Sinful Seduction (14 page)

“I think she’s due any second.”

Tony nodded, his gaze drifting back to the waves. “Good for her.”

They stood together for a long time, the wind whipping between them. They didn’t talk. Skylar wanted to say something—anything—but it was hard to think of a topic that wouldn’t set him off.

After a while, he let her off the hook. “You look good, Sky.”

“You look way too thin. Are you
okay?
”

His lip curled. “Define okay.”

“Are you physically well?”

“Yeah. Now.”

“What do you need? What can I do for you?”

A firm shake of his head dismissed this question. Maybe he thought he was beyond help. Or maybe it was hope he didn’t believe in. “You can’t help me.”

“I want to try, Tony.”

“You got a magic wand? Fairy dust? Genie in a bottle? ’Cause I’m thinking those are the only ways I’m going to get the lost parts of my life back, you know?”

There was no upbeat response to that, so she didn’t try to manufacture one. “I know.”

He turned to her again, his expression so bleak it might have been ripped from a post-apocalyptic landscape. “I guess I’m a selfish bastard.”

“What? Why?”

“I didn’t expect people to give up on me being alive so quickly. And I didn’t think it would be this easy for people to go on without me.”

“It wasn’t easy. It’s been terrible. Sandro has been sick with—”

“Sick?”
His face twisted, hardening into something that scared her. Not that she thought he would hurt her; she was more afraid of what he was doing to himself. “Is that why you had your tongue down his throat a minute ago? Mouth-to-mouth?”

“Tony—”

“Why the crocodile tears, Sky? It looks like you and Sandro have been helping each other through the grief. Setting up house and—”

“We have not been setting up house! I arrived the other day to give him the papers relinquishing my share of the house to him. He was drinking, Tony. Staring at some of your possessions from the war—”

His brows flattened over his eyes.

“—your boots and tags and photos of you. He has a shrine going in the study. Did you notice that? The house was dark because he’s been wallowing in his guilt and trying to keep it together enough to raise his son alone—”

“Ah, but he’s not alone, is he? He’s got you.”

“You have to forgive him, Tony. You’re not the only one who’s been suffering—”

He leaned down in her face, lips pulled back in that sneer she was beginning to hate. “You’re not seriously comparing being a POW to a case of survivor’s guilt, are you?”

“No. Of course not. But you’re home now and you’re brothers. You need each other.”

“Need?”
Every hard syllable out of his mouth was like a whip’s lash. “You want to talk about
need,
Sky? Well, I
needed
you, my beautiful fiancée, and I thought you
needed
me, but it turns out that all you
needed
was a Davies twin. Didn’t matter much which one, did it?”

She deserved the accusation. Had even braced for it. But hearing it spat at her like that still filled her with hurt and shame.

“You and I weren’t right, Tony. I should never have let things go so far between us, but I was—”

“What? Swept up in a little whirlwind romance with a soldier who was shipping out soon? Is that it?”

Why did it sound so ridiculous when he said it like that?

“I didn’t mean to—”

“To what?” he roared. “To
what?
To fall in lust the second you met my brother at
our
engagement party? Because that’s what happened, isn’t it? Don’t lie to me.”

She struggled, helpless to explain something she still couldn’t understand. “It was more than that—”

“Yeah? What was it, then?”

“I love him,” she said simply. “If I’d cared about you the way I should have, I would never have been attracted to him in the first place. And that’s why I’m so sorry. We should have always just stayed friends, Tony—”

“Is this you making me feel better? Because here I’d thought you loved
me.
That’s why you said yes when I asked you to marry me. And now I find out you were just killing time until my brother came along?”

Could shame kill a person? It was crawling through her, drowning her in prickling heat. “I’m sorry,” she said again. “I’m so sorry—”

“Sorry? Don’t tell me that! That’s not what I want to hear!”

“What, then? What should I do to—”

“You tell me why!” he shouted. “You tell me what he’s got that I haven’t got!”

“I don’t want to hurt you—”

“That ship has sailed, sweetheart. And I need you to tell me so I can get past this. You owe me an explanation.”

Yes, she did. Even if she didn’t want to give it.

“It’s his eyes. It’s his tenderness and his vulnerability. It’s the way I feel when I’m with him—”

“How is that?” he asked sharply.

“I’m not good with putting it in words,” she tried.

“Tell me.”

“I feel like I’m home when I’m with him. That’s all.”

She waited, certain that this fuzzy and probably unsatisfactory answer would set off another round of enraged shouting. It didn’t. To her surprise, Tony’s face eased, slackening with what looked like sudden understanding.

“But we’re twins, Sky.”

“I’m not saying it makes sense. But you and he are completely different.”

They stared at each other for several beats, his expression slowly clearing.

At last his mouth softened into the scant beginnings of a smile. Her chest loosened with relief and a crazy kind of gratitude she’d never felt before.

“Tony,” she began, her heart full of a thousand other apologies—for giving up on him, for not having more faith in him, for not being the woman he’d needed her to be—but he waved her to silence.

“We had some fun, didn’t we? I didn’t imagine it.”

The implicit forgiveness choked her up, making her lips twist with repressed tears. This was a wonderful man standing here with her, even if he wasn’t the wonderful man for her.

She took his face between her hands and stroked his gaunt cheeks. “We had a lot of fun.”

Satisfied, he gave her a rueful nod, and a sweet charge of remembrance went through her. The next thing she knew, he’d cupped her cheeks and was leaning closer, his lids lowering.

“Goodbye, Sky,” he murmured.

“Goodbye,” she said, and tipped up her mouth to meet his.

The kiss was gentle, lingering, and so poignant that her heart ached with—

“Sorry to interrupt,” Sandro said.

Oh, God.

Flustered, Sky broke away from Tony and turned to the doorway in time to meet the frigid blast of Sandro’s gaze as he entered the room. Nikolas and Mickey followed behind and headed for Tony with glad cries.

She opened her mouth, ready to explain away the kiss, but Sandro wheeled around and was gone before she found her voice.

None of Sandro’s usual coping mechanisms worked for him that night.

His study felt simultaneously overwhelming and stifling, as though a rain forest had been crammed into a cave, making it impossible for him to get his breath. The lamp in the corner was too bright, and yet the study was a crypt that threatened to suck the remaining pulse of life out of him. He couldn’t sit still behind his desk, but pacing exhausted him. He longed for drunken oblivion, and should have been well on his way after four shots of vodka, but his mind remained stubbornly clear and the liquor became so disgusting that he couldn’t get another drop down.

In fairness, though, it wasn’t the liquor that disgusted him. He did that to himself.

Over in the corner, the piano mocked him, and he wished he had the energy to retrieve the mallet from the toolshed so he could come back and smash it.

Three emotions had him in a stranglehold, and he couldn’t figure out which he felt the most.

Was it joy that his brother was alive and Sandro was, therefore, no longer a broken half of the missing whole?

Or was his old friend guilt reigning supreme, because not only had Sandro survived the attack, he’d left a man behind to suffer. Wasn’t that worse than his brother’s outright death would have been? Hell, when Tony was “dead,” at least he was at peace. Now it turned out that Tony had been alive and imprisoned—which meant, let’s face it, tortured—while Sandro endured such minor woe-is-me’s as
Why does my son hate me?
and
What should I do with myself now that I’m not a soldier?

So, yeah—guilt.

But there was an ugly new emotion in the mix tonight. Well, not
new,
exactly, but certainly more primitive and ferocious than it had ever been before.

Jealousy.

The images stalked him in all their high-def glory, slowly making him insane.

Skylar’s undisguised emotion at realizing Tony was alive.

Skylar and Tony staring at each other with the intimacy of former lovers…touching each other…falling into each other’s arms.

Skylar running after Tony to console him.

Skylar…kissing Tony.

The jealousy twisted and writhed in his gut, seething and expanding until he could taste its foul bitterness on the back of his tongue.

He eyed the half-empty bottle of vodka. Hell, maybe it wasn’t so nasty after all.

Topping off his shot glass, he raised it in a silent cheer to nothing and gulped it down. Gasping, he swiped a hand over the back of his mouth and resumed brooding.

The thing was, he’d examined the situation from every angle, and there was only one way it could turn out: badly. In life, he knew, there was always an action and a reaction. A sweet balanced by a bitter. A yin and a yang. And the price to be paid for Tony’s miraculous return was simple.

Sky would go back to him.

It was inevitable.

Tony always recovered. He always landed on his feet and came out ahead. He was always the winner, a simple fact that Sandro should never have forgotten. Tony was back, he wanted Sky back and he would get Sky back. The only thing that remained to be seen was whether it happened sooner or later. Which of course depended on Sky’s sense of duty. She’d claimed she’d loved Sandro, and maybe she really thought she did. But that was before. This was now. And she and Tony hadn’t even waited half an hour before they’d fallen into each other’s arms and picked up where they had left off.

So what was left for Sandro?

Nothing but the frigid emptiness he’d known before Skylar showed up on his doorstep.

Reaching for the vodka bottle, he poured again.

Suddenly Skylar strode in without knocking, came to stand on the other side of his desk, and stared down at him with her hands on her hips.

Her lips thinned. “What a surprise. You in the study. In the dark. Drinking by yourself. Who’d have thought?”

She had a fair point. “Like that old board game, Clue, isn’t it? Sandro in the study with the liquor. It’s got a certain ring to it, don’t you think?”

“Where were you at dinner?” she asked.

“In here, of course.”

“Why weren’t you with us?”

“Thanks for noticing I was gone. I wondered about that. I didn’t want to ruin your little reunion scene.”

“It’s your reunion scene, too.”

He shrugged. “Tony didn’t seem that happy to see me.”

“Tony’s in shock.”

Her obvious and ongoing concern for his sainted brother tightened everything inside him to the breaking point. If she’d been worried about a troubled stranger she’d met on, say, the train, he’d’ve admired her compassion. But since her shadowed face was for Tony, he wanted to rage and smash everything in sight. He hated himself for this pettiness, but he still felt it.

“Touching,” he murmured, reaching for his glass. “Well, don’t let me keep you.”

She watched him, brows contracting. “He needs both of us now.”

“Hmm. I’m betting he needs you more than he needs me. Cheers.”

To his irritation, she interrupted his jeering little toast by snatching the glass from him and pouring its contents on his leather blotter. Then she slammed the glass back on the desk and wiped her hands on her jeans.

He glared up at her, waiting and hopped up on adrenaline.

“I’m sorry,” she told him.

“For?”

“That kiss.”

“Oh, was there a kiss?”

She shook her head, emitted a disbelieving little laugh, paced away from the desk and came right back, her face lined with determination. “Your sarcasm isn’t going to get to me.”

“No?”

“No. I know it’s a defense mechanism. Plus, you’re angry—”

Angry? She had ripped his heart out and then opined about him being
angry?