The Hand that Rocks the Ladle (25 page)

Donald didn’t answer his wife’s question. Instead he pointed to a sign.

“Town coming up. I told you.”

“Well, we could have killed her back there. I’m beginning to think you’re chicken.”

“The hell I am!”

“Buc-buc-brack!” The imitation blonde did a horrible imitation of a chicken.

“Bitch!”

That, believe it or not, was one of the nicer names they called each other. It went downhill from there. They used words I’ve never even heard of, and I thought Aaron had taught me everything there was to know about the mindless world of profanity. Folks who swear do so because they lack the wit to express themselves. Of that I’m sure.

At any rate, the couple in the front seat got so caught up in their childish fight that I was forced to face the window, lest they see the smile plastered across my face. We were now passing through the city of Carlisle, and on a rather well-lit stretch of the turnpike, and that’s how I happened to notice the little girl in the car next to us. She was staring at me. No doubt she found my Amish getup fascinating.

I stared back.

She waved.

Then it occurred to me that perhaps she was the answer to my prayers. “Help!” I mouthed.

She stuck out her tongue.

“Help! Get the police!”

The girl was a lousy lip-reader. She stuck two fingers in either side of her mouth and made a horrible grimacing face.

“They’re babynappers! They’re going to kill me. Help!”

I mouthed my words carefully, but she still didn’t get the point. She stuck her entire fist in her mouth and crossed her eyes. In the meantime the car she was in started to pull ahead.

In foolish desperation I slid my shackled hands over the seat and retrieved the binky. To my surprise, and hers, I popped the pacifier in my mouth. At this point Donald and Gloria were practically coming to blows, and my action, bold as it was, went mercifully unnoticed by them.

The little girl laughed and pointed at me. Then she poked her mother in the front seat. The mother turned, at first obviously annoyed, and then amused.

I spit the binky out. “Help!” I mouthed again. “Help! Call the police!”

Thank heavens her mother was a better lip-reader.

"And that’s where I come in, right?” Susannah had taken a huge bite of freshly churned peach ice cream and it oozed from the corners of her mouth as she spoke.

“Take it away!” I cried. “It’s all yours.” I’d been trying to stifle my sister for the last fifteen minutes by keeping her mouth full, but of course to no avail. It had merely been a waste of ice cream. She is a Yoder after all, and nothing but a pistol could tie her tongue.

“So you see,” Susannah said, “if it hadn’t been for me, when the little girl’s parents called the police, they might have dismissed it as a prank call.”

“Ach, what did I miss?” Freni had been changing a diaper during the first part of the story, and apparently Little Mose was adept at what baby boys do best. When Freni returned from the bedroom she was still wiping her face.

“You must have missed the most important part,” Susannah said, ignoring my glare. “It was me who got the A.P.B. out on Mags’s kidnapping.”

Freni blinked behind bottle-thick glasses. “A.P.B.?”

“All points bulletin. Of course Melvin actually called it in, but it was me who noticed that nose.”

I tried to cover my proboscis with one hand. It took two.

“Can we skip that part?” I whined.

“But it’s the best part.” Susannah turned to her audience for confirmation. Besides Freni and me, the audience included Barbara, Jonathan, and Gabe. We were, incidentally, sitting on the front porch of the Hostetler homestead. It was the first day home for all three babies, and now with Little Mose changed and dry, it looked as if all three were finally asleep.

“Yah, it was a good part,” Jonathan said.

Barbara nodded her agreement.

I glared at each in turn. “Go on,” I wailed to Susannah, “but don’t exaggerate.”

Susannah rolled her eyes. “Please, I don’t have to. So anyway, after I discovered Dr. Pierce’s body, Mags dropped me off at the Material Girl, that fabric store in Bedford. And guess what? They gave me a job.”

“How much does it pay?” Barbara asked. From what I could gather, Freni was even more interfering as a grandmother than she was as a mother-in-law.

“It’s just minimum wage,” Susannah said with surprising patience, “but I can buy from the bolt at half off.”

Barbara nodded. “These little ones will need lots of clothes.”

“Right. Now where was I? Oh, yeah—so I don’t have a ride home, you see, and it must have been a bad hair day or something, because I wasn’t getting any offers. So I was standing by the road when Naughty Eddy got off work. He owns a hair salon right next door to Material Girl. Anyway, Naughty Eddy offered me a ride, and of course I accepted. He isn’t really that naughty, you know. I mean, it’s all a bluff. He says it’s because of a war injury, but I heard he was born that way, with only—”

“Ach!” Freni squawked. “The nose! Tell us about the nose.”

“Okay, okay, but don’t rush me. So, we were coming down Route 96, and we’re almost to Hernia, when we pass this car coming the other way. I happen to look over and there’s Mags, sitting in the backseat, all decked out like an Amish woman. Man, did I do a double take.”

“How did you know it was her?” Freni asked. If you ask me, it was not an innocent question. “Because of the nose!” everyone chorused.

“Very funny,” I humphed. “Lots of Amish women have big noses.”

“I think it’s a great nose,” Gabe said. “Noble even.” Susannah smirked. “No offense, sis, but none of the Amish women have noses so big they require their own zip code.”

Everyone laughed, Gabe included.

“Anyway, I made Naughty Eddy turn around and pass you guys so I could get a better look, and sure enough it was you. I waved and honked, but you were sleeping or something.”

“I was unconscious, dear.”

“Yeah, whatever. So then we turned around and went back to Hernia, and Naughty Eddy dropped me off—boy, did Melvin blow a gasket when he saw him. It took me forever to calm him down, but then after he’d rolled over and gone to sleep, I got to thinking about Mags again. She does a lot of weird stuff, but I’ve never seen her dress like an Amish woman before—except for that one time in Ohio, when she had to, and that was just to save her life.

“So I called the PennDutch and this crabby English woman answers and says that Mags isn’t there, and her dreamy boyfriend doesn’t know where she is either”—Susannah looked meaningfully at Gabe—“and that’s when I started thinking that something was wrong in a major way. So, I woke Melvin up, and made him issue the A.P.B. He didn’t want to at first, but I made him.”

“And how did you do that?” Gabe winked at me. “We don’t want to know,” I said. “The point is the Carlisle police caught up with us—only by then we’d left the city limits, so they notified the sheriff. After a two-county car chase, the Redigers—and believe it or not, that is their real name—were apprehended, and yours truly survived basically unharmed. Well, except for the ten years that wild ride took off my life.” Freni nodded solemnly. “Yah, you look older.”

“But not ten years, sis,” Susannah said loyally. “More like five.”

“That was just an expression, dear,” I said to Freni. “I think I look pretty good considering everything I went through, if I must say so myself.”

That was a hint, if ever I’ve given one. Unfortunately, Gabe allowed the opportunity to pass him by.

“That Dr. Bauer just ticks me off,” he said. “A bad apple like that can really besmirch the name of the entire medical community.”

“Yah, I hear he was a drug dealer,” Jonathan said in hushed tones.

“From Colombia,” Barbara said.

It was time to step in with some facts. “He wasn’t a dealer, dears. He was a user. A heroin addict. I should have known when I caught him drowning his pancakes in syrup. Anyway, that service area was supposed to be a rendezvous, but they got into an argument and Dr. Bauer went berserk and started shooting. The cops got him right away. But like I said, I should have known when I saw the syrup that he was no diabetic.”

“You can’t keep track of everything,” Gabe said kindly. “And this was a slick bunch of characters. Renting that apartment next to your sister and a room at PennDutch—now that was a stroke of genius.” Sometimes it is I who cannot leave well enough alone. “Yes, but I should have known that Nurse Hemingway and Gloria Rediger were one and the same person. They both reminded me of someone, and besides, I had a pair of twins staying right there at the inn who showed me what a huge difference a hairstyle can make.”

Gabe eased his long lean legs off his rocker, sauntered over to me, and took my ice cream bowl gently out of my hands. Then much to Freni’s amusement— and Susannah’s envy—he refilled it. The ice cream, incidentally, had been churned in an old-time crank machine. I still had not been to Pittsburgh to pick up my electric version, or my size twenty dress.

“But all’s well that ends right, right?” He chuckled. Despite the cold bowl, my fingers burned where his had touched me. “Right. I’m just glad Donald broke down and told the sheriff everything.”

“Yah, and now we have our baby back,” Freni said. She was still patting her face with her apron.

“And three other babies,” I reminded her. The Redigers and Dr. Bauer were not the only members of the New Jersey-based babynapping ring in the area. Donald ratted out a pair of cohorts in Bedford who ran a baby “clearinghouse.” Baby Hostetler was among the four newborns discovered there. Thanks heavens all four infants were in good health.

“Baby this, baby that,” Susannah said, rolling her eyes. “You still haven’t chosen a name for her, have you?”

Freni’s eyes glistened. “Of course.”

Jonathan rose and put a hand tenderly on his mother’s shoulder. “Yah, Mama, but it isn’t what you think.”

“What do you mean?”

Barbara looked directly at me, and I could tell she was purposefully avoiding her mother-in-law.

“Mama, we owe so much to Magdalena—”

“Yah?”

Jonathan swallowed hard. “Mama, Barbara and I agree that we should name our little girl Magdalena.” Freni swayed, and without Jonathan’s restraining hand, might well have fallen off her rocker. “Magdalena?” she croaked.

“Yah, Mama. Magdalena Veronica Hostetler.”

“Freni is the diminutive of Veronica,” I said for Gabe’s edification.

“Oh, Mags, that is so neat!” Susannah, with no thought to my full bowl of ice cream, threw herself into my arms.

I should not have worried about spilled cream, not when I still had secrets to disclose. To everyone’s astonishment, except for mine and Gabe’s, my chest hissed at Susannah. To no one’s astonishment, her bra barked back. My chest hissed again.

“Ach,” Freni wailed, “and now she makes with these games!”

“To the contrary, dear.” I dug deep and hauled out a blinking Siamese kitten.

Susannah backed up, knocking over the ice cream churn. “What the heck?”

“Look what I’ve got,” I said, beaming. “You’re not the only one who can lug a pet around in her lingerie.”

Susannah righted the overturned churn. There was a new respect in her eyes.

“Oh, Mags, he’s precious. Where did you get him?”

“It’s a she, dear, and she’s a present from Gabe.”

“What’s her name?”

“Little Freni,” I said, and then clamped a hand over my mouth. I really wouldn’t hurt my friend for all the world.

And although she’ll deny it until the cows come home, Big Freni smiled.

I said good night to Gabe on the front porch. It is in clear view of Hertzler Road and thus eliminates a lot of temptation. Besides, all we did was talk. I asked Gabe if he wanted to affiliate with Hernia Hospital— as a consultant only—but he firmly refused. He didn’t have time, he said, to write the great novel and heal broken hearts. Unless that heart was mine, I thought, but wisely kept my mouth shut.

Inside the empty inn, I took stock of the remainder of the week’s events. The Moregold twins had made remarkable comebacks when they learned I would not be waiting on them hand and foot. When they left for Disney World, courtesy of Yours Truly, we were on good terms. Not so the vamp Vivian and her boy-toy Sandy. They bailed out the night of my capture, and without paying the balance of their bill. But I had her credit card imprint, and besides, to be perfectly honest, I hadn’t been the best of hostesses.

As for the mystery guest in Room 6, well, that was a riddle still waiting to be solved. I’d pushed a note under his door that very morning, telling him to vacate. I had a full contingent of guests scheduled to arrive the next day.

“Well, shall we go up and see if he’s gone?” I asked Little Freni.

She meowed in agreement.

We took the elevator up. There is no point in risking my neck needlessly on those impossibly steep stairs. Not when there is no one around to come to my aid.

The door to Room 6 was ajar, and it appeared to be empty, but I knocked anyway. “Hello? Hello?”

There was no answer.

Little Freni plaintively asked to be let down. I set her gently on the bed.

“Don’t eat any of this stuff, dear,” I warned. “It’s liable to make you sick.”

Little Freni ignored me, sniffed one of the plates, and gave it a cautious lick. Then she literally turned up her nose and bounced away. Something else had caught her attention.

“What on earth is that?” I demanded. Little Freni was batting at something, some kind of a wire. I picked up the shiny object. “Why, it’s just a broken guitar string,” I said.

Homemade Peach Ice Cream