Read Priceless: The Case That Brought Down the Visa/MasterCard Bank Cartel Online

Authors: Lloyd Constantine

Tags: #Antitrust, #Business & Economics, #History, #Law, #Nonfiction, #Retail

Priceless: The Case That Brought Down the Visa/MasterCard Bank Cartel

BOOK: Priceless: The Case That Brought Down the Visa/MasterCard Bank Cartel
2.74Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
The Case that Brought Down the
Visa/MasterCard Bank Cartel


Lloyd Constantine

Copyright © 2009, 2012 by Lloyd Constantine

All Rights Reserved. No part of this book may be reproduced in any manner without the express written consent of the publisher, except in the case of brief excerpts in critical reviews or articles. All inquiries should be addressed to Skyhorse Publishing, 307 West 36th Street, 11th Floor, New York, NY 10018.

Skyhorse Publishing books may be purchased in bulk at special discounts for sales promotion, corporate gifts, fund-raising, or educational purposes. Special editions can also be created to specifications. For details, contact the Special Sales Department, Skyhorse Publishing, 307 West 36th Street, 11th Floor, New York, NY 10018 or
[email protected]

Skyhorse® and Skyhorse Publishing® are registered trademarks of Skyhorse Publishing, Inc.®, a Delaware corporation.

10 9 8 7 6 5 4 3 2 1

Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data is available on file.

ISBN: 978-1-61608-375-5

eISBN: 978-1-62087-549-0

Printed in the United States of America.

This book and the work it chronicles are dedicated to

Jan, Isaac, Sarah, Elizabeth, “Connie,” and Edna

They are the reason for my life.


PROLOGUE: An Expensive Dinner for MasterCard

PART I: Origins

Opening Statement

The Cartel Revealed

Going Private

Wal-Mart, The Double-Edged Sword

The Teams Line Up

PART II: Six Battles

The Tide Turns

The United States Hitches a Ride

Five Merchants Become Five Million

Unsealing the Shark

Double Jeopardy

Visa/MasterCard’s Hail Marys

PART III: Endgame

Preparing for Trial

Breaking the Deadlock



Closing Statement

2012: Motion to Reconsider




An Expensive Dinner
for MasterCard

HE NIGHT OF July 10, 1989, I hosted a buffet dinner at my Manhattan apartment for my fellow assistant attorneys general from fourteen states. Everyone assembled on West Sixty-Sixth Street for my mostly green banquet of chili, broccoli soup, salad, tabouleh, and pasta with pesto. Although the get-together at my place was intended to be social, allowing me to show off my wife and kids and our views of Central Park and the Chagall windows of the Metropolitan Opera House to colleagues from cities like Baton Rouge and Austin, the dinner conversation was dominated by a discussion of the credit card giants, Visa and MasterCard, whose combined market share was more than 95 percent. These companies had announced the merger of their separate debit card networks, forming a new joint network called “Entree.” The general opinion was that this debit card merger was designed to dominate that fledgling but inevitably huge business and destroy competing debit card networks like NYCE, MAC, STAR, and Shazam.

The fourteen states had responded to the announcement of the merger with a letter stating their intent to sue Visa and MasterCard. As head of the task force that coordinated antitrust enforcement for all fifty states, I was lead counsel of the team. The investigation that had led up to that day had taken sixteen months, and we were now ready to act. The lawsuit we would soon file against Visa and MasterCard was not merely the culmination of that sixteen-month probe: It was the tangible result of nearly a decade of work. That night, we talked about the progress that the states had made in our efforts to fill the void created by the Reagan administration’s virtual abdication of antitrust enforcement. Many of my dinner guests had participated in every step of this effort.

A full-day meeting with Visa had occurred that day, and a similar meeting with MasterCard was scheduled for the next day. Meetings like those we were holding with the bankcard associations are usually offered to target companies prior to civil suit or indictment. They rarely change anything but are used by both sides as an opportunity to learn something from the other side prior to formal hostilities. These particular meetings, however, wound up changing the entire course of dealings between me and the targets, and especially with MasterCard.

The meeting earlier that day with Visa had been polite, if inconsequential. Most of it had been consumed by Visa’s substantially and sadly accurate explanation of how the symbiotic relationship between Visa and MasterCard and the lack of real competition between them was the product of antitrust enforcement decisions made by our counterparts in the Federal Antitrust Division. By 1989, the antitrust laws had been sapped of much of their vitality. After eight years, in which Reagan administration antitrust officials had systematically dismantled the enforcement agencies and waged a campaign in Congress and the courts to trivialize the law, state attorney general (AG) enforcement,
which I coordinated, was the last and only line of defense. Visa predicted that if the state AGs were to try to break up the Entree joint venture, we would fail—as the many previous antitrust suits against Visa and MasterCard had.

At 11:00 PM that night, after my dinner with the other Assistant AGs and hours before a scheduled meeting with MasterCard, Tim Cone, a young colleague, called to tell me about a conversation he had overheard at former baseball star Rusty Staub’s new restaurant on Fifth Avenue. Tim, his fiancee Diana, and his father Terry Cone, a senior partner at the Cleary Gottlieb law firm, heard three men discussing the meeting they were going to have with me the next day. The men said that an investigator would be hired to uncover something about me that I wouldn’t want revealed and that they would threaten to expose me unless I backed off MasterCard.

From Tim’s description, I was reasonably sure that one of the three men was Bob Norton, MasterCard’s general counsel, and that another was Stanley Robinson, a senior antitrust partner at the Kaye Scholer law firm. I told Tim that I didn’t take the conversation seriously and considered it macho dinner bluster, perhaps fueled by alcohol. Tim put Terry Cone on the phone, who related the same story and told me that the discussion about the investigator had come in the middle of a sober, serious, and straight-faced discussion of legal issues and tactics that would be used to defend MasterCard. He said he had practiced law for many years, knew what he had heard, and was positive that the men were serious about their plan to investigate and then threaten me.

I called my boss, New York Attorney General Bob Abrams, and we convened a midnight conference call with Mary Ellen Burns, the chief of the AG’s Public Advocacy Division, and Jack Ryan, our chief of criminal prosecutions, who had skillfully conducted the highly publicized Tawana Brawley grand jury investigation, involving
sensationalized allegations of sexual abuse and mistreatment of a teenage African-American girl by white police and prosecutors in an upstate New York community. We agreed that I should call back the Cones and ask whether they would identify the three men prior to the meeting. I also asked them immediately to memorialize the conversation they had overheard, without further discussing it. They agreed to do this. The Cones also told me that the men had agreed to walk out of the meeting at exactly 12:30 PM and say that there was “nothing more to discuss.”

The next day, prior to the meeting, the three MasterCard lawyers were identified by Tim Cone, who was positioned behind a glass barrier where he could see, but not be seen from, inside the room where he was positioned. Then the meeting began. In contrast to the previous day’s meeting with Visa, the session with MasterCard was aimless. The three MasterCard lawyers talked and joked with each other and broke four times in just two and a half hours. At precisely 12:30 PM they got up, and Bob Norton said that the meeting was over because there was “nothing further to discuss.” I realized that the Cones were probably correct about what they had heard the night before.

According to a plan that we had established the previous night, I asked the MasterCard lawyers to speak with me privately and escorted them into Mary Ellen Burns’s office, where she and Jack Ryan were waiting. Turning to Norton, now identified as the lawyer who had said I would be investigated and threatened, I asked if they had dined at Rusty Staub’s restaurant the previous night.

“Yes,” Norton said.

I asked Norton if he were hiring an investigator to try to uncover illegal or embarrassing activities I had or was engaged in. Norton unraveled. He just started talking: “Oh my God, Oh my God. I know you’re not
supposed to talk in bathrooms. I know you’re not supposed to talk in elevators. I said it. I said it. But I didn’t mean it! It was a joke. You’ve got to believe me, it was a joke! No matter what we found out about you, we wouldn’t use it. If you used drugs, we wouldn’t use it. If we found out about some weird sexual behavior, we wouldn’t use it. No matter what, we wouldn’t use it. Lloyd, you’ve got to believe me!”

Norton continued to rattle on about other illegal and embarrassing things they might uncover if they were to investigate me, which they wouldn’t have, but in any event would never reveal about me. This went on for a while in a panicked stream of consciousness reminiscent of Sherman McCoy’s confession in Tom Wolfe’s
The Bonfire of the Vanities.
Stanley Robinson and the other MasterCard lawyer seemed paralyzed. Robinson finally said, “Bob, shut up.”

I turned to Robinson, a man then in his late sixties and one of the big names in antitrust at the Kaye Scholer law firm, which then had one of the premier antitrust practices in the United States. I told him that if he wanted to know something about me, he didn’t have to hire an investigator—he could just ask his law partner and my friend, Josh Greenberg, or Bob Kandel in his firm’s real estate department, who was my classmate at both Williams College and Columbia Law School.

BOOK: Priceless: The Case That Brought Down the Visa/MasterCard Bank Cartel
2.74Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

Other books

The Death Dealer by Heather Graham
Behaving Like Adults by Anna Maxted
President Fu-Manchu by Sax Rohmer
We Live Inside You by Johnson, Jeremy Robert
Helion by Olivia March
Task Force Black by Mark Urban
Rotten to the Core by Kelleher, Casey