for the questioning of the soldiers, servants and tradesmen who were here between the closing of the castle gates for the night and the opening for the morning trade. Perhaps the murderer hides in those ranks and we shall quickly find the truth of what happened there.”

Thomas coughed and glanced nervously at his prioress.

She nodded permission for him to speak his mind.

“My lord, might this murder have any connection with the death of your retainer?”

“I have thought of that. Henry was a thoughtless whelp, and, although I do believe that Hywel’s death was an accident, it would not have occurred if Henry had been taking due care with his own horse. Perhaps there are some here who would wish to take revenge, although I pray that such is not the case. I have worked hard to gain the trust of those in my service. Nonetheless, the possibility will be investigated and should be resolved when everyone in the castle has been questioned.”

Thomas opened his mouth to continue, but the baron raised his hand to signify he would hear no more. It was clear to all that they had been dismissed.

“In the meantime,” Anne said in a low voice to Eleanor and Thomas, as they left the hall, “we must pray for the snow to fall unabated, thus keeping the sheriff with his chains from Wynethorpe Castle until we can present him with those who did this to Lord Henry.”

“Indeed,” Eleanor whispered back.