The Best American Mystery Stories 2012 (54 page)

Because Dr. Barnes hadn't the money to restore Trafalgar, whatever he might claim about time.

“I can't think that there was. Some of his books? I don't know about such things, but someone else might.”

“It didn't appear that there were books missing.”

“That's true,” she agreed. “I'm used to dusting them. They're all there save one.”

Rutledge took the Barnes family history from his pocket. “My doing, that. I needed to show someone the photograph in the front.”

“I'll see it's in its rightful place,” she said, moving the book aside and setting down his cup of tea. “There's a bit of chocolate sponge cake, if you'd like that,” she told Rutledge. “I made it for my dinner.”

He thanked her but refused. After a moment she sat down across from him. “There are the weapons between the photographs, in the study. But none of them was taken.”

Not even all of them would raise the sum needed to restore Trafalgar. “It doesn't matter,” he said. “If it were robbery, it would be for something worth thousands of pounds. Not a few hundred.”

She nodded. “I worry, sometimes,” she said, looking away as if embarrassed. “If I'd been here that day—or come back from the greengrocers a little sooner—could I have prevented what happened? I know you told me I might well have become a victim, too. But it weighs on my mind, you see. I needn't have gone into Mumford that day. His dinner would have been all right without that onion.”

“I doubt it,” he told her bracingly. “Most killers would wait for their chance. If you hadn't left that day, you would have left on another.”

Hamish said, “It's a kind lie.”

He went through the study and the parlor again, looking for something missing—some explanation for why a man had to die—knowing very well that Mrs. Gravely would have noticed and brought it to his attention long ago.

It was all as he'd seen it the first time. The tidiness of the soldier, used to spartan conditions. The collector of books, most of them on warfare, Cambridge, even India. The husband, who loved his second wife and kept her portrait where he could see it, but who bore no grudge against his first wife, headstrong though she may have been. The fastidious man who was always freshly shaven and carefully dressed, judging by the body.

Rutledge went back to the bookshelves and ran his finger down the line of titles. Nothing out of the ordinary. Several volumes of biography: William the Conqueror, Henry II, Edwards I and III. Soldiers all, in the days when kings led their men into battle. The tactics of the American general Robert E. Lee. The strategies of Napoleon.

He stopped and pulled out one of the books at random. As he opened it, something fell out and drifted lightly to the floor.

Stooping to pick it up, he saw that it was an article cut from a newspaper, yellowed and thin.

It was about the destruction of the Great Mews of Whitehall Palace. The stables of Edward I and his predecessors. This had been done early in the eighteenth century, when the ramshackle mews was more of an eyesore than it was useful. Rutledge glanced at the spine of the book and saw it was a biography of Edward I. The cutting was well before Sir John's time, and turning to the end covers, he saw that the name inscribed there in an ornate bookplate was that of Sir Robert Middleton. Father? Grandfather? Uncle?

He set the book aside and picked up the Bible. Searching the list of births and deaths, he realized that Sir Robert was a great-grandfather of Sir John's. Not a contemporary of the destruction of the royal mews, but Sir Robert had been alive in the first part of the nineteenth century, when various architects, including the famous Nash, had taken on the task of creating a square that would fit into the overall view of a new and spacious London. The name given to the finished square came from the column bearing the statue of Admiral Nelson: Trafalgar Square. But as Hillier, the Dartmouth bookseller, had said, it had been among the last of the memorials to Lord Nelson.

Interesting, but it was, as Hamish was reminding him, decades in the past. Hardly pertinent to a murder in 1920.

Glancing at his watch, Rutledge saw that it was half past one o'clock in the morning. The house was quiet, and he thought perhaps Mrs. Gravely had gone up to her bed. Still, he sat down at a table in the parlor and read the faded cutting. It told him very little more. Picking up the book, he thumbed through the pages, looking for any reference to the royal mews. There was nothing of interest. He went back to the study, searched for other books on Edward I, and carried them into the parlor. Had it been only coincidence that the cutting was in that particular history?

It was close on five when Mrs. Gravely came in with sandwiches and a pot of tea. He ate absently, his mind on the hunt. When she came to take away his plate and cup, she said, looking over his shoulder, “He must have loved that book. I can't count the times I'd find it on his desk when I was dusting.”

Rutledge turned to see what she was pointing to. A slim volume bound in worn leather, printed a hundred years ago.

It was written by a man called Baker, and it purported to offer an account of the crusade the then Prince Edward Longshanks made to the Holy Land. He had already turned homeward in 1272 when he learned of the death of his father, Henry III, and that he was now king. He was two years in reaching England to be crowned. Legend claimed that with him he brought a small gold reliquary, encrusted with precious stones and containing a piece of the True Cross. It remained with him through the early years of his reign, although it was more common to give such relics to a church in thanksgiving for his safe return. As he'd been sickly as a child, it was thought he kept the relic for his own protection. But when it failed to save his dying queen, Eleanor of Castile, in a ferocious fit of temper he ordered it buried in the largest dung pit in the stables.

According to Baker, it had been lost to history from that time forward, until a workman had discovered it during the demolition of the stables in the eighteenth century. The man had shown it to his brother-in-law, a yeoman farmer in Kent, who paid him handsomely for it, and the object had remained in the farmer's family, passing from father to elder son in each generation. It had become known, Baker went on, as the Middleton Host, although the family had denied any knowledge of it, and with time the Host and the family itself had been lost to history. The remodeling of the land once occupied by the stables had revived the tale, but Baker had been unable to prove whether it was true or not. He had contacted a number of families by the name of Middleton in Kent and elsewhere, but had failed to find any trace of the story.

Rutledge sat back, considering what he'd just read. Then he rose and went back to the study to look at the small wooden box by the bookshelves.

There was no way of knowing what it had contained. Even Mrs. Gravely, when questioned, had no idea what had been kept inside—if anything. She had dusted it but never opened it.

But suppose—just suppose—it had held the Middleton Host.

That would match with the message that the dying man had tried to pass on to his housekeeper.

Trafalgar.
Not the name of his late wife's home, but the square in the heart of London. Would he have told the secret to Althea Barnes? A great joke, that, one she might have appreciated and passed on to her father and her brother.

What would such a reliquary be worth? Monetarily and intrinsically.

What would it be worth to Dr. Barnes, working daily with men whose minds were destroyed by war? Had he come, in December, to ask for the use of the Middleton Host? And instead been pawned off with promises of the house in Dartmouth? A house he had no use for and couldn't afford to keep up? An albatross, compared to the cure the reliquary might achieve in men who could be brought to believe in its power.

Rutledge went to the door, called to Mrs. Gravely that he would be back shortly, and hurried to his motorcar. Driving into Cambridge as dawn was breaking, he went to the telephone he'd used before and put in a call to the clinic where Barnes worked.

He was informed that Dr. Barnes was with a patient and couldn't be disturbed.

Swearing under his breath, he walked out to his motorcar and was on the point of driving to London when another thought occurred to him. Even tired as he was, it made sense.

The old dog.

Mrs. Gravely had claimed that Sir John had spoken to Dr. Taylor just before he died. She had nearly been sure that he'd asked about his dog. And the doctor had responded with a single word.
No.
She had thought that the doctor was telling Sir John that the dog was dead.

Turning the motorcar around, he drove back to Mumford. He searched the high street of the little town, then looked in the side streets. Shortly after nine, he found Dr. Taylor's surgery, next door but one to the house where the doctor lived, according to the nameplates on the small white gates to both properties.

Hamish said, “'Ware.” And it was a warning well taken.

Knocking on the surgery door, Rutledge scanned the house down the street. He could just see a small woman wrapped in a coat and headscarf, standing in the back garden, staring at the bare fruit trees and withered beds as if her wishing could bring them into bloom again. The doctor's wife? That told him what he needed to know.

The nurse who admitted Rutledge was plump and motherly, calling him
dearie,
asking him to wait in the passage while she spoke with the doctor. “His first patients of the day are already in the front room. It's better if you come directly back to the office.”

“It's about his report on the postmortem of Sir John.”

“He has already mailed it to the Yard,” she said. “I took it to the post myself.”

Rutledge gave her his best smile. “Yes, I've been in Dartmouth. It hasn't caught up with me yet.”

She nodded and bustled off to tell the doctor that Rutledge was waiting.

Dr. Taylor received him almost at once, saying, “Mrs. Dunne tells me you haven't seen the postmortem results.” He sorted through some files on his desk and retrieved a sheet of paper. “My copy,” he added, passing it across the desk to Rutledge. “You're welcome to read it.”

Rutledge took the sheet, scanning it quickly. “Yes. Everything seems to be in order,” he said, glancing up in time to see the tension around Dr. Taylor's eyes ease a little. “Two blows, one to the back of the head and the second to the face. Weapon possibly a cane.” He handed the report to Taylor. “There's one minor detail to clear up before the inquest. Mrs. Gravely told me that Sir John spoke to her as she was coming into the study. Was that possible, do you think?”

“I doubt if he was coherent,” Taylor said easily. “A grunt. A groan. But not words as such.”

“She also reported that he spoke to you. And that you answered him, just before he died.”

Taylor frowned. “I thought he was asking if the old dog was still alive. I told him it was dead. I wasn't sure, you understand. But I thought if that was what he was trying to say, I'd ease his mind.”

He had just contradicted himself.

“I don't think that the dog's death was something that would comfort him.”

Taylor shrugged. “I wasn't in a position to consider my answer. As I told you, he wasn't coherent. I did my best in the circumstances.”

“Actually, I think he was probably asking if you'd use the Middleton Host to save the old dog. And you refused. You had to, because Mrs. Gravely was standing there in the doorway.”

Taylor flushed. “What host?”

“He must have told you at one time or another. A medical man? That a king had found it useless and thrown it in a dung heap. But then Eleanor of Castile was probably beyond help by the time the reliquary reached her. She died anyway. King Edward loved his wife. Passionately. Everywhere her body rested the night on the long journey south to London, he built a shrine. The wonder was, he didn't smash the relic. But I expect he felt that the dung heap was a more fitting end for it. A fake, a sham.”

“I have no idea what you're talking about, Inspector. And there are patients waiting.”

“It was a story that must have touched Sir John. He hadn't been able to save either of his wives, had he? The host was, after all, no more than a pretty fraud.”

The doctor's face changed. “That's an assumption that neither you nor I can make. Sir John was a soldier, a skeptic, hardly one to take seriously legends about relics and miracles. Where is this taking us?”

“I'm trying,” Rutledge returned blandly, “to establish whether or not Sir John loved Elizabeth Middleton as deeply as—for instance—you must love your wife. Because it was for her you did what you did. Not the patients out there in the waiting room.” It was a guess, but it struck home.

Taylor opened his mouth, then shut it again.

“Why did you put the dog out? Did it attack you? If I asked you to have another doctor look at your ankles or legs, would he find breaks in the skin to indicate you'd been bitten? Even if it has begun to heal, the marks must still be there. Would you agree to such an examination?”

Taylor rose from behind the desk. “Yes, all right, the dog was dying when I got there. Sir John was kneeling on the floor beside it when I opened the door and called to him. He told me he was in the study, and to come quickly. Still, the damned dog growled at me and got to its feet as I struck the first blow. I had to get rid of it, because Sir John was still alive and I needed to hit him again. The cold finished it off, I expect. Its breathing was shallow, labored.” He moved to the hearth. “My wife has just been diagnosed with colon cancer. I'd already asked Sir John if I could borrow the reliquary. To give her a chance. He told me it had done nothing for his wife, dying of childbed fever. But I didn't care. I was ready to try anything. I just wanted to
try.
But he was afraid that if my wife recovered on her own, Mumford would be swamped with the desperate, the hopeless, believers in miracles. He said it would be wrong. Time was running out, and yet that afternoon he begged me to do something for his
dog.
It was obscene, I tell you.”