Sisters (9 page)

The Justice Initiative was located in a brownstone building which formed part of the New England University Law School. Alex spoke to the receptionist on the first floor. She was directed up three flights of steps to Marisol Torres’ small, narrow office. On each floor the building seemed to buzz with activity.

The door was open, but Alex tapped on the door frame. Marisol looked up and greeted her with a smile. She moved some boxes and folders so Alex could sit down. ‘Sorry about this mess,’ she said. ‘I think this room was somebody’s storage closet when the building was a private home. No windows and you can barely fit a desk in here.’

‘It’s cosy,’ said Alex, sitting down on a swivel chair on casters, which was wedged firmly in place by cardboard boxes filled with papers. On Marisol’s desk was a photo of a bright-eyed little girl in a striped T-shirt with ribbons in her hair.

‘Is that your daughter?’ Alex asked.

Marisol sighed and looked fondly at the picture. ‘That’s my Iris. Everything I do, I do for her.’

‘She’s adorable,’ said Alex.

‘Thanks,’ said Marisol, settling into her own chair. ‘So, I spoke to Dory, and told her you were curious about her case, and she said that I could tell you anything you wanted to know about it.’

‘I have a lot of questions,’ said Alex.

‘I’ll try to help.’

‘I guess my first question is a legal one,’ said Alex. ‘How can you win an appeal for someone who’s already pleaded guilty to the crime?’

‘Basically we will be pleading that Dory was denied her right to counsel because she was advised by her attorney to plead guilty. He said that she could never win at trial.’

‘And she could have?’

‘No one can answer that. But Dory told the police that the day Lauren died, she and her sister argued – the prosecution had a witness to corroborate that – a dry cleaner who came to the family’s apartment in the South End to make a delivery. Then Dory claims that she went out for a walk. When she returned, she found her sister’s body.’

‘What actually . . . happened? I mean, the crime,’ Alex asked, grimacing.

‘Well, Lauren’s body was found in the kitchen at the back of the house at the garden level. The door to the garden was unlocked when the police got there. Lauren was found on the floor, stabbed several times. The murder weapon was a knife from the block on the kitchen counter. Dory was covered with blood when the police arrived. But that was easily explained. She said she was trying to revive Lauren.’

‘I read in the newspaper accounts that Dory and Lauren argued about this guy, Rick Howland,’ said Alex. She did not mention that she had just come from Dr Howland’s office.

Marisol nodded. ‘Oh, yes. The foot doctor with the Spinone.’

‘Spinone?’ Alex asked.

‘That’s his dog. He and Dory had only recently started seeing one another. Socially, so to speak. Dory seemed to see Rick as quite a prize catch, and she was sure Lauren was trying to steal him away from her. In fact, she was always very jealous of Lauren. There’s no disputing that. But there’s no evidence of any entanglement between Doctor Howland and Lauren. No emails. No calls. Nothing. Lauren lived in Branson, Missouri, and rarely visited Boston.’

‘So, it’s possible that Dory was being . . .’

‘Paranoid. Yes. I’m afraid so.’

Alex frowned. ‘Everybody agrees that she had a motive. And an opportunity, obviously. What makes you think she could have won at a trial?’

‘Ah,’ said Marisol, raising her index finger. ‘This is where the attorney’s negligence comes in. Dory said she took a walk after their argument to clear her head. In his effort to convince Dory to take a plea, her attorney, the public defender in question, told her that there was not a single witness to back up her story. He claimed to have canvassed the neighborhood and that nobody remembered seeing her. He said there was no one to support her alibi.’

‘How is that helpful?’ Alex asked.

‘It turns out,’ said Marisol, pausing for effect, ‘the neighbors were never asked. That much they do remember. No one ever came around from the public defender’s office to even ask if they remembered seeing her. Dory claimed that she walked up to Copley Square and that she bought a bottle of water in the Back Bay station. No one ever questioned the clerk who was on duty that day, or showed the clerk her picture. The attorney just didn’t bother to try to corroborate her story.’

‘Were there cameras in the store? Security cameras?’

‘Yes – not that the attorney checked on that.’

‘Did they show Dory?’

‘Well, I’ve looked at the footage,’ Marisol said. ‘It was a cheap camera, so the film is grainy. And sadly, the owner was using it to spy on his clerks. So the only visible face was the clerk’s. Everybody else was shot from behind. And it was a cold day so they were all wearing scarves and hats and collars up.’

‘What about a receipt?’ Alex asked.

‘Dory threw it away,’ said Marisol. ‘The attorney told her that without alibi witnesses there was no hope for an acquittal, and she needed to take a plea or go down for life.’

‘And she took it,’ said Alex.

‘Yes. And she never should have. This was a murder case,’ Marisol said. ‘The brief will show that her defense lawyer made no effort to confirm her alibi. That alone should demonstrate that she was not defended adequately, and the judge should grant her a new trial, especially with what they already know about this public defender.’

Alex tried to sound positive. ‘You seem pretty hopeful about this.’

‘I am,’ said Marisol. ‘The brief is being reviewed right now by one of the attorneys who help us. Harold Gathman. He’s already applied for a court date for the judicial review.’

‘Good,’ said Alex. ‘But if she does get a new trial, there’s still no way to prove her alibi. Especially after all this time.’

‘We’ll cross that bridge when we come to it,’ Marisol said.

Alex nodded.

Marisol sat back in her seat. ‘So, we can count on your support.’

‘Yes,’ said Alex doubtfully.

Marisol frowned at her. ‘Dory said she thought you might be willing to help with some funds.’

‘Funds?’ said Alex, knowing she had never made any such offer.

‘The law school could really use any financial contribution you might want to make. Everything costs money,’ Marisol said.

Alex stood up. She was a little bit put off by the fact that Dory had offered her financial assistance without even asking. She couldn’t help remembering her attorney, Mr Killebrew’s warning. Prisoners were known to take advantage of people from the outside. People who cared about them. But there was no doubt that this was a good cause, she reminded herself. The Justice Initiative. It was worth supporting. ‘Of course, I will. This is important work that you’re doing.’

‘I like to think so,’ Marisol said.

NINE

A
lex drove home, parked the car in the garage, lowered the door, and was about to go into the house when she remembered that she had nothing in the house to eat for dinner. She thought about getting back in the car and heading for the grocery store, but the thought of major shopping was unappealing. She decided to walk the three blocks to the nearest convenience store to get herself a hero sandwich or something equally decadent. She needed to stretch her legs, breathe some fresh air and think about what she had learned from Rick Howland and from Marisol. Overall, it wasn’t encouraging. The podiatrist had suggested that Dory was obsessed with her jealousy of Lauren. Obsession implied a kind of madness.

Alex’s conversation with Marisol Torres had left her frustrated. She had to admit to herself that she had hoped to learn that there was some irrefutable proof of Dory’s innocence which was motivating the Judicial Initiative to represent her. In fact, it turned out to be, as the Colsons had said, all about legal maneuvering. Marisol was focused on the misdeeds of the public defender, and she might very well win the appeal. But in a new trial, how would anything be different? While she knew that everything Marisol had told her was legitimate, it seemed to beg the question: had Dory killed her sister? No one is going to answer that for you, she thought. Either you believe her or you don’t.

The afternoon was growing dark and Alex shivered in her coat. She thought about that day, when Dory said she had gone out for a walk in the South End of Boston. If it had happened in the summer, people would have seen her on the street. But on a cold day like this people were in their homes, not sitting out on the front steps watching passers-by. If I had to prove that I was out walking today, she thought, how could I do it? There was no one looking out at her and, even if they were, she was covered in a coat, hat and scarf. It would be hard to tell at a passing glance if she were a man or a woman. A few cars went by but it was nearly dark, and who would remember seeing someone hurrying along, bundled up against the weather?

Alex trudged along in the cold, and was glad to arrive at the brightly lit convenience store. She picked up a basket at the door and began to put a few things in it. Not too much, she thought. She needed everything, but this was only a stopgap measure. She still had to carry it home.

She brought her items up to the counter and set them down.

‘Pretty chilly out there, isn’t it?’ said the clerk.

Alex shivered reflexively. ‘It really is. I wouldn’t be surprised if it snowed.’

The clerk nodded as he rang up her order. ‘They’ve been saying on the TV that it’s going to. Twelve dollars and ninety-nine cents,’ he said.

Alex handed him the money.

‘You want your receipt in the bag?’ he asked.

‘No, I’ll take it,’ she said, stuffing the slip of paper in her coat pocket.

‘Stay warm,’ he said as Alex moved out of the way of the person who was now behind her.

Alex gathered up her bags and headed for the door, opening it with her shoulder. She dreaded going back out into the cold. She put her head down against the wind and began the short, unpleasant walk home.

She went into the house, turning on all the lights, and carried her bags to the kitchen. She flung her coat on a chair and began to put the things she had brought back with her into the cupboards and refrigerator. Feeling guilty, she had decided to skip the sandwich and had bought, instead, some eggs and a ready-made salad. She could make an omelet with the cheese she already had in the refrigerator . . . She emptied both bags and realized that she didn’t have the salad.

Damn, she thought. I paid for it. I know I did. She didn’t want to go all the way back to the store and start complaining, but it was a four-dollar salad. She looked in the bag for the receipt and then in her wallet, to no avail. Then, going over the transaction in her mind, she remembered that she had stuffed her receipt into her coat pocket. She picked up her coat off the chair and fished into the pocket, past the gloves and a wad of tissues, and pulled it out. She looked it over. No salad was listed. I’m losing it, she thought. I could have sworn . . . All that was listed was juice, bread, milk and a package of Oreos. Oreos? She hadn’t bought Oreos. And then she looked again at the receipt. This was not her receipt from today. It was a receipt from . . . Alex stared at the little slip of paper. At the bottom the date and the time of the transaction at the convenience store was printed. It was from two weeks ago.

Alex was distracted from her missing salad by another thought. On the day that Lauren was killed, Dory had bought a bottle of water at Back Bay station. That receipt could prove that she was where she said she was. Dory said that she’d thrown it away. She probably didn’t even remember what she did with it. What if there hadn’t been a trash can handy? Dory might well have jammed it into her coat pocket, just as Alex had done at the convenience store. Alex frowned, picturing it. It was possible. It could have happened that way.

Alex gazed at her own jacket as if she were seeing it for the first time in a new way. Had that receipt for a bottle of water been jammed in there, covered by lint and tissues, in Dory’s coat pocket? And if it was, whatever became of that coat?

She picked up her phone and searched for the number at the prison, punched it into her phone and prepared herself to sound desperate while she listened to it ring. A family emergency, she thought. I’ll say it’s a family emergency. She expected resistance from the person who answered, but a woman with a harsh voice said, ‘Just a minute,’ when Alex asked to speak to Dory. Alex marveled at the lack of restriction on a phone call. No one seemed to be concerned.

By the time Dory picked up the phone, Alex was drumming her fingers impatiently on the dining room table. She jumped when Dory said hello.

‘Dory,’ she said. ‘It’s me. It’s Alex.’

‘What do you want?’ Dory asked suspiciously.

Obviously there weren’t going to be any pleasantries. Fair enough, Alex thought. ‘Something occurred to me. I have a question.’

‘About what?’ Dory asked.

‘Dory, what happened to the clothes you wore that day? The day Lauren was killed?’

‘The clothes I wore?’ Dory sounded skeptical.

‘Yes. Your clothes. What happened to them?’

‘The police took them,’ said Dory. ‘They had blood all over them.’

Alex was silent for a moment, her thoughts filled with this grisly image.

‘Well, when I found her, I lifted her up. I tried to help her,’ Dory said defensively. ‘That’s why they had blood on them. I got it on my clothes when I tried to help her. I had to give them all to the cops. I don’t know if they keep shit like that . . .’

‘Everything?’ said Alex, deflated.

‘Shoes, socks, the works,’ said Dory.

‘Your coat too?’ Alex asked.

‘Probably,’ said Dory. And then she was silent for a moment. ‘No. Not my coat. I wasn’t wearing my coat when I found her. I must have hung it up when I came home.’

‘Are you sure about that?’

Dory hesitated again. Then she said, ‘Yeah. When we went to the police station, my dad gave me one of his old work jackets to put on over the bloody clothes. He said I should wear the parka so we could throw it in the wash when I got home. He didn’t know I wasn’t coming back home.’