Authors: Sarah Hall
âYes?' I said.
âMy name is Candace,' she announced, very formally, like a grade-school kid. âThe people from the community are organising a little memorial and we thought you might want to know that, this evening, there will be a small candlelight vigil for that poor couple from the motel.'
It was clear she'd said these lines many times before, on all the other porches before this one.
âNothing too fancy, just some candles and flowers, I think. Some people are going to sing or play music, but you are welcome to just stand silently. We are going to start in about half an hour.'
âThank you,' I said.
Nothing like this had ever happened to me before and I don't think the opportunity will come again. The invitation was made
and there must have been a chance, a second when I could have accepted, when I could have been taken in and carried along, but I did not go for it. A clinical part of my mind, something colder than it should be, kicked in and I spoke when it would have been better to stay quiet.
âOh, I didn't think they were a couple,' I told her. I can imagine my blank face staring into hers. âMy wife and I, we heard, we thought it was two separate things, two separate incidents. We heard that the people didn't know each other at all, maybe didn't even see each other. We didn't think there was any connection.'
An expression of deep confusion rose up in Candace's eyes and flexed across her forehead, then switched to anger, almost disgust.
She said the word: âIncident?' And then she snapped. âWell they are a couple to me. And lots of people around here like to think of them like that, together and not alone.'
She turned and stamped away from me. The candle almost went out.
*
This is the rest of it. This is what really happened, just to us, on May 31st, the night before our closing, the night before we moved into our home, the night he killed the woman and made her disappear.
On our side of the wall in the Bide-a-While motel, we had bought a big cheap bottle of sparkling wine â 1.5 litres of not champagne â and we put it in a waste-paper basket and poured half a bag of ice over it and let it stand for an hour. Then we packed up the rest of our loose stuff and we loaded the car. By eight o'clock we were set and everybody was in their sleeping gear and it was my turn to take the freezing shower. When the water first hit my chest, I gasped hard and I felt all the air leaving
my lungs, but then I gradually got used to it and I relaxed a little and I was able to at least rub the small soap over my body and rinse. It took maybe five minutes and then I dried off and pulled on the last of my fresh underwear and my final clean T-shirt. I tussled my hair a bit and walked into the bedroom.
Maddy was waiting on the other side of the door and she held up both her hands, palms flat and right in my face. She pointed at our daughter and made the shush sign with her fingers on her lips.
Lila was face up in the middle of the other bed, arms and legs starfished beneath one thin blanket. Her eyes were closed and her breathing was deep and regular and steady.
âHow did that happen?' I whispered. âTranquilliser dart? Something in her milk?'
âNope,' Maddy said and she smiled. âNothing we did, just a summertime miracle.'
She raised Lila's limp wrist about a foot off the mattress and let it fall back down.
Nothing registered. The girl's breathing kept that steady pace.
âGone,' I said. âCompletely gone. Unbelievable.'
We were both clean and we smelled better than we normally do. There was an opening.
I kissed Maddy and when our tongues touched, it felt like both our mouths were wetter than usual. She put her hand on the back of my head and I felt her fingers going through my hair directly to my skin. She stroked the ridge where the back of my skull tapered into my neck.
We took the bucket and quietly went back into the bathroom and closed the door almost all the way, leaving only a crack. There was barely enough space to stand so I put the bucket in the tub and stepped in there with it. When I pulled it out, the bottle was wet and sweaty and I undid the tinfoil and twisted out the little wire. I shook it a bit, enough so that the white plastic cork flew with a muted pop and hit the ceiling before rattling back down.
The fizzy wine ran up and over my hands and we quickly poured it into the bathroom glasses.
âHere we go,' I said, and I held out my glass for her to clink it. âTo this.'
âYes, to all of it,' Maddy laughed and she gestured to the lump of wet towels shoved into the corner behind the door.
We clinked and downed our glasses in one gulp and then quickly refilled. This was the first drink Maddy'd had since we found out about the baby, but we were only a few weeks away now.
âOne more of these is not going to hurt anybody,' she said and she drank again.
I stepped out of the tub and we sat there on the edge and leaned into each other. Our pinky toes touched. The carbonation made a kind of mist in the glasses and everything in the room was so tight and so compressed, it felt like you could almost hear every separate bubble bursting.
I put my hand on the soft part of the inside of her thigh and my thumb grazed the edge of her underwear. We stayed still and silent for about thirty seconds, thinking it through, and then we went for it for real, kissing again, harder. There was no room and we had to kind of spin around and almost elbow each other in the face as we tried to get our shirts off. As we kissed, she ran her fingers down the bones of my spine and then brought her hand around so her palm was flat on my chest. I pulled her in close and hard.
It had been a long, long time for us. Every little flutter with Jack's pregnancy worried us and all we wanted to do was get through unscathed. Again: there were mysterious chemicals flowing through our bodies and our brains, especially in these final stages, and we felt like there was a delicate balance that shouldn't be fooled with. There were words, names, in our
What to Expect When You're Expecting
book and we said them out loud like a kind of incantation but we did not know what they meant. It
seemed like no one knew for sure. Progesterone, oxytocin, prostaglandins. Nothing behaved in the same way every time and there were reactions and counter-reactions that could only be experienced and never explained or predicted. The doctors had told us that our miscarriage was nobody's fault and that nothing had gone wrong. A completely natural occurrence, they said, a thing that happened all the time, but we did not feel that way. Now though, at last, in that tight bathroom, it was all coming back and it felt like everything inside us was working again, accelerating and rushing down the right channels.
âMaybe just a lick,' she whispered. âPlease.'
We took the last good towel from off the rack and put it down on the toilet seat. Maddy spread her legs, resting one foot on the edge of the tub and the other in the dip of the gooseneck from the tiny sink. She braced her hands against the wall and I went down on her. My left hand moved back and forth, resting on her stomach or touching her full hard breasts, while the fingers of my right hand went in and out of her, very gently, and my tongue stayed on the right spot.
âSlow,' she breathed. âGo slow.'
It was perfect. I could feel her tensing and relaxing, tensing and relaxing and blowing out these long, long breaths.
âGood,' she said. âSo good.'
After a few minutes she put her hands in my hair and pushed me back. I moved to the left instead of the right and I smashed my head on the stainless-steel leg that propped up the sink. She wanted me to stand up, but when I backed against the bathroom door, one of the hooks jabbed me in the neck.
âSmooth,' she laughed. âVery smooth.'
âThis is not easy,' I said.
âNow you,' she said. She put the towel on the floor in front of me and knelt down on it. Then she pulled my shorts down and put my cock in her mouth and worked the shaft with her hand. Too many
things were happening at the same time, the new and the familiar were mixing and I couldn't keep up. I looked around the room and imagined our next move. Us trying to do it standing up in the tub or somehow crouching down into this square of tile. The angles were all bad and I didn't think any of them would work. We were running out of space and time.
âOut there?' I whispered. âDo you want to try out there?'
I opened the door. The curtains to the parking lot were still half open and a beam of end-of-day light fell directly onto Lila's face, but she didn't stir. I took two or three quick strides across the room and pulled the velour drapes closed so that they only glowed around the edges.
Maddy was on her back on the other bed, on top of the blankets. We would have no cover if Lila woke up.
âAre you sure?' I asked.
âYes,' she said. âWe're fine. Come on. Right now.'
In the beginning, all I could do was concentrate on Lila, watching her for any sign, and imagining how Maddy and I could maybe both roll off the side and duck down behind the bed if we needed to. I did not want to get caught by a four-year-old and end up leaving some scarring image that would be seared into her brain.
Then we shifted positions, standing up with Maddy pushed against the wall. The pressure was rising and the pace increased. From that stage on, I closed off and did not care any more. I don't clearly remember exactly what happened or the order things followed. Something gave way inside of me, in both of us, and after months and months of stillness it felt like we were moving again, doing what we were supposed to.
âOn top,' she said after a little bit. âI want to be on top.'
I rolled over onto the bed and she straddled my legs and put her hand on the headboard. She pushed down very hard and I pressed back up against her. We were getting closer and there was
no concern for Jack any more. Raw sounds were coming out of us and we were saying words we would not normally use. I could just vaguely sense that things were getting louder and louder, more insistent, but I wasn't sure any more. Maddy's eyes were closed and she was grinding down and sliding herself back and forth very fast. The headboard was making steady regular contact with the wall and the lamp shades were moving. We both had all our weight, all our strength, behind every movement.
I was breathing hard and my legs were actually starting to burn. I was just going to say something when we heard these three booming blows coming out of the wall on the opposite side of the room. The spacing was even and methodical, like a machine with a two-second delay between each movement. A thud and then a thud and then a thud. We glanced at each other, both our chests expanding and contracting. We were close, but we could not be sure if this sound came in response to what we were doing or if it was entirely its own action. The two were likely connected â the timing too close â but we could not be certain.
It felt like the blows were coming through the whole wall, like a repeating wave of sound, the echo from some piece of roadwork machinery, or the concussive vibration you feel in your chest after a firework explodes or when they are excavating for a new underground parking garage in your neighbourhood. It did not seem like this could be the work of a single hand or a forearm or a shoulder hitting just one spot. When I turned to look at the wall I thought I watched a crack opening up and actually moving down through the plaster. In the dresser mirror, I saw the two of us, still moving furiously. Her back pounding down, my hips rising up. We were seven months pregnant with our second child, but he was not in the world yet. In the other bed, Lila, his big sister, did not stir. The noise from us and the noise from the other side did not reach her.
I looked into Maddy's face. Our eyes locked and she shook
her head. Before I could say anything, she reached down and clamped one hand over my mouth. Our rhythm increased.
âDo not stop,' she said.
We carried through all the way to the end. Our actions did not trigger the premature birth of our son, and our daughter slept through to the morning and no other sound ever rose from the other side. No secret door knobs were turned and no phones ever rang and no inquiries were ever made. The night of May 31st faded quickly and completely into our shared past and on the morning of June 1st, our new lives began and continued on for almost two years.
But then the TV showed his picture and the other story â the bigger one that includes us all â began. The detectives visited our house and sat around the kitchen table while the children slept upstairs. We told them almost everything â our move, our plan for the Bide-a-While, the house, the sunscreen, the taps and the Mr Freezes â but we kept the last part only for ourselves and we never gave that away. The booming signal sounding in the night â the message that may have been sent directly to us, or maybe through us into the larger world â did not make it into the official record and it did not become information and you will not find it in any of the reports. When they took us to the station, Maddy and I gave our independent statements and we delivered them in different rooms to different officers, but when they were placed side by side, they matched up perfectly, the same gaps inserted into the same spaces. For years, we have kept that sound just for ourselves and it is not something we share with other people.
I think about it a lot, though. Or maybe I think that we think about it a lot or we hear it repeating in our memories. The sound and our silence are combined now and the consequences of our choices â the things we did or did not do â are hard to understand even though I have tried to play out all the different scenarios. Perhaps our quietness saved our lives and saved the lives of our
children. Perhaps we were spared. Or perhaps the noises we made and the noises we heard but never reported led to very different results for other people living their lives in other places. Perhaps we are partly responsible for what happened to them. Perhaps the strange possibilities he was trying to open up on his side of the wall shut down other possibilities in our lives. It is hard to know. I cannot tell where privacy ends and the rest of the world begins.