Read Rothstein Online

Authors: David Pietrusza

Tags: #Urban, #New York (State), #Sociology, #Social Science, #True Crime, #20th Century, #Criminology, #New York (N.Y.), #New York, #General, #Criminals & Outlaws, #Criminals, #baseball, #Sports & Recreation, #Nineteen twenties, #Biography & Autobiography, #Crime, #Biography, #History

Rothstein (20 page)

BOOK: Rothstein
11.83Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
ads

Numerous attempts were made to rob Rothstein. Several succeeded; several didn’t. Not all were by professionals. Early in his career-just after establishing his gambling house on West 46th Street in 1909-Arnold entered the Metropole’s dining room. An armed man snarled, “Now, you Blankity-Blank, give me that five thousand dollars you owe me or I’ll kill you.”

Arnold realized the man wasn’t a criminal or even a sore loser; he was, in the parlance of the times, simply a lunatic. Arnold spoke calmly. “Of course, I’ll pay you the money. But right now you look tired and hungry, and I haven’t the money with me anyway. I tell you what. You come with me, and I’ll fix you up with something to eat, and a good Turkish bath, and then I’ll get the money I owe you, and give it to you.” They went off together to the baths. From there A. R. called Bellevue Hospital and had his assailant put under observation.

The most notable use of force to relieve A. R. of his bankroll happened on Wednesday night, May 16, 1917. Rothstein had organized a highstakes card game at a second-floor suite of West 47th Street’s Hotel St. Francis. The game’s thirty-odd participants included several well-heeled professionals, including Herbert Bayard Swope. A. R. employed the unusual precautions, but took one chance. In recent weeks gunmen had robbed several big games, relieving players of cash, jewelry, and sundry valuables. One individual had attended a high percentage of them. Rothstein invited him to attend the night’s festivities.

The game started at 10:00 P.M. Four hours later, four masked men entered the hotel. One pointed his gun at the desk clerk; the others took the elevator upstairs, ordering the night bellboy to lead them to Rothstein’s rooms. When the bellboy rapped on the door, they burst in. One ordered: “Now, all of you stand up against the wall, hold your hands up in the air, and don’t make a peep.”

Arnold knew who had betrayed him. He also knew what to do to minimize losses, kicking his bankroll (somewhere between $20,000 and $60,000) under the carpet. All the while he maintained eye contact with his Judas. “Rothstein always reacted faster than any other man I ever knew,” Swope recalled. “This was as good an example of his reaction time as you could want. There were only a few seconds for him to figure out what was happening. He didn’t need more than one or two. But hiding the roll was only part of what he had to do. He had to make certain the tipster didn’t tell the holdup men where the bankroll was.

“His eyes were on that man from the moment the door swung open. He kept him under constant watch all the time the holdup was going on.”

A. R. saved the bulk of his bankroll, but lost $2,600 in cash, his gold pocket watch, and pearl stickpin.

While one intruder kept his weapon trained on his victims, his two partners collected their loot, becoming increasingly relaxed. One even removed his mask. Approaching Cleveland gambler Eddie Katz, he asked. “Haven’t I seen you in Cleveland?” Eddie mumbled he might have, and his interrogator responded, “Well, when you get back give my best regards to your friends, and tell ‘em how well I’m making out.”

That was as far as his sentimentality extended as he grabbed Katz’s jeweled stickpin. “Hey,” wailed Katz, “won’t you leave me that. I’d rather give you twice as much money as it’s worth, and keep it.”

“Don’t worry, I’ll send you the pawn ticket. What’s your address?”

The other robber examined A. R.‘s stickpin, asking its worth. “Thirty-five hundred,” Rothstein said.

“I’ll take it,” said the gunman, adding, “I’ll send you the pawn ticket, A. R.”

Arnold didn’t like being mocked. Nor did he like losing the stickpin-the only item of jewelry the sartorially conservative gambler wore. It meant a great deal to him. “Don’t bother,” A. R. responded. “I’ll have it back before the mail arrives tomorrow morning.”

When the robbers left, there wasn’t much for everyone to do. No one called the police. Rothstein lifted the carpet and retrieved his bankroll. He had Abe Attell-and his suspected betrayer-join him for coffee. He didn’t particularly want to see his “friend” again, but brought him along out of caution. “I thought the bastards might be waiting for me outside,” he later told Swope, “and, if they were, I was going to make sure that fellow got what was coming to him.”

Swope wanted Rothstein to talk to the police, goading him that he was simply afraid to bring the law into the case, and conveyed Police Commissioner Arthur Woods’s comments: A. R. was “yellow.”

“People know better,” Arnold responded. “I never take my troubles to the cops. Why do I need them? The fence got this back to me [he pointed to his stickpin] before breakfast.”

Swope bore in: “They’re laughing at you, Arnold. The word is out that you’re buffaloed.” That got to him. Never before, and never again, would Arnold formally go to the police for justice. This time he did.

Police responded with surprising-or, perhaps, not so surprisingalacrity. Within a few days, they arrested two suspects: a thirty-fiveyear-old small-time hoodlum named Eugene F. Price and twenty eight-year-old drug addict Albert “Killer” Johnson. Johnson was more dangerous, twice having been charged with murder.

Note: All illustrations are courtsey of the author’s collection unless otherwise noted. Above left • Lower East Side Tammany chieftain, State Senator “Big Tim” Sullivan (center) helped give Rothstein his start. Above right • Times Square gambler, Herman “Beansy” Rosenthal’s inability to keep his mouth shut got him killed in July 1912. Below • Beansy Rosenthal’s funeral-his casket was carried from his 104 West 45th Street gambling house.

Courtesy Library of Congress.

Above left • Lower East Side gang leader Big Jack Zelig-was he killed because he knew the truth about Herman Rosenthal’s murder?

Above right • Manhattan District Attorney Charles S. Whitman rode the Rosenthal murder case all the way to the New York governor’s mansion.

Above • Former featherweight boxing champion Abe Attell was A.R.‘s gambling buddy and bodyguard-as well as his indiscreet henchman in fixing the 1919 World Series.

Right • Chicago White Sox starting pitcher Eddie Cicotte was a key member of the 1919 World Series fix.

Police Lieutenant Charles Becker (shown with his wife Helen) went to the chair for Herman Rosenthal’s murder. Courtesy Library of Congress.

Above right • Byron “Ban” Johnson. The most powerful man in baseball thought he had a deal with the man who fixed the World Series.

Above left • New York Governor Alfred E. Smith was the prized protege of Big Tom Foley, a key Rothstein contact at Tammany Hall.

Left • New York Giants owner Charles Stoneham (left) depended on A.R. to protect his crooked Wall Street operations from the law. His manager, John McGraw (right), was Rothstein’s partner in a popular Herald Square pool hall.

Above left • Saloonkeeper Charles Francis Murphy was Tammany’s smartest boss.

Above right • Jules “Nicky” Arnstein. Debonair international con man. Multimilliondollar bond thief. Wandering husband of Fanny Brice. Arnold Rothstein’s admirer, partner, and fall guy.

Right • Broadway star Fannie Brice married Nicky Arnstein in 1918.

Above • Jack “Legs” Diamond was Rothstein’s bodyguard and henchman in rumrunning and labor racketeering.

Left • Broadway actress Lillian Lorraine steered rich suckers to Rothstein’s gambling houses and card games. Courtesy of John Kenrick, The Musicals 101. com.

Above • Arnold Rothstein operated one of Saratoga Springs’ most lavish gambling houses, The Brook, just outside of town. Inset • A gambling chip from The Brook.

Below left • Swarthy West Coast gambler Nate Raymond (left) took A. R. for $300,000 in a single card game, but never collected.

Above • Titanic Thompson, the country-boy cardsharp and legendary golf hustler who sat in on Rothstein’s fatal card game at Jimmy Meehan’s.

Top • Bill “The Great Mouthpiece” Fallon, the Roaring ’20s’ most flamboyant and successful criminaldefense attorney, did a lot of business with A. R., but that didn’t keep the duo from profoundly despising one another.

Above • Marion Davies’s relationship with William Randolph Hearst was key to Bill Fallon’s defense on witness bribery charges.

Swope feared that A. R. would back out of testifying against Price and Johnson. He told A. R. of Police Commissioner Woods’s new remarks: “Well, I guess your friend, Arnold Rothstein, is yellow after all. I thought he was going through against those thugs that held him up. If he doesn’t identify them, the police won’t have any case.”

A. R. testified. Both criminals were convicted. As Killer Johnson’s guilty verdict came in, he had to be restrained from attacking Arnold, threatening revenge if he ever got free. Two months later, Johnson escaped from Sing Sing.

A. R.‘s friends advised him to leave town-or at least go into seclusion. Worried that his gamesmanship might now lead to his friend’s death, Swope nervously advised Rothstein to leave town. Arnold wouldn’t listen and phoned Carolyn.

“If I ran away people would know that I was buffaloed,” he told her. “I’d be finished. I have to stay here.”

“I’d rather you were buffaloed than dead,” Carolyn said.

“It’s the same thing,” he answered her. “A man who backs down is finished. Well, I won’t be finished that way. I’ll just have to take the chance that they’ll catch Johnson before he shoots or, if they don’t, that he’ll miss when he does shoot.”

“Then you are afraid?”

“I’m afraid, all right. There are only two people who know that, though. You and me. We’re the only two people in the world I trust enough to let them know it.”

Johnson came close to finding Rothstein several times. One night he tailed A. R. to Reisenweber’s, on Columbus Circle. Johnson waited outside in a cab, sending word to Arnold that someone wanted to see him. A. R. didn’t take the bait. He sent private detective Val O’Farrell outside to investigate. Johnson fled and shortly thereafter left New York for the Midwest.

There Johnson tried robbing a particularly vulnerable-looking small-town bank. He had not, however, counted on its unusual alarm system. Instead of merely alerting the local police, it rang in dozens of local homes. The citizenry grabbed their rifles and shotguns and headed in the direction of their deposits. Arnold Rothstein never had to worry about the late Albert “Killer” Johnson again.

Armed robbery was thus an occupational hazard. Before 1918 ended, robbers again victimized a Rothstein floating crap game, this time in Harlem. He lost $28,000.

Both that robbery and the St. Francis robbery were mere prologues to a far more significant event. On January 19, 1919, A. R. staged a highstakes dice game at a fourth-floor apartment at 301 West 57th Street. It ignited a controversial sequence of events that saw Rothstein shoot three police officers, escape unindicted, and obtain the prosecution of the police inspector who dared to question these circumstances. “I don’t think,” said Carolyn Rothstein, “there is a better instance than this … of the very genuine influence which my husband exerted at the height of his career.”

Nineteen other gamblers were present, including Arnold’s sometime bodyguard, Abe Attell. Arnold held the dice and announced, “Four is my point.” Up came a four. “Little Joe,” he said softly but appreciatively.

Suddenly he heard heavy rapping. A gambler gingerly opened the thick wooden door, secured partly by a chain. A gruff voice barked: “Open up, there!”

Rothstein immediately fired three times through the door’s upper half. The invaders pushed hard upon the door, caving it in. A hand unfastened the chain. Eight men poured in-not robbers, but police detectives led by Inspector Dominic Henry. Detective John McLaughlin shouted that they were police.

Rothstein’s shots had hit McLaughlin and detectives John J. Walsh and Dick Oliver. McLaughlin took a bullet in the shoulder. It wasn’t serious. Walsh suffered a very minor flesh wound to his right arm, hardly more than a crease. Rothstein’s third shot tore through Oliver’s left sleeve and singed his arm, a wound hardly worth mentioning. Still, A. R. had shot a trio of cops.

“Where’s Rothstein?” barked one detective, clearly tipped off as to who ran this game.

A. R. had vanished. For a man of no athletic skill or interest, Rothstein possessed remarkable dexterity. Once, he was dining at a Manhattan restaurant. The room momentarily went black, but when the lights returned, A. R. no longer sat where he’d been. He had bolted from his chair, maneuvered silently through total darkness and a crowded midtown restaurant, and serenely ensconced himself at another table. If anyone wanted to shoot Arnold Rothstein in any darkened room, he wouldn’t make it easy.

And so A. R., after wounding three policemen, had similarly disappeared. Rothstein’s companions denied that he’d been in the room. The police didn’t believe them, searching the flat but finding no trace of the man. While they packed the gamblers into a paddy wagon, a bystander informed them that a man was hiding on the second-floor fire escape.

Police arrested the elusive but still nonplussed Mr. Rothstein. He proved extremely gracious. Were detectives Walsh and McLaughlin injured? No need to travel by ambulance, boys-take my limousine.

Magistrate Francis X. Mancuso ordered $1,000 bail for each defendant. Arnold paid it all, with a neat stack of $1,000 gold notes. It seemed nothing of consequence would result from the shooting of three cops. Police graciously excused the action, noting apologetically that they should have been more specific in demanding entry. It was only reasonable for gamblers to fear robbery and act accordingly. Of the daily press, only William Randolph Hearst’s American bothered to report that Rothstein was suspected of the shooting.

Rothstein engaged Bill Fallon and former Magistrate Emil E. Fuchs as counsel. Fallon was a master of delay, his theory being that the first reports of a crime tend to inflame public imagination. Let the furor die down, and chances for acquittal increase dramatically.

And so they did. Not until February 13 did District Attorney Edward Swann summon a grand jury to investigate. “We want everyone present at the raid to tell the Grand jury who shot the detectives,” Swann informed reporters. “We want to know what happened after the detectives were shot. They were taken to a hospital. You gentlemen know whose car took them there I suppose?”

BOOK: Rothstein
11.83Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
ads

Other books

Red Cell by Mark Henshaw
Chained by Jaimie Roberts
A Most Immoral Woman by Linda Jaivin
Ashes of the Fall by Nicholas Erik
This Is How It Really Sounds by Stuart Archer Cohen
The Orkney Scroll by Lyn Hamilton
Stuff to Spy For by Don Bruns
Un guijarro en el cielo by Isaac Asimov
Highlander in Her Bed by Allie Mackay