Carnal Isræl: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture (54 page)

Read Carnal Isræl: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture Online

Authors: Daniel Boyarin

Tags: #Religion, #Judaism, #General

BOOK: Carnal Isræl: Reading Sex in Talmudic Culture
9.16Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
< previous page
page_203
next page >
Page 203
clearly grotesquely obese if several basketsful of fat could be removed from his body, and his activity is portrayed as a grotesque violation of the integrity of the body of the Jewish people. The association of the grotesqueness of body and of behavior is underlined by being doubled in another rabbinic figure, Rabbi Ishma'el the son of Rabbi Yose, who performs similar services for the Roman government and is also marked as an inferior son to a superior father:
To Rabbi Ishma'el the son of Yose there also occurred a similar situation. Eliahu (the Prophet Elijah) met him and said to him, "How long will you persist in sending the people of our God to death?!" He said to him, "What can I do; it is the king's order?" He said to him, "Your father ran away to Asia-Minor; you run away to Lydia."
When Rabbi Ishma'el the son of Yose and Rabbi El'azar the son of Rabbi Shim'on used to meet each other, an ox could walk between them and not touch them.
These rabbis truly are proto-Gargantuas if when they stand together their stomachs form an arch so big that an ox can walk under it. It is exciting to see how the talmudic text bears out Bakhtin's remarkable insight by combining in one moment the monstrous belly that "hides the normal members of the body" and the actual dismemberment of that monstrous organ. Indeed, the image of what is done to the body of the rabbi is almost comparable to giving birth, to a kind of lunatic Caesarean section. This association makes perfect sense in the logic of the grotesque body, because it is precisely in the association of fertility and death that the grotesque draws its power (Bakhtin 1984, 238), and in the next episode of the narrative is explicitly thematized.
Reproduction and the Grotesque Body
The theme of reproduction begins explicitly to obtrude in the sequel to the anecdote about the two fat rabbis and thus connects the theme of grotesque obesity with the theme of fecundity:
A certain matron said to them, "Your children are not yours." They said, "Theirs are bigger than ours." "If that is the case, even more so!"
There are those who say that thus they said to her: "As the man, so is his virility.'' And there are those who say that thus did they say to her: "Love compresses the flesh.''
 
< previous page
page_203
next page >
< previous page
page_204
next page >
Page 204
The Roman matron who sees the two obese rabbis cannot believe that they could possibly perform sexually, so she challenges the legitimacy of their children. A brief, highly comic linguistic farce ensues. They answer her cryptically, "Theirs are bigger than ours," apparently understanding the matron to have meant that since they have such enormous penises, they could not have intercourse and replying that their wives have even bigger vaginas.
7
The matron, misunderstanding their answer and thinking that they are referring to their wives' abdomens, retorts, "If your wives are even fatter, then all the more so that you could not have intercourse." At this point the fat rabbis finally understand the matron's concern and answeraccording to one tradition, that the size of a man's genitals is in keeping with the size of the rest of his body, and according to the other, that desire overcomes obesity.
It is at this moment of anxiety about paternity in the text that the account of the gargantuan phalli of the rabbis is mustered. Beginning from this incident, the text produces a phenomenal series of stories that all have anxiety over gender and reproduction as a major motif. The most obvious sign of this thematic concern is the fact that when Rabbi El'azar returns to the House of Study, his first activity is to permit marital sex for sixty women who have had a flux of blood that may or may not be menstrual. According to rabbinic practice, when a woman has a discharge, if it is certainly menstrual blood, then she and her husband are forbidden to have sex until after the period and a purification ritual. However, if it is doubtful as to whether the discharge is menstrual or not, a stain is shown to a rabbi who makes a judgment based on his expertise.
8
In our story, Rabbi El'azar was shown sixty of such stains and judged them all to be non-menstrual, thus permitting intercourse for these wives. All of the sixty children born of the intercourse permitted by R. El'azar were named after him, signifying him as in some sense their parent. My claim for the significance of this narrative moment in signaling the thematic emphasis of the text is occasioned by its very gratuitousness. We could have had the rabbi performing any feat of halakhic (rabbinic law) ingenuity in
7. I owe this interpretation to David Satran, and to my student Christine Hayes I owe the brilliant suggestion that the matron meant one thing and the two rabbis another.
8. This practice has, of course, disturbing aspects with regard to gender and power over women's bodies and sexualities. In a forthcoming research project, this issue will be dealt with fully, dv.
 
< previous page
page_204
next page >

Other books

The Reader by Traci Chee
Improper Advances by Margaret Evans Porter
Bone River by Chance, Megan
Lost Her (Lost #1) by Sharp, Ginger
Pascale Duguay by Twice Ruined
Silent No More by N. E. Henderson
06 Double Danger by Dee Davis
Play Dirty by Jessie K
Eterna and Omega by Leanna Renee Hieber