Authors: Clayborne Carson
TO | : | DIRECTOR, FBI (25-330971) |
FROM | : | SAC, NEW YORK (105-7809) |
SUBJECT | : | NATION OF ISLAM |
The following is a substantially verbatim account of Part Three of “The Hate That Hate Produced.” Part Three was shown on 7/15/59 on the MIKE WALLACE “News Beat” show on Station WNTA-TV, New York.
WALLACE: | Tonight we take a look at the impact of the black supremacist movements upon the power structure of the New York Negro community. Not infrequently, when the Harlem leaders gather, JAMES R. LAWSON and Minister MALCOLM X are there. JAMES LAWSON is President of the United African Nationalist Movement. He is a man who said that ROY WILKINS is an “Uncle Tom.” He calls ARTHUR SPINGARN, President of the NAACP, a Zionist Jew. He calls United Nations Under Secretary RALPH BUNCH the “George Washington of Israel.” Minister MALCOLM X is the leader of the New York Muslims. They are the purveyors of the doctrine that the white man is evil by nature, |
 | On May 18 of last year, New York woke up to this news story: |
 | HULAN JACK, the Negro who had been elected to the highest municipal office ever occupied by a man of his race in this nation's history had been booed off a Harlem street corner by members of his own race. Clearly something was afoot in Harlem. No one seemed to know quite what. |
 | “News Beat” reporter LOUIS LOMAX covered that story. LOU, what were the facts behind that story? |
LOMAX: | To capsule it, MIKE, the Muslims were miffed with HULAN JACK because he had not attended some rallies that were held in Harlem; they organized the booing session. Minister |
WALLACE: | The booing session took place at a NAACP meeting, didn't it? |
LOMAX: | That is correct. They were celebrating the anniversary of the Supreme Court decision desegregating schools. |
WALLACE: | And the Muslims organized the booing? |
LOMAX: | Yes, they did. The booing signal was when MALCOLM X walked through the tavern door, and once the booing began, many non-Muslims joined in the well-organized spontaneous demonstration. |
WALLACE: | Well then, what did HULAN JACK do to bolster his popularity in Harlem as a result of this booing incident? |
LOMAX: | Well, I do not want to make any unwarranted conclusions, but the records show that within a week or two HULAN JACK hired a Negro public relations man. A month and a half later he welcomed Mr. ELIJAH MUHAMMAD, the leader of the Muslims, to New York. |
WALLACE: | Well, what do you say? |
LOMAX: | Just this. That there was unrest in the Negro community, that HULAN JACK was very unpopular, and that the Muslims were those who expressed this sentiment. |
WALLACE: | And he wooed the Muslims? |
LOMAX: | Yes. |
WALLACE: | That was the story, that is the story that the headlines failed to tell. . . . |
WALLACE: | Let us take a closer look at this manâa closer look at this man called brilliant by Congressman ADAM POWELL. This man, MALCOLM X, who preached a vesper service in ADAM POWELL church. There he is with the glasses. |
 | MALCOLM X, by his own admission to “News Beat,” is a former dope peddler and procurer, an ex-convict who served time for theft in Michigan and Massachusetts prisons. He is a changed man now, he says, because ELIJAH MUHAMMAD's personal brand of Islam taught him no longer to be ashamed of being a black man. So it becomes evident that the responsible leaders of the Negro community are fully aware of the activities and teachings of the black supremacists. |
 | But what about the NAACP? This organization is dedicated to the elimination of all racism, black and white. What does it know about the drive for black supremacy? Reporter LOMAX asked NAACP Executive Secretary ROY WIL-KINS what is the attitude of his organization toward the black supremacists and this is what ROY WILKINS said: |
LOMAX: | Mr. WILKINS, you said that you are not aware of any of these street corner meetings and what they have been saying. |
WILKINS: | Oh, I'm aware of the meetings, but all I said was that I haven't stood around on street corners and listened to any speeches. |
LOMAX: | Has the NAACP ever taken any kind of action against these people or have you ever raised the question of whether they should be on the street corner or whether they should be allowed to say these kinds of things? |
WILKINS: | Oh no. We believe in free speech. If they want to speak on street corners that is up to them. |
LOMAX: | Let me move on to something else. Several Negro newspapers, specifically the |
WILKINS: | Certainly. |
LOMAX: | And that they are the evil doers that are synonymous with evil and should be destroyed. Are you aware of this column and the Muslim movement in general which Mr. MUHAMMAD heads? |
WILKINS: | I do not read the |
LOMAX: | ELIJAH MUHAMMAD. |
WILKINS: | ELIJAH MUHAMMAD? No, no. |
LOMAX: | You have never seen his column? |
WILKINS: | I have seen the name, but I have never been induced to read it. |
WALLACE: | We found it incredible that ROY WILKINS was unaware of the existence of ELIJAH MUHAMMAD. Every other responsible Negro leader in the city knows about the Muslims, about ELIJAH MUHAMMAD, and about Minister MALCOLM X, who is the New York leader of the Muslims, the heir apparent to ELIJAH MUHAMMAD, the man who ADAM CLAYTON POWELL called “brilliant.” |
 | Then our research staff unearthed these picture. |
 | Here you see ROY WILKINS conversing with MALCOLM X. That is ROY WILKINS in profile and MALCOLM X just behind him to his right. And here you see the two men shaking hands. Now maybe Mr. WILKINS does not know ELIJAH MUHAMMAD, maybe he does not know that the Muslims have parochial schools where they teach the youngsters that the white man is evil by nature and must be destroyed; maybe Mr. WILKINS does not know that there are about two hundred fifty thousand |
 | We call this series “The Hate That Hate Produced” because it is our conviction that the hate that we have been learning about is the hatred that a minority of Negroes are returning for the hate the majority of Negroes have received. |
 | Senator HUBERT HUMPHREY told the NAACP fiftieth-anniversary convention today that the Negro people are to be congratulated for returning love for hate, but here we are seeing tragic evidence, frightening evidence, that some Negroes are returning hate for hate. The white community must accept a good deal of the blame for the indignities the Negroes have suffered. The white community must admit its share of the blame and take corrective action. But the Negro community is not blameless. They and all of their responsible leaders must move quickly to root out the hatemongers in their midst. |
SECTION 5
November 17, 1959âMarch 3, 1960
REPORTS: | 1. November 17, 1959. New York 2. March 3, 1960. Text of “Pro and Con” (report not available) 3. May 17, 1960. New York |
The November 17 report summarizes Malcolm's July 1959 trip to the Middle East and Africa as Elijah Muhammad's ambassador. The report begins with a
Los Angeles Herald Dispatch
article from April 1959 in which Malcolm called for a Bandung Conference of Negro leaders and branded “the entire white race as âdevils' and as a common enemy of all dark mankind.” The report continues with excerpts from Malcolm's speeches from 1959 in which he takes a much less violent and aggressive stance than in previous years. The change appears to be confined to strategy and tactics and does not show a transformation of ideology. For example, on April 24 in New York City, Malcolm reportedly stated, “We must not teach hatred of the white man when introducing Islam
to
friends and relations. ... In the future we will emphasize unity of the black man for economic, financial and moral betterment.”
His trip abroad is detailed, with the report stating that he did not go to Mecca because he became ill. A letter from Malcolm, written while in Khartoum and published in the
Amsterdam News
on Aug. 22, 1959, insisted that Africans judge the sincerity of America's offers of assistance by U.S. treatment of its own blacks. Changes in Malcolm's strategy are even more evident after his July trip. On August 25, he reportedly instructed each NOI member in New York to “conduct himself as a true Muslim.
They should talk to no one on the outside and should be courteous to everyone.”
The next report contains statements Malcolm made during an interview with William Kunstler on the radio program “Pro and Con.” Malcolm defends the NOI against attacks from white liberals and “Negro leaders.”
Excerpted from the May 17 report are an informant's notes from a New York speech of March 23, 1960, at which Malcolm spoke approvingly of blacks misleading the white man into believing that they love him.