Satan's Lullaby (8 page)

Chapter Fifteen

Brother Thomas paced up and down the path near the hospital, unable to dampen his anger. How dare that arrogant priest accuse Sister Anne of murder?

Proving her innocence should be simple, he thought with bitter sarcasm. All he had to do was find the hooded and unidentifiable messenger who had come for the remedy, and do so without offending Davoir, who seemed to dislike him anyway.

Thomas knew the elusive one could not be a lay brother or monk from the priory. He must be one of the clerks, slipped like a venomous snake into Tyndal by that accursed priest. Or, he thought, he was one of the soldiers who had accompanied the band of investigators here. If he found a man he suspected, he wondered how he could arrange a meeting between the suspect and Sister Anne with the hope she would recognize the voice if she heard it again.

“Brother!”

Thomas turned to see a gray-faced crowner behind him. “You have finally been summoned?” He had tried to keep his sour mood out of his tone but failed.

“Only after a miscarriage of justice and much reluctance by that priest.” Ralf threw his hands up in despair. “The man may have the unquestionable right to do as he wishes with those vowed to God on priory grounds, but I tried to argue on Sister Anne’s behalf, believing my long acquaintance with her was useful. He silenced me with a churlishness not even a confessed thief deserves.” Ralf swallowed a curse. “If God dared to disagree with him, I doubt this Davoir would even listen.”

Despite the crowner’s sharp words, Thomas thought Ralf looked both weary and distraught. “You have examined the body?” he quickly asked. His own anger fleeing in the face of his friend’s unease, the monk’s voice grew gentle.

“That I have, for all the good it did me. My conclusion is that the clerk, Jean, is dead.” He flashed a scornful smile. “Beyond that, I can say little with any certainty. He bears no stab wounds, signs of a crushed skull or garroting. Has he been murdered? I fear he has. That other fool of a clerk whimpered about convulsions and wild visions but claimed the lad never had a fever.”

“Was that the clerk called
Renaud
?”

Ralf nodded in disgust. “But, when I tried to question him further, all he did was blubber like my brother, Odo, when he was a boy and I yanked his hair.”

Thomas tried not to smile. Ralf’s ill-loved and second-oldest brother had since taken vows, become an abbot, and grown fat on the king’s frequent gifts of venison.

“I need Annie’s opinion just like I did when Martin Cooper was killed. Poison is not a weapon I know well, and that seems the most likely explanation for the death.”

“Jean had no enemies?”

“After I yelled at Renaud to stop whining, I asked. According to him, the clerk was the saintly beloved of this pest from your abbey. The worst Renaud could say about him was that he was unsure whether Jean was wrestling with a demon in bed, having visions from God, or was sick.” Ralf ran a hand under his nose, and then sneezed. “Don’t bless me, Brother. The Devil and I meet with such frequency over villainous deaths that we have become like kin.”

“You are not only a father once but soon to be twice. You need a blessing, Crowner.” And he gave him one to keep evil from filling the space left by the sneeze.

Now that his contempt of clerics was vented, Ralf sank into unhappy silence.

“You have learned from Davoir or his clerk about the accusations against Sister Anne?”

“From that vermin sent by your abbess. How could he be trusted to review anything when he is blind to all facts?” He spat. “I swear I saw ears on Davoir. If he owns them, why can he not hear when those with knowledge of Annie’s virtue speak so eloquently on her behalf?”

“I do not understand how he could insist on her arrest and confinement either. Father Etienne may have the authority to examine the state of Tyndal Priory, but Prioress Eleanor still rules here.”

Ralf hit the monk on the shoulder. “Have you not heard the rest of the foul news? This I learned from the sniveling clerk.”

The monk stared at him as if unable to comprehend that something even worse than the arrest of the sub-infirmarian could have happened.

“Davoir also threw suspicion on Prioress Eleanor regarding his clerk’s death. And do you know why?” His voice had risen to a shout.

The force of his friend’s outrage was so numbing, Thomas found he had lost the ability to ask for an explanation.

“That tonsured louse claims that our good prioress may have ordered Annie to kill the clerk.” His face flushed red, and he turned away. “The priest accused her of doing this to make him flee, lest he discover the truth about…”

“The purpose he was sent here? He finally said why this visit was ordered?”

“You and Prioress Eleanor have been accused of lying together in unholy lust.” Ralf could not face the monk as he said that. Instead, he stared back at the guest quarters as if willing them to spontaneously combust.

Thomas’ mouth dropped open.

Ralf spun around and shook his fist. “Swear you will defend yourself against this vile accusation!”

Thomas stared at him. “I have heard many lies, Ralf, but this is one of the most abominable. As for defense, I must rely on the strength of the truth. ”

“Who could have accused you both of such a thing?” Ralf laid a hand on his sword hilt. “Since your vows preclude you from doing violence, tell me the name. I shall render the justice due the lying fiend.” He lifted and dropped the sword back into its scabbard.

Thomas fell silent as he thought, then shook his head. “I do not know, Ralf. Our prioress owns great virtue and ably serves God. She feeds and clothes us all well. The poor are given food. The sick receive the finest care in England. The mill grinds the village grain at no profit. And, when she is not running this priory with an integrity and skill most men would envy, she brings murderers to justice. The reason for this condemnation is not based in any fault she owns. Someone has grown jealous of her virtues.”

“She may run the priory with the aid of others, but it is you who stands by her side in matters of unlawful bloodshed. Someone hates you with equal fervor.”

“I do little enough, Crowner. It is she who leads me to the truth, just as she leads all at Tyndal to God. The insult is against her, not me.” Thomas shuddered. “Sinner though I may be, and God knows best what frailties I own, I am not guilty of lying with our prioress nor is she, virtuous woman that she is, guilty of breaking her vows with any man.”

Although he had once suspected her of suffering lust, he had also seen her battle with the evil spirit of desire until it fled and she saw the wicked heart the man possessed. For her valor and fortitude in that struggle, he respected her even more. He often told others in confession, that it was not the temptation God abhorred. It was the succumbing He loathed. As for his own sinning, he had surrendered only once to his greatest weakness. Yet it was an act he could not fully repent and one still debated with God.

“The accusation against you both remains unaddressed,” Ralf said, “and most probably will until this clerk’s death is solved. The resolution will be difficult. Annie is locked away. Prioress Eleanor cannot help prove her innocence. If she tries, she will be accused of tainting the evidence to protect herself. And you…”

Thomas felt ill. “And I am hobbled like a horse because I am accused of being our prioress’ lover.”

Ralf nodded. “Someone has been fiendishly clever. Those most able to solve this problem have been rendered impotent.”

“You are left to do it. Alone.” Thomas might be frustrated over his inability to act, but he had no doubt about his friend’s competence.

“I cannot do it all, Brother. Although I may investigate a suspicious death, I am treading on God’s earth at the priory. There are people I cannot question without a witness present. If Davoir chooses that person, the monk or nun might hesitate to give an honest statement out of fear of the priest’s retaliation. If I find the culprit, and he falls under God’s law, I cannot take that person into custody. Church justice outranks the king’s here, as does the final questioning. And it is hard to imagine that the killer slipped over the walls to administer a lethal dose of some poison to a clerk in the company of Father Etienne. I fear the man is one of yours, not mine.”

“You must still ask the priest questions.”

“Which he can refuse to answer because he denies my authority to do so. Not only is he vowed to God, he is the brother of your noble abbess, and he is the confessor to one of the French king’s brothers.”

“If nothing can be resolved quickly about the clerk’s death,” Thomas said, “the accusation against our prioress festers. Prioress Eleanor will not meekly submit to the injustice rendered against her. The matter will go to Rome.”

“And we may all be dead by the time Pope Nicholas III renders judgement. After the roof fell and killed his predecessor, he might be leery of making decisions without long consultations with God.” The crowner turned pale. “And my wife needs our Annie with her at the birth. Gytha is a brave woman, but this is her first babe. If anything goes wrong…”

“Has Sister Anne said there was any possibility of a problem?”

“Would she?” Ralf covered his face. “Remember the horrible birthing of that young mother when the Jews were almost murdered by the mob here?”

Thomas put his hand on his friend’s shoulder. “Not all women suffer so. If our sub-infirmarian is confident this late in Gytha’s pregnancy that all is well…”

“Women have died after being told they had no cause to fear the birth.” Ralf’s voice grew hoarse. “My first wife was given no grounds to doubt her survival. Sibley was born healthy, but my wife died a few days later. Gytha resides where my heart lives, Brother. Without Annie’s care, she might die and so shall I.”

Ralf turned his back on his friend, but Thomas saw the tears. “Then we must prove Sister Anne innocent and free her in time for the birthing.”

As he spun around, the crowner’s face was scarlet with rage. His fist clenched as if he longed to strike the monk, but he wilted in an instant and fell to his knees on the path. “Were Gytha to die, I will leave this world. I swear it.”

Thomas dragged his friend to his feet. “You would be a most troublesome monk, Crowner. And if you meant you would commit self-murder, I advise against it. Your wife, a good woman and a loving spouse, would be in Paradise while you spent an eternity far away from her in Hell for your crime. I suggest we set our minds to figuring out how to get across the moat the wicked and the fools have dug around us. We shall find the truth.”

Ralf glared at his friend, then burst out laughing. “You are right, monk. I have no calling for chastity or obedience, although poverty might suit me well enough. But should I fall into Hell, I think even God would pity Satan, for I would surely make the Devil as miserable as I.”

“I fear even I might feel some sympathy for the Prince of Darkness!” Thomas grinned, then took Ralf by the arm and whispered in his ear. “Let us consider our choices.” He looked around, but no one was close enough to hear.

“Do we have any?”

Someone called out to them. Looking up, they saw Gracia running toward them.

“Come!” she said, skidding to a stop and panting from the exertion. She looked over her shoulder, then lowered her voice. “Prioress Eleanor calls you both to attend her. She has something to discuss. But you must arrive without being seen, lest a wandering clerk report the meeting to a certain high-ranking guest. I see none on this path. Hurry!”

“If our prioress has joined our conspiracy, Crowner, I begin to hope,” Thomas said to Ralf.

As the trio hurried down the path to the prioress’ chambers, Ralf glanced back and saw Conan walking toward the guest quarters. Fearing the man had seen the three of them together, the crowner raised his hand in greeting as if he wished to tarry with the guard captain. In fact, he only hoped to distract Conan lest the man see Thomas walking toward Prioress Eleanor’s quarters.

But Conan ignored the gesture and continued on his way.

Chapter Sixteen

Gracia poured each of the men ale, and then offered warm bread and a white goat cheese.

The usually ravenous crowner glanced at the food and refused it.

”You have now heard everything Gracia has discovered from Sister Oliva,” Eleanor said.

Thomas smiled at the maid. “God gave you good wits,” he said, “and you apply them well.”

The girl flushed with pleasure. “It was my lady who thought to send me, Brother. If I have shrewdness, it is she who directed the use of it.”

Silent and melancholy, Ralf stared into his mazer.

“Something troubles you, old friend,” Eleanor said. “What is it?”

“I beg pardon, my lady. The moment I heard that Ann…” He glanced at Gracia and cleared his throat before rephrasing his concern. “Now that I know no one can identify the man sent to Sister Anne by the priest, it is hard to chase away my fears. As you know, I honor her and refuse to give up hope that she will be released. But that time seems even further off now, and my wife is near her term. Gytha must bear our firstborn in terrible pain without Sister Anne’s comfort and skill. I can only hope God listens to my wife’s prayers and shows mercy…”

“Sister Anne will attend your wife’s birth if I have to take our sub-infirmarian from that cell myself and stand guard outside the birth chamber like the cherubim at the gates of Eden.” Eleanor knew he was terrified for Gytha’s safety, a woman he cherished more than his own soul. Nor was Ralf the only one worried. Gytha had been her maid for several years before she married the crowner. The entire priory loved her, and the woman was as dear to the prioress as a younger sister.

Thomas watched his prioress’ hand form into a fist. Although she might otherwise tread carefully in this sensitive matter that could wound the tender pride of God’s anointed kings, Davoir and his army of clerks could not stop her from freeing Sister Anne when Gytha’s birth pains began. His spirits rose. Prioress Eleanor was no novice in the clash of wills and usually won the jousts.

“My lady, neither my wife nor I want to put the outcome of this ill-considered investigation, ordered by your abbess, at risk…” Tears trickled down the crowner’s cheeks. There were many in Tyndal village who would be shocked to see this often rough man weeping.

Eleanor shook her head. “Until Abbess Isabeau orders otherwise, Ralf, I rule this priory, not Father Etienne. I shall not allow the health and comfort of a new mother and her child to be set aside because one man has made a bad decision, one he shall soon rue. Sister Anne has been unjustly accused. She shall be at your wife’s side and bring both Gytha and the babe safely through their ordeals.”

“Your kindness is beyond measure,” Ralf murmured. “I shall reassure my wife.”

“And no matter what malicious lies have been spewed forth against us with unknown but foul intent, the God we serve at Tyndal Priory is loving and compassionate.” Eleanor’s face was white with fury. “He will vindicate the honor of us all, but the matter of Sister Anne’s innocence comes first.”

Thomas had rarely seen his prioress this angry or determined. “How to do so remains a mystery to me,” he said.

Ralf swallowed the last of his ale, and, his fears for his wife abated, he glanced at the food with renewed interest.

Gracia filled his cup and brought him the bread and cheese.

He thanked her with a smile.

“Neither you nor I can investigate without casting doubt on the validity of any evidence we find,” Thomas said to his prioress. “And Ralf’s authority here is limited.”

“You and I have always worked together in perfect accord, my lady, but Davoir will not allow me that freedom of consultation or investigation.” The crowner raised a fistful of food and then bit into his cheese.

“The precedent of cooperation has been set, Ralf. If Davoir questions it, any at this priory can confirm the practice and the respect you have always shown God’s law. In order to determine if this death is murder…”

“Davoir has already decided Sister Anne killed his clerk.” Fighting a resurgence of despair, Ralf waved a diminished handful of food at the ceiling. “May God curse him,” he muttered.

“And no matter how firmly Father Etienne holds that conclusion, he is in error. If he cannot be wooed by logic, I shall exercise my right to override any attempt by him to supersede my commands.” Her smile was as cold as a north wind on the feast of All Saints.

“What if he orders his clerks to lock you into a cell?” Ralf’s face turned gray.

“He has his clerks. I have loyal lay brothers under the command of Brother Beorn, all of whom wield pitchforks with the same skill clerks use quills.”

There was absolute stillness in the room as they all stared at her.

Thomas broke it with a laugh. “Brother Beorn might be army enough by himself, my lady. Even our crowner gives way to our lay brother on the path when they meet each other.” Glancing around, he was relieved to see that the mood had lightened. Even Ralf was grinning.

“At times I pity God that the lay brother serves Him,” Ralf said, then took more cheese when Gracia quickly offered it to him.

“If God has compassion for our guest, we may not need to use the lay brother, our greatest weapon. I can debate for hours with Father Etienne. By the time the priest and I have stopped quarrelling, Crowner, you will have done everything needed to prove our sub-infirmarian innocent or at least raise a reasonable doubt in Father Etienne’s mind.” Eleanor sat back in her chair and fingered her staff of office. The time for jests was over.

Ralf rose and began to pace. “Whom may I approach?”

“Begin with Sister Anne while you may,” she replied. “I will send someone with you for proper attendance. Ask for her version of the events, seek any clarification you need, and present your observations of the corpse. You have seen, touched, and smelled the body. From your questions and comments, our sub-infirmarian may have enough information to give you her firm opinion on the cause of Jean’s death.” She thought for a moment. “If God is kind, she may be able to help with timing of the death. Perhaps the beginning of the symptoms will provide a new clue, although I fear this elusive Brother Imbert remains the key to the locked chest where the solution lies.”

“But will Davoir allow this?”

“We shall invite his participation. Ask him for one of his best clerks to record and witness the interrogation. For all I care in this matter, you can leave the door to the cell open so everyone can hear what is said. There is no purpose in hiding anything if you phrase your questions cleverly.” Her smile was mischievous. “And I know just how clever you can be, Crowner. After all, you stole my maid from me.”

He flushed.

“Sister Anne must be made aware of this plan,” Thomas said. “How can that be done?”

The prioress gestured to her maid. “Gracia shall take our nun her meal from the kitchen and give her a brief message to alert her.”

“Won’t Davoir be suspicious if your maid appears so often, my lady?” Ralf asked.

Eleanor stood and gestured to the girl to come closer. Putting an arm around her, the prioress said to the crowner, “Look upon her. Do you see a child or a woman?”

“When you first came to Tyndal, Gytha was only a little older but had a woman’s form,” Ralf said after a moment. “Gracia does not.”

“Exactly. If Father Etienne notices her at all, he will dismiss her competence due to her perceived youth. Perhaps he thinks I selected a babe to serve me out of simple charity and will soon rue my choice. He most certainly does not see her as a messenger, nor one who observes and reasons far better than most owning many more years on this earth. Brother Thomas and I learned just how clever Gracia was in Walsingham. I am grateful she chose to come back with us and bring those skills.”

Gracia flushed with pleasure.

Thomas winked at her. “More fools they. Look at how effectively she questioned Sister Oliva in the hospital apothecary hut.”

“I did nothing except obey my lady,” Gracia said softly.

Eleanor gave her a hug. “And I take no credit for the gifts God has bestowed on you, my child.”

“Then let us plan what I must ask,” Ralf said eagerly.

Eleanor began to sit, then changed her mind and walked to the table to pour herself a cup of ale. “Forgive me, Ralf, but there is information I learned from Father Etienne that I should have sent to you long before now. I fear the clerk’s death and the arrest of Sister Anne chased the news from my memory.”

The chamber door creaked open, and the prioress’ cat entered. Contemplating all in the assembled group, he chose to favor Gracia with his attentions and rubbed against her legs.

She knelt to pet him.

“On the journey here,” Eleanor said, “one of the soldiers assigned to protecting our guests was killed. The captain of the guard insisted that he was aware of the circumstances and would render the appropriate justice. No crowner or sheriff was called. Perhaps the captain was correct, but I believe you should know about this.”

Ralf raised an eyebrow.

“Father Etienne did not say if any soldier was punished or executed for the crime. He was more concerned about the health of his clerk.” She sipped her ale. “Nor have I concluded there is any link between that death and Jean’s. Nonetheless, I did not want you to remain in ignorance, lest there be some connection or error in failing to alert you to the crime.”

Indeed I should know, Ralf thought, recalling the badly scarred man who sat with him at Signy’s inn and exhibited a rare curiosity about the village and the priory. Conan had made him uneasy. Now he had more cause to investigate this guard captain further.