I can't help but wonder how my life might have unfolded if I'd taken Jo instead of Mary all those summers ago. Choosing her at the bach would have extinguished any opportunity of being with Mary. Perhaps I might have enjoyed a simpler, less demanding life. Who knows? When I awoke with Jo in the Hilton there was a moment when I felt as though the alternative path had been
followed. There was just this second of peace as I watched the gentle rise of her sleeping shoulder. But as quickly as it came, it was gone. My room was not a place of happiness and order; it was disorganised and dirty, full of insatiable desires. Hastily yanked clothing, the remnants of drugs and half-full glasses were everywhere. This was my life.
To be honest, Jo enjoyed the greater satisfaction: for her a great wrong was righted and years of longing gratified. For me it was a routine evening of sex and fairly average, given some of the delights I'd experienced this last year. But knowing how important this was for her, I should have stayed away. I should have ignored her and waited to see what Bebe had rustled up from Auckland's underbelly. But I know I'm a suckerââno' and me just don't seem to go together. At least, I hope that's the reason. Please don't let there be something deeply Freudian going on.
The one night should have been the end of the Jo thing, the Jo fling. The situation demanded a fond farewell, promises of future contact with absolutely no likelihood of compliance and a firm shut of the door. Why, then, did I not follow such simple rules? Before I could stop myself, before I seemed to have a proper grip on the day, I invited her to the party after that evening's show. She was delighted. She positively glowed and sank into my arms like the woman in the films who has finally welcomed the return of her long-lost lover. And, of course, she had.
S
ome say that first love is the finest love. Casting a weary, nostalgic eye and forgetting that great corrupter of memory, hindsight, there are times I might agree with that sentiment. There is no doubt that first love is always the purest. It alone has that moment of total intoxication when you first grasp the spirit of love and sense its permanence. First love feels as though it will last for ever, it feels invincible and incorruptible. Nothing and no one will ever prise it away. However, when first love is lost and you love again there's always a part of you that won't surrender. There's always a voice to remind you how your love was stolen and how it hurt.
When I returned to New Zealand from Cambridge I was warm with the glow of a man immersed in first love. I'd been faithful to Mary and I knew she'd been faithful to me. I was loyal to our love and I ached with anticipation at seeing and holding her again. Thinking of Mary and replaying over and over in my mind the moment of our reunion sustained me through the hard and lonely times of our separation.
It was deep winter when I left Cambridge. The temperature had remained below zero for a week, and the coat-piercing wind off
the Fens made it considerably colder. Even without snow the city resembled an idyllic Christmas Day picture, with frost so thick and heavy it rimmed windows and transformed tree branches into silver limbs. I owned an old purple Mark I Escort and when the cold weather came I played roulette with the starter motor. One day it started first time, the next not at all, the third a start and a stop with no chance of further resuscitation. There was no pattern; it was chaos theory exemplified. Ali Naidu and I lived in Great Chesterford, a small village just south of Cambridge in a house owned by Mrs Grey.
Never was a woman more aptly named. She'd housed university students for twenty years and the house, and its contents, were unchanged since the first lodger took up residence. Every scrap of colour and every vestige of fun were long drained from the place, just like her pale, tasteless vegetables, which had been boiled to buggery. Mrs Grey, everyone called her Mrs Grey, not only had an aversion to vegetables that might offer the merest resistance to a strong set of teeth, she also had something against heat. The front room, small and overpopulated with heavy threadbare chairs, had a wonderful fireplace, but fire never adorned its splendour. Occasionally when it was a âbit chilly', which for Mrs Grey meant either snow or frost so thick it had to be chipped from the front path with a shovel, she put an electric bar heater on for half an hour. The heater had two bars, but one was broken and the one that worked only got an orange glow along three-quarters of its length. Ali and I learnt to live in four layers of clothing. We became well practised in the art of manoeuvring and eating with arms hardly able to bend. Some nights the sound of Ali's teeth chattering kept me awake. Poor Ali, how must he have felt coming from Cairo to Great Chesterford? I had enough
trouble even if she was slightly more recognisable to me from my visits to Grandmother's farm.
Ali was on the same physics course as I was, though we hadn't spoken in the two weeks before we moved in with Mrs Grey. We became friends quickly. This was the first time I'd met anyone of equal intellect. I know that sounds elitist, but that's how it was for me and how I found Cambridge. I met people every day who understood relativity and quantum theory the way others might understand multiplication or division. I was no longer a freak, always fighting to be accepted as normal; suddenly I was among equals and I could begin exploring the boundaries of my intellect. It was a wonderfully liberating experience and I grew like a limp lilo with a new foot pump: fast and in every direction. Cambridge may have been frosty and cold but already it was my intellectual home. The only thing the place lacked was Mary.
I flew into a New Zealand summer. Even early in the morning, heat was beginning to subdue Auckland. I saw Mary first, not surprising since I was looking out for her the moment I rounded customs control. We gripped each other, Mary shaking with a sob. Dad shuffled on the periphery, embarrassed at our affection. Finally, after Mary released me, I went to him and we shook hands. He stared over my shoulder at some distant point on the back wall, unable or unwilling to look me in the eye. We walked to his car, loaded up and I said goodbye to Mary, just minutes after greeting her, though we would meet later that day.
âGood flight?' They were the first words spoken by Dad, who still had that faraway gaze.
âYeah,' I lied. I'd worried the entire journey and was sure the arm rests had the indentation of my fingertips on their underside.
I waited for further comment, but our conversation was done.
Even though I hadn't seen Dad for almost a year, I might as well have just stepped off the bus after being away for the afternoon. Poor Dad, I don't think he got the Cambridge thing or, to be more precise, I think he chose not to understand. It was easier that way. This was how he dealt with life now. There was a time when he understood, but all that went when Mum left him. Life was much simpler and less worrisome if looked at in monochrome. There was no need for detail any more.
âI expect you'll go up to the bach sometime, will you?' he added some hours later as though the intervening time between our first words and these were forgotten.
âThought I'd go up with Mary, Helen and Mike. Is that OK with you?'
âShould be.'
âThanks.'
That was that. Holiday fixed. Well nearly: just before we left, Helen and Mike decided they wanted time by themselves, so they packed a tent and headed south. Mary and I travelled north for a week together before the Christmas and wedding onslaught. It was our first time back since the fateful holiday the year before and our golden moment on the beach. The bach was a mythical place for us now, our private Shangrila where dreams came true. The moment we arrived everything in our lives was how it should be. This was a perfect moment of first love. We sat and watched the sun set, casting an orange glow across the bay and sea. All was gentle, even the smallest flick of surf on the beach. It would be hard to think of a more sublime moment.
âThis is amazing.' Mary propped her legs on the glass coffee table in the middle of the room and sipped a glass of wine. Her body nuzzled into my side and she felt as soft as the picture
before us, just as I had dreamt of her as I sat in the cold of Mrs Grey's front room.
I merely nodded. Even speaking might doom the moment and break my happiness.
âCan I ask you something, Jack?'
I managed a grunt, but already I was aware of perfection slipping.
âDon't be angry.'
âI promise.' I was immediately on my guard. What dangers lurked in this simple request? I felt her body tense.
âDo you find meâ¦boring?'
I almost laughed with relief. âOf course I don't. What on earth makes you think like that?'
âI mean intellectually boring.' She moved away so she could turn to look at me. âIt's just that you are so, well, bloody clever and I'm so average. Do you find it difficult, I mean a strain, to be with me? Do you feel like you have to lower yourself to my standards, to my level?' She paused and noticed my smile. âJack, I'm serious. Caroline said something to me and it's kind of freaked me out.'
âWhat did she say?'
âBasically that you'd tire of me and when you did, you'd leave.'
âMary, I promise, I don't find you the least bit boring.'
âHow can I be sure of that, Jack?'
âI don't sit here thinking about questions I'd like to ask you or subjects to discuss and then say, “Shit, this is Mary, so there's no point in asking.” Come on, Mary, it doesn't work that way. I'm with you because I love you. I'm not looking for an intellectual equal, I'm looking for someone to love.'
âThere, you said it, I'm not your equalâthat's what you think.' She stood up and walked from the room. Moments later I watched her stride along the beach with the comical waddle of someone trying to walk through sand quickly. She looked like a cartoon character: all movement but no gain.
She returned an hour later and sat in the chair opposite, one leg lazily dropped across the arm. âI think that was our first argument.'
âI think so.' I went to her. âYou know I don't think like that about you, Mary. Come on, would I be here if that was how I felt about you?' I smiled thinly at the top of her head as I kissed it. My words sounded cheap and hollowâand they were.
The holiday passed without further comment on Mary's intelligence. That night we kissed and made love to heal the wound of our argument and the subject was closed. However, a shadow was cast and although we ignored the darkening when we were together I had no doubt Mary was as aware of it as I was. The near perfection of the return to the bach was broken and could never be mended.
Mary returned to the maelstrom of wedding arrangements and the plethora of small arguments turned large by stress. In contrast to the chaos of the Roberts' house, I returned to the maudlin silence of my home. I had lived in the red brick bungalow all my life. It was square and functional with a back lawn that sloped down to thick hedges. The garden was useless for playing with balls, which always rolled down and lodged in the sharp lower branches of the bushes, but it was ideal for the re-enactment of siege warfare. As a child, under a fierce summer sun I would play the crusader knight attacking a desert fortress. With plastic sword I would slay Ottomans on the deck battlements and gain
possession of the flowerpots by slicing off the head of the last defender.
I was standing on that slope the day Dad came to tell me Mum had left. He stood there, suddenly brittle in my memory, beckoning me to his side. Awkwardly he put a hand on my shoulder and patted me as though that act alone might soften the impact of what he had to say. I cried until he told me he thought she would be home by the weekend and she was just tired and needed time to rest. I still don't know if he believed that to be true, or whether he just wanted to protect me. Maybe he just wanted me to stop crying. I can understand that: seeing me so distraught couldn't have helped him to cope with his own grief. Whatever he thought, though, I'm sure he never contemplated the possibility that neither of us would ever see her again. If he'd known that, I think he would simply have given up then rather than slowly sliding down the following years as it dawned on us both that she was never coming home and we would never know what had driven her away.
At first I assumed it was my fault. Who else made her tired? What mother could leave her child unless the child deserved to be left? Perhaps she couldn't cope with my precocious talents. Dad ignored them, but did Mum just up and leave? However, as I grew older and became aware of what adults are capable of inflicting on one another I started to blame Dad as well. For exactly what I was unsure, but I imagined awful scenes of abuse behind closed doors. But I never blamed Mum for going.
Christmas dinner passed with little celebration. Dad and I shared a simple meal, a bottle of wine and long periods of silence broken by brief conversations like sporadic gunfire on a sleepy night at the Western Front. After the meal he poured himself
a whisky, which he drank in two gulps, then poured another, which he drank nearly as quickly again. I'd rarely seen him have more than a glass of wine at a time before. By evening he'd drunk half a bottle of whisky and his cheeks were flushed red. I shared a couple of drinks with him and smiled the inept smile of the half drunk.
âYour mum never liked me drinking.'
âRight,' I replied, my usual response to one of his brief remarks. Inside, though, I felt as though a bomb detonated. This was information on an unprecedented scale, even if it had been delivered as though reporting the weather.
âIt seemed wrong to change the habit once she'd gone. You had enough on your plate, what with her going like that.' He spoke with precision, as though he'd brooded on this conversation for years and now that he had finally spoken wanted to be sure what he said was correct.
âI never remember you drinking more than a glass.'
âI used to keep the whisky in the shed.'
âWhat about at the bach?'
âIn the boat shed.'
âAnd Mum never knew?'
He just shrugged his shoulders at the question. âI don't know for sure. She never said anything, but that's not the same thing, is it?'
âNo, it's not.'
He caught the hard edge to my reply. âIt's not why she left, if that's what you're thinking.'
His offhand remark angered me. How dare he make such presumptions? âHow do you know?' I asked with some trepidation despite my anger.
âI think your mum just wanted more, more than you and me. I never got drunk, Jack. I just shot a few drinks in the evening, it wasn't enough for her to leave us like that.' There was a sudden bitterness in his voice that I could hardly begrudge.
âShe had to leave for a reason, it had to be someone's fault.'
âI don't know, Jack, I just don't know.'
âI wonder if she found what she was looking for?'
âI doubt it, people rarely do, but most acknowledge the failure.'
We sat in silence for a moment before he poured us each another drink. âThere's nothing wrong with liquor, Jack, as long as you master it, never let the stuff control you. Once that happens, you're finished. Then you'll lose everything, and I mean everything. It never happens immediately and that's the danger, Jack. You think you can keep what you have got, but eventually you lose everything. It will just slip through your hands like sand and before you know it, you open your hand and the sand has all gone.'
It was the longest thing he'd said to me in years, but I didn't listen to him. I didn't think there was anything he could teach me. Next day I forced down an early morning drink as a dare to him and me. I could be different, as I was in so many other ways. I could prove my old man wrong and tame the drink. I could keep the sand in my handsâwhat a victory that would be. The whisky tasted awful but I would not be defeated.