“And
The Rubáiyát,”
said Isadora, “his favorite poem. I will read part of that.”
“Of course, Miss Wing,” said the rabbi, deferential to the
idea
of Fame, even if he'd never heard of the person. “Of course.”
So it was that Isadora came to read her blasphemous memoir to an audience consisting of her sister, her mother, her father, her aunt, her cousins, her husband, two ex-husbands (one a psychiatrist, the other a psychotic), assorted friends and acquaintances-and one horrified rabbi.
“As I begin writing this, my grandfather is dying in a hospital in Spring Valley, New York, dying alone, with paid nurses to attend him, dying thousands of miles from the town
in
Russia where he was born ninety-seven years agoâa town I do not even know the name of.
“I am writing, fast, my pen speeding over the page, writing in the hopes that if I get it all down, get it right (or as nearly right as an American granddaughter can), it will ease his passageâor mine. I know that death is a movement toward lightâor so I said once in a poem-but I also know that to die by inches, and every inch alone, is neither light nor justâthough it is common.
“He was a painter. He should have died the minute he could no longer paint, the minute the cataracts, the cancer, the arthritis, the exhaustion, the despair overwhelmed him. But that would be too simple, and just as we do not choose our loves or our children, we do not choose our deaths. I have known a number of men in their nineties who died by inchesâKurt Hammer, Louis Untermeyer, and my grandfatherâand each at the end truly wished to die, but his wish was no command.
“I knew him only and always as Papa. My parents were Jude and Nat in that phony thirties tradition of parents-as-pals. We all lived to regret it. But Papa was the patriarchâwith all the good and bad that word implies. In a house full of artists, he had the best studio, the only studio. Amongst daughter-painters he held his maulstick like a magic wand (or a bludgeon) over their heads.”
Normally Isadora was a good reader. She could hold an audience captive with her incantatory poems; she could read other people's poems and novels with the conviction of a born actress. But reading this painfully self-revelatory memoir, her conviction faltered, her palms sweated. She stood at the shaky lectern, wishing she had something more to hold on to. She had nothing, not even Papa's hand. She had committed herself to this as one commits oneself to childbirthâat a moment one would commit to anything.
“When I was born, it seems he was already an old man. In fact, he was only fifty-nine. He wore round wire-rimmed glasses and painted in the witch-hatted studio that crowned the triplex apartment on Seventy-seventh Street where I grew up. That curious gothic apartment house terminates skyward in a trapezoidal roof containing a huge northern window which rattled (perhaps still rattles) in the wind that the Museum of Natural History fails to block. The window shades were dull forest green and drawn up on pulleys from below; a trapdoor separated the studio from the rest of the house. On one wall of the studio hung a death mask of Beethoven, as mute in white plaster as his ears became at the end. Only the wind penetrated those ears; and his domed eyes were sightless as well. This blind Beethoven was watched, however, by an open-eyed Voltaire, present in a bust of the same dusty white plaster.
“On Halloween, a sheet would be draped from Beethoven's mask, a candle placed next to a jawless skull perched on my grandfather's heavy, paint-spattered easel, and we children would gather, teeth chattering, for the tale of Dracula, told by my mother in this witchi est of settings. Here, in the heart of New York, was Transylvaniaâor as near to it as one could get.
“I was too little. My older sister's friendsâfive years olderâwere having the party and I was just allowed, as special grace, to creep up the studio stairs, sit upon the middle step, and listen.
“Never have I regretted any grace so much! The stake might as well have been driven through my heart; the bats might as well have flown through my skull. The nightmare galloped through my dreams for years after that fatal story hour! An evil that cannot die indeed!âbut my grandfather lives on, being transfused when he wishes to die, being X-rayed when he has no lungs, being spiked through the hand and heart with tubes and needles like the living dead.”
Nice, she thought. Dracula in the intensive-care unit. That was indeed how intensive-care units always made her feel.
“The skull, the death mask, the bust of Voltaire, the easelâthese were my grandfather's artifacts and amulets. In the studio, there were also two damp, domed closets. One contained canvas by the roll and stretchers and tacks (my grandfather always stretched his own canvases and nearly always bashed his thumb), and another contained mysterious clothes left by mysterious sitters. A general's dress jacket, but no pants or hat; an evening gown of a style to do Mme. Vionnet proud (all paillettes and pastel chiffon); a double-breasted blazer which might have been worn to Cliveden by the Duke of Windsor.
“Papa was a portrait painter for a living (in the thirties he'd done movie posters for MGM) and his sitters were all posh, upper-class, and gentile. They rarely deigned to come, but sent instead their photographs, their clothes, a lock of hair, a swatch of fabric.
“ âWho's that?' I used to ask about the pink-faced, pinstriped, three-piece-suited man whose glowing oil-painted image (still wet) was perched on the easel.
“ âMr. Johnson,' Papa would reply.
“ âWho's that?' I would ask the next day, when the easel bore his white-haired consort in pearls and robinâs-egg blue silk.
“ âMrs. Johnson,' Papa would say.
“I soon found out the two were no relation. Johnson was simply the most goyish name that came to mind. All the paying customers were Johnsonâwhile the voluminous black nudes who posed at the Art Students League, or the Spanish guitarists lured in to pose for a day, all had their own particular first names. Velda or Luis or Roberto or Geneva. Only the clientele were scorned and nameless âpainted for money, not love.
“(What I learned from this was: always write for love not money, but try to be paid for it, too.)”
Aha, thought Isadora, this is true. My whole life's lesson, gleaned from Grandpa: write for love, but do not love merely in order to write about it.
“He passed his legacy on to meâhe who painted at the top of the house (as I now write above the family roar). I was never banned from his studio; nor is my daughter banned from mine. âI am writing a novel, Mommy,' Amanda says, at twoâas I, at two, painted âMr. Johnson' and âMrs. Johnson' alongside my grandfather.
“ âWho's in your novel, Mandy?'
“ âKermit the Frog an' Mickey Mouse, Mommy, Daddy ... But not Lucinda.' (Lucinda is the little girl Amanda loves to hate, her best/worst friend in the world.)
Yes, thought Isadora, such relationships begin early. Catullus was right: “I hate and I love” is the essence of life.
“The smell of oil paints and turpentine so infused my childhood that I've only to pass an artist's studio to be plunged back, through the infallible offices of that Mnemosyne who lives in the nose, to my childhood.”
Smells, she thought. Why do smells trigger memory so insistently? She'd read once that the olfactory lobes are the oldest parts of the brain, what we have in common with the “lower” mammals âif you considered dogs and dromedaries lower, which she didn't. Isadora was a great smeller. She had always liked gamy men, found them sexier than the overbathed variety. And as for herself, she spent fortunes on perfumes, her current favorite being Opium. “If you smell good, you can conquer the world,” she used to quip. Her perfumes had “progressed” from Chanel No. 5 in high school, to Shalimar in college, Ma Griffe in graduate school, Fidji when she first met Josh, Bal a Versailles and Joy for their good years, and Opium since the birth of her daughter made her, at last, a woman. What could that possibly mean? That womanhood itself required an opiate?
“The tools of the painter's trade are as familiar to me as the tools of my own tradeâand as precious. The sable brushes: Papa always washed them in the kitchen sink, at five each night, by painting them against a wet block of Ivory soap; the colors swirled in the soap, merged to become a muddy brown, then drifted away down the drain, leaving the soap white again. The turpentine: a smell of trees and forests; the primal smell of nature becoming art. The golden linseed oil: its sheen on the canvas when wet, and its strange gelatinous drops when it fell upon the easel and congealed. The Windsor and Newton paints in silvery cylindrical tubes, with their poetic names: alizarin crimson, cerulean blue, rose madder, vermilion, burnt umber, zinc white.”
Reading aloud these names of paints, Isadora suddenly became comfortableâwarmed, as it were, to her cold subject (like an after-dinner speaker hearing his first round of laughter, or an actor his first round of applause). The paint names had particular resonance for her. They evoked her childhood, like the smell of turpentine. What the hell, she thought, the speech was starting to flow. For better or for worse, she was into it.
“ âA good painter never uses black,' Papa would say, âonly
shmearers
use black.' Since black is all the colors put together, it was an article of Papa's faith that you made black yourself with hues of your own choosing. And you looked for the special colors in the blackâthe plums, the aubergines, the sea-floor greens. Black was not black, but dark violet or murky green. Nor was white white. It was ivory or eggshell or bluish or iridescent pearl. Once, when I was thirteen and already at the High School of Music and Art, Papa made me attempt a still life of eggs and onions, cut crystal and white satin, just to prove to me how many colors were in âwhite.' It was a lesson I never forgot.â
“Nor was there such a thing as âflesh color'âwhatever my Crayola box might say. Flesh was pink or ocher, ivory or greenish blue, brownish gold with umber shadows. Caucasians might be pinkish, yellowish, greenishâbut never white; and blacks (Papa would have objected to the term black not because he was a racist, but because of its color-blind inaccuracy) were brownish, creamy, even purplish where shadows were cast upon their faces. Orientals might be amber, golden, greenâbut never âyellow.' The world of race was a world of multicolored shadows; Papa taught me about dapple long before I read Gerard Manley Hopkins.”
Here she looked into her audience and was again seized with self-consciousness. Bennett Wing, her Chinese-American second husband, sat in the audience looking inscrutable, as usual. Seven years had elapsed since she'd seen him, but he was ageless and unchanged, immortal perhaps. Or so it seemed. More gray in his thick hair was his only sign of age; his face was as unlined as ever. Perhaps he'd die that wayâthe Chinese Dorian Gray. Isadora had, after all, thought her grandfather immortal and here he was mocking her with his mortality. Bennett was surely mortal, too, despite his Buddha mask. Age could not wither him. He was pickled in psychoanalysis.
The black husband of a friend of Aunt Gilda's also betrayed no flicker of emotion at her reference to race. Unfortunately, we were living at a time in history when
any
reference to race was likely to be regarded as racism and Papa was of that benighted generation which said “Negro.” Though she was only his Horatio, not the protagonist of the piece, somehow she felt guilty for his sins, charged with his debts of conscience.
“If the world was truly multicolored for him, then why was it so black? For one cannot write about Papa without chronicling his depression. A chronic and contagious depressive, he spread such gloom to his children and grandchildren that often they wished to escape him. âLife,' he said, âwas pointless' ('till the endâwhen his tune changed). His philosophy, often statedâuntil it made us furiousâwas that the artists and intellectuals of the world carried the âdead weight' along. We made life; they ate it up. We created light; they muddied it into darkness. I had a vision of my grandfather's beautiful white cake of Ivory soap, turning to mud under the mingled paints from his brush. That was what the world did to artists; that was how
they
treated
us.
Isadora had vowed from earliest adolescence never to be bitter like her grandfather. She would risk
everything
with her work, show the world who she was. If they liked itânne. And if not, at least she had committed herself. She would not die wondering.
“Papa's bitterness had, like all bitternesses, a personal foundation beneath the lofty generalization: he was unsung. Through no fault of the worldâs, really, but only his own.
“True, he had had the ill luck to be born in the era that saw the birth of âModern Art.' True, he was painting figuratively when Cha- gall and Picasso were in the saddle. True, he emulated Rembrandt and Vandyke in a world that emulated only Picassoâbut still, his very eccentricity might have been turned to advantageâhad he not been so eager to stand in his own light. For he had an absolutely unerring knack for alienating anyone who might do him good. Art critics, collectors, gallery ownersâhe would alienate with a swift insult, like a knee to the groin! Art critics he pronounced blind, and gallery owners venal (with which many artists would heartily agree âbut not to their faces). As if this weren't enough, Papa steadfastly and resolutely concealed the very best of his work from public view. The stiff, formal portraits he exhibited; the dream sketches (as he called them), he hid away. These sketchesâdone in india ink and watercolor, fountain pen and pencilâare to me his best work. They are also astoundingly original and âmodern' in a timeless, untrendy way.”