Authors: Kate Richards
Then I go inside and writeâ
Naava and I are now sharing a room.
âHi, I'm Naava,' she says every morning. âWhen were you admitted?'
âHi Naava. I've been here a couple of weeks.'
âReally? Have we met before?'
âYeah.'
âShit.'
âIt's okay, it's the ECT you're having. It fucks up your memory.'
âDoes it?'
âYes.'
She says something in Hebrew that I don't understand. She has pale skin, very dark hair, immensely intelligent eyes and like Brett, she looks as lost as someone who finds herself in the middle of an unexpected dream. We talk about music â PJ Harvey and Broken Social Scene. Our despair matches.
In the afternoon James is released from HDU and walks through the ward into the courtyard as if completely new to the world. I remember him when we were at uni together â then, as now, he was passionate and articulate and creative. Then, as now, he wrote nihilistic poetry. He wore pants and shirts and jewellery in a myriad of styles and fabrics and somehow made the whole thing look like a cutting edge outfit. Back then he had his own interior design business. I don't ask him about it.
âThey said I was making up things about their coffee,' he says, as we sit together, drinking coffee. The tiles are hot under my buttocks and bare feet.
âThey're scared of people like me and you who have ideas and create new thoughts. They arrest us because they want our knowledge and then they torture us.' He stands up suddenly, dropping his coffee. He looks at the sky, âCriminals have more rights.'
Hot coffee is all over my face and arms and legs but I don't move.
âIf you tell the straight truth,' he says, sitting down again, âif you say, hey what the hell are you doing with your life, or if you say, hey, psychiatry is a theatre of cruelty, they can't bear it because it diminishes their power. That's when they start their experiments.'
As an inpatient I'm prescribed an interesting cocktail of medication: olanzepine, mirtazapine, lithium, periodic chlorpromazine and periodic diazepam. It is in one sense effective: I'm so sedated, so completely unable to think, so emotionally and physically numb, that The Presence's talons shrink down into matchsticks.
Friends from work, Bev and Chris and Monique visit, Zoë and Tanya and my parents visit, and I sit with them on the green vinyl couches and I'm only partially aware of their physical presence. I'm not asleep, neither am I awake.
Damien lends me some books by writers he admires. There are letters on the pages. I don't know how to turn them into words. We talk about making small, daily steps towards improving my mental state. He cajoles me out of bed in the morning for a walk in the park. Here are the oak trees â their branches like arms lending out scraps of nirvana where the sun touches the leaves.
We talk about hope. He has a kind of extraordinary faith that I'll recover, and as I do get better, I hold onto it too, like we are together clutching the string of a balloon.
Sometimes in the night I ring Aaron's rooms and recite Arthur Rimbaud into his answering machine:
Je regrette les temps où la sève du monde,
L'eau du fleuve, le sang rose des arbres verts,
Dans les veines de Pan mettaient un univers!
( . . . in the veins of Pan, a whole universe!)
âCome on,' says Josie, my allocated nurse for the morning. âShower.'
I take off my clothes and turn the water on and stand under it. I cannot touch my body. I stand for a reasonable number of minutes, turn the water off and put my clothes back on over wet skin; eyes shut tight against the engulfing mirror. Back in my room, sitting on my bed, is my dear friend Tanya, and in her arms is Ruby. I lose my breath.
âRuby,' I whisper. She smiles. Perfection. Her eyes are so clear, and blue â the blue of the sky first thing in the morning. If I could paint her, I would paint her skin with marble dust and sun-thickened linseed oil and beeswax. I would paint her superbly round head and her hands, her nose, her feet, her baby buttocks. When she smiles her three-tooth-smile, something happens to my insides. A warmth. A warmth that slips down from my brain and slides along my spinal cord and then spreads out through my heart to my fingertips and toes. I gather her up into the centre of me, I let her grasp my breast, pull my nose and I screw up my face and she laughs. I cradle her head; her fairy-fine hair and her eyes and her skin â oh all of her â merus, angelus.
We drive into the city for coffee. The air is salty and cool.
death is gathering
He leans in and leers but I have Ruby in my arms. Suddenly I can smell it, the beautiful slightly bitter smell of strong black coffee and there's a rush of saliva in my mouth and the air is salty and cool and I have Ruby in my arms and whoosh, my heart is here, my lungs, I am present.
Damien and I talk about the business of getting better. We talk about the importance of space and time and the importance of being heard.
âThere's no such thing as justice,' I say, sadly. âThose folk who are the sickest, who are terribly, awfully completely lost in the serpent arms of psychiatric illness, who need the most space and time, we're herded in and out of the acute public units like cattle.'
âVery often we provide a place when no-one else will,' says Damien. âAnd when no-one else can.'
âThere is no such thing as justice,' I say to Aaron later in the therapy room.
âYes. How are you sleeping?' he asks.
âHuh. If you were to turn us into a mathematical equation, each of us a straight line with a relationship to the x axis and the y axis, we'd probably intersect at infinity.'
âYou do make things difficult,' he says.
âShrinks,' I say to Zoë and Naava, as we sit drinking coffee in the hospital cafe. âHow can I be real, and open and honest and fragile with Aaron is so closed off he might as well be an automaton?'
âI agree,' Zoë says, sadly.
âIt reminds me of the Sanskrit expression, Namaste: the spirit in me recognises and honours the spirit in you. The light within me honours the light within you. But when the spirit and the light are withheld so completely . . .'
âFinding the right psychiatrist is not the same as finding the right orthopaedic surgeon,' Naava says, staring into her coffee. Then she looks up and we hold eyes and grin at each other.
âI mean, the point of a therapeutic relationship is that it be therapeutic,' I say. âIt makes up about 30 percent of the whole healing thing.'
â30 per cent?'
âYup. Certified evidence-based medicine.'
We sit for a while amid the hospital flotsam.
âYou know what it's like, you want to feel kinda respected and listened to,' I say. âThere's nothing worse then being dismissed or ignored, even when you're really sick. I know pharmacotherapy is important and crisis care is important and education is important, but there's got to be more to it than that. Half the time I think Aaron is just trying to stay awake. Christ, I must be boring.'
Later in the day Sarah visits and brings a phalaenopsis orchid with four blazingly white flowers. Sarah and I have been firm friends since we were 12 years old. She's eight months pregnant with her second child. How stark the contrast between us. How good it is to see her. How it hurts.
Morning. Belinda, who has the room next to ours, is sitting in the courtyard drinking coffee and smoking.
âIt's good to be thinking straight,' she says.
I sit down opposite. âHell yeah.'
âOne day I was making a cup of coffee and I realised that if I poured the boiling water over my hands, they wouldn't burn, I mean I'd become sort of invincible, and I kept telling everyone because it was so amazing and no-one believed me and I got so bloody angry and so they stuffed me in HDU for four frigging weeks! Actually, I think I did need to be there cos I was off my head, I remember one of the nurses in HDU kept telling us stories about him being an astronaut in another life and I totally believed him! Oh my god, I was on so much frigging zyprexa, I put on six kilos in four weeks, how bad is that? I just kept on eating eating eating . . . and smoking cos there's nothing else to do in HD. D'you know, I quit for a year until this last episode and now I'm back on a pack a day.'
âIt sucks,' I say. âGoing mad.'
âFucking sucks,' Belinda says.
The Presence has slid out of my consciousness and divested Himself from my body. I accept that my brain conjured Him; I don't know why. Neurotransmitters have a part to play: dopamine, serotonin, noradrenaline, but there is a difference between what we conceptualise as the brain (purely organic) and what we conceptualise as the mind, and He definitely lived in my mind.
Damien asks if I will have a chat with some first year nursing students and I agree and we sit together in one of the therapy rooms.
âThe thing with psychosis, with delusional thinking is . . .' I stop and sigh, trying to find the words. âIt's . . . well, when I'm sick I believe the delusional stuff to the same degree that you might know and believe the sky is above and the earth below. And if someone were to say to me that the delusional thinking is, in fact, delusional, well that's the same as if I assure you now that we walk on the sky. Of course you wouldn't believe me, and that's why it's sometimes so hard for people who are sick like this to accept treatment â to know that they even need treatment.'
The students are polite. They treat me like a bomb that may go off at any second.
âThe other thing about psychosis and also severe depression is that they have a huge effect on how you relate to other people and how you see the world. It's a bit like being in a vacuum, or behind a wall of really thick glass . . . you lose any sense of connectedness. You're cast adrift from everyone and everything that matters. Some people never find a way back.'
After the students leave I shake hands with the nursing staff and pack up my books and music and a few clothes. Naava and I exchange phone numbers.
âKeep safe,' I say, hugging her gently.
âYou too. See you on the outside.'
Damien isn't on shift, so I write him a letter to return with his books and my parents drive me home.
Home. Beautiful cats with their soft fur and warm bodies and candescent eyes. Books. Here I am in the same room as Toni Morrison and William Faulkner and Keri Hulme and T.S. Eliot â minds and minds and minds. I run my hands over the tops and sides of the books, feel their spines, salivate. My parents have stacked the freezer with food and cleaned the flat and washed my clothes and I'm consequently torn between gratitude and shame.
It is a further week of insensibility before I heave up the courage to ring my manager to arrange a return to work. Again the flooding gratitude that this workplace is willing to take me back at all after six weeks leave. The shame. In the intervening fortnight, I manage two things: driving from home to the cinema to see a children's film with my father, and walking to a local cafe for coffee with Melyse, after which on both occasions, I fall fast into a kind of catatonia deeper than the sea.
Naava comes to stay for a couple of weeks after her discharge from the inpatient unit. We sit together on the couch, smoking sweet, apple-flavoured tobacco through her water pipe.
âYou okay?' she asks softly.
âYeah.' I pause. Summon something like courage. All the years of building layer upon layer of internal fortification make it hard to admit I need someone. âGlad I'm not alone,' I say.
âYeah?' The ends of her mouth twitch.
âYou okay?' I ask.
She nods, eyes all tears.
We don't go out much or sleep much or say much but we listen together to Dave Matthews and Tim Reynolds and we cook together and check that the other is taking her right medication. On bad nights one will wrap the other in (1) an enormous faux-fur blanket and (2) both arms. We shore each other up like two elderly, shallow-rooted trees, side-by-side in a high wind.
With Zoë, we spend long evenings discussing Life, and whether anyone has ever really had any idea about the whole soggy point of it. We eat smoked ocean trout and stuffed vine leaves and pita bread and olives. We ruminate about meaning and relationships and loneliness and illness. In the absence of partners of our own, we form what we call an âemotional family,' meaning we'll be here for each other no matter what.
At the end of my first month back at work, there's a letter from Aaron's rooms in the mailbox. It's soggy where rain has seeped through cracks in the brick. I slide a finger under the edge of the envelope while driving to the library. It's a typed letter. A long typed letter. I pull over on the side of the road, under a streetlight. And then I take a long breath in . . . and forget to breathe out.
I've been dumped by my psychiatrist. This is not something I'd considered â Duty of Care and the Hippocratic Oath and all that. He says, in part, that I have poor insight and symptoms of psychosis. He says I'm not always compliant with his recommended treatment and I'm not always honest. His professional opinion is that my prognosis is of serious concern. He suggests I either re-connect with the Community Clinic or find another clinician. He wishes me well for the future.
I fold the letter in half and sharpen the crease and then I fold it in half again and sharpen the crease and then I fold it in half again and sharpen the crease. Once home from the library I put the fat little square of paper in the rubbish bin.
So my confusion about Psychiatry as a discipline solidifies. It was a vague mistrust in the beginning, a nebulous sense that something about the nature of the practice wasn't right.
As a medical student on psych rotations, the psychiatrists who taught us showed a modicum of respect and interest in the patients while in front of the patients (as professionalism dictates) but once we were closeted in an office, they'd discuss various symptoms as though they were disconnected from ever belonging to a human being. Sometimes they'd disbelieve a patient we'd interviewed somewhat condescendingly, or flat-out dismiss another patient's suffering. One psychiatrist said, as I was shadowing him on a public unit, âThis place is a zoo. Get into private practice as soon as you can if you do psychiatry.'
The debilitating side effects of high dose antipsychotics like mental clouding, lethargy and sedation were glossed over. One feels (every hour of every day) the slow drowsiness of having drunk a lot of alcohol without any of the associated pleasure or relaxation or emotional warmth. I wondered (then and now) if it would make a difference if these doctors themselves just once tried a low dose of the drugs they were prescribing.
Eight months away from becoming doctors ourselves, we'd had almost no teaching about the ways mental illness cause disruption to the lives of family and friends as well as to that of the sufferer, and we had little insight into the often life-long associated disability. No one ever said, âEthan over there was a highly functioning young man with a job and a lover and dreams and ambition and hope for the future. He was brought into hospital in the back of a Police van. Can you imagine the grief and confusion that must come with a diagnosis of manic-depression?'
There is always a power imbalance between a patient and physician, but I've witnessed it more acutely in psychiatry than in almost any other branch of medicine. âThem And Us.' And never the twain shall meet.
But Winsome chooses not to give up on me.
âI fully understand that all is not well and that you have been in a terrible space. It is good that you are still alive,' she says at our first session since my discharge from the inpatient unit.
âWinsome,' I say. âI'm sorry.'
âPlease do not apologise. You are in no way to blame.'
I look up from the floor fast, right into her eyes. My eyes. Hers. Oh, relief. I smile for the first time in weeks. âI was difficult and I feel bad about that. But thank you. I seem to have regained my rational mind.'
âWonderful,' she says. âFor better or worse, the last eight weeks are murky and confused â until I woke up on Sunday and felt myself.'
Winsome smiles. âWhat a relief for you.'
âI think . . . I hope . . . the blackness and the paranoia is not all of who I am.'
âI agree.'
âComing here this morning I was scared you might have had enough.'
âOf?'
âThis. Me. Us.'
Winsome waits, not staring at me, but just with her presence, creating space (in which to be honest).
âUm, because this means a lot. This. Us. I pay you, it's professional and so on, I know that. Still.'
âAnd we'll work together till you get there Kate. You will get there.'
I'm running on a beach, flat, hot, beautiful sand, water, waves, flying.
For a second.
But it's good.
âDo you think there is such a thing as a psychiatrist who sees the whole person â I mean really sees the whole person?' I ask.
âI don't know,' says Winsome.
âDamn it Winsome, all the facets of the human condition exist in a person with mental illness. Right?'
âRight.'
âDesire, love . . . search for meaning. Connection. Pain.'
âYes. Absolutely.'
âD'you know, the literal translation of psychiatry is healing of the soul.'
We sit quietly with this.
Winsome moves her consulting room to a comfortable cream Edwardian with tall roses in the front garden. The chairs are deep and soft. The courtyard has cumquat trees in pots around its edges. The cumquats are the glowing orange of just-blown-on-coals.
âWe all have a presentable face â a self that is socially acceptable and professionally acceptable,' Winsome says. âYes?'
âYes.'
âHere we are exploring the much deeper stuff. All the layers underneath.'
âYes.'
âAnd some of your layers have been hidden for a long time, and there is a lot of pain.'
I nod.
no kill her
âCan you tell me more about the pain?'
do it do it hands throat THROAT
There appear to be clouds in the room.
âIt's awfully crowded . . .' I tap my head with my index finger. Tap. Tap. Then I hunch up. There are clouds in the room.
âCrowded,' Winsome says.
âForeverandeverandever,' I whisper to the rug. My boots are purple.
âPardon?'
âClouds.'
Winsome's eyes are the only light. âTell me what is going on . . . in your mind . . . right now.'
Silence-and-clouds and
is-there-an-I and
are-they-going-to-let-me-live.
âDo you think everyone has . . .?'
âHas . . .?' says Winsome. Her voice is measured, soft.
âOther . . . I know there's the self . . .'
âYes.'
âHere,' I tap my head. Tap. Tap. âThere's a sort-of-self, a theoretical self, at least I think so, because I'm saying I . . .'
I stare at my boots. My boots are purple. Winsome thinks there are two of us in this room, but she is wrong.
kill her
Time diffracts.
âSometimes the thing called self disappears completely. There's an awful lot of black. Black bile, black dog, Black Death, and . . . I'm kind of governed.
Actually, I'm kind of suffocated.'
Hunched up. The rug is Turkish. My voice is over the other side of the room. The people in my head are going to kill her for this line of questioning, but Winsome is relaxed; still â in her chair, her neat feet quiet on the floor. She isn't bothered by the clouds.
âKate,' she says. âYou are safe here.' She pauses. âYou are safe enough to tell the truth.' She pauses. âWho is suffocating you?'
âThere's um, there's quite a lot of them,' I say.
Now the shaking. Thighs, knees. Nipples tight shut.
âThey live . . .'
Winsome's expression hasn't changed. She doesn't look like she's trying not to laugh. I open up my hands. There are little sweat-rivers in the palmar creases.
âThey live . . .' I tap my head with my index finger. Tap. Tap. âHere.'
The room has shrunk; the walls folding into a cylinder, pressing. Low cloud like fog . . . and where is the light? Winsome's eyes keep me from dying.
âYears and years and years and years and years and years and years. Jesus.'
do it do it hands throat THROAT
âSometimes they rage,' I whisper. âSometimes it's do this, do this and then they laugh.'
And then my breath runs out.
Gag.
shhhh
âShhhh,' I whisper. Frozen. I have given them up â a betrayal, and they are like Medusa: snaky-headed, potent gazed. Perseus severed Medusa's head from her body and not even that curtailed her power. Poisonous vipers grew from the spilt drops of her blood.
you bitch
this is the end
They are in unison. They are around my throat and my life is in my throat and air isn't moving anymore and evidently this is the end.
Winsome waits until my breathing rights itself. After a long time I look up and nod and smile and wipe the sweat from around my eyes and lips.
âJesus,' I say in my ordinary voice. âThe clouds have gone.' I move forward in the seat to stand up but my knees won't straighten.
âTake your time,' Winsome says.
âSorry,' I say, flushing and suddenly cold. I look up again. The room is cream and softly lit and I'm still alive. I've told someone about . . . and I'm fucking well still alive.
All night I sit in bed with cats asleep around me and think. Meaning. Illness. Ordinary life. The beauty of ordinary life and the enormousness of
their
power,
their
truth,
their
meaning. The cats stretch and sigh, air fluffing through their noses. Their eyelids flutter as they dream. On my bedroom wall is Marc Chagall's painting,
Three Candles
: a twilight world of rapt figures in which the gold candles throw yellow through blue and lovers embrace the sky in a dreamy elegance; their hands touch among fruiting lilacs. Orange angels populate the boughs with fully fleshed bodies attached to wings ethereal as cotton flowers. It is enough.
In the morning I walk to the train station with the sun low in the eastern sky. The air feels new in my mouth and lungs. The people in my head are hissing as usual and I can feel the heat of their eyes but I can also hear Winsome's voice, low and soft, âYou are safe'. So I get on the train, stand in the corner of the carriage, headphones on, books clutched, and I get off at the right station and go to work. And all through the day and into the evening when I walk from work into the city, I wonder . . . at the possibility . . . that
their
truth may not be the truth.
I've believed them, all of them, since I was sixteen â fifteen years of bitter acumen, sarcasm, bile and vomit, fifteen years of their ability to halve and quarter me. I am naked before them and whenever they see my body their laughter is high and mirthless. They have always outwitted me.
And now. Given that I'm standing here on the steps of Flinders Street Station, oddly enough alive . . .
Oddly enough alive.
The dusk air carries with it the colours of the sunset â carmine red and cadmium scarlet and magenta â smooth as honey on my skin. I sit on the steps until the almostblack sky is above and all around. There are no stars.
A week later Winsome draws a picture of my brain.
âWe know you have a presenting self â let's put that towards the front. Then there's the . . . cacophony, made up of the voices and their judgements and criticisms and bullying. And in between is a sliver of real self.'
âReal self? Huh.'
âYes indeed. And one of our goals here is to manage the cacophony and to find some space in which the real self can grow.'
Then Winsome says, âWho are you, Kate? What makes up your real self?'
I think about this for a while. âMost of the time, about twenty percent of me is alive in the external world and the rest flails about . . . mired, stammering . . . in the internal world.'
âThat must be very tiring,' says Winsome.
âYes. â
eeeeeeeee shhhh die do it doit THROAT
I close my eyes. Put my hands around my throat.
âTake your hands away from your throat, Kate,' says Winsome. âTell me what's happening.'
Her voice is safe.
I sit on my hands to keep them under control.
I take a breath.
Then I say, very quietly, âThere were only three of them to begin with â BANG â when I was sixteen. I don't know where they came from. At first I kept looking around to see if anyone else heard them shouting, but no one ever did. And then I assumed everyone had, you know,
other
 . . . but that it was something private, like vaginitis, so I never said anything and I practiced a pleasant face. No matter what they said . . . no matter what they said, I trained myself not to react. Now when they order me to do things, I do it with a smile.'
Winsome doesn't look aghast and nor is she laughing. âThank you for sharing this with me,' she says. âHow did you train yourself not to react?'