Read The Last Man in Russia: The Struggle to Save a Dying Nation Online
Authors: Oliver Bullough
powder snow thrown up by the two
or three snowmobiles that had roared
off before us. Alexander twisted the
throttle and the wind cut into my
face and tore at my arms. I began to
wonder if he might be right about
the jacket. The cold was intense –
down to minus 40 and due to fall
still further in the clear conditions –
and physically painful.
The wooden houses of the
village flicked past as I tried to shield
my cheeks from the wind. By the
time we arrived at Alexander’s
single-storey home, I was rubbing
my face to get a bit of warmth back
into it. Alexander looked at me in
confusion.
‘Why didn’t you just face
backwards?’ he asked. I felt like an
idiot, since that had not even
occurred to me, and tried to create a
convincing lie for my stupidity.
‘I wanted to see where we were
going,’ I tried, hesitatingly. That did
not
even
convince
me,
and
Alexander laughed. He pointed me
at the door and went to put away the
snowmobile.
I entered a porch filled with
firewood. The doors were lined with
blankets, both for insulation and to
ensure a good fit in their frames. I
pulled off my boots, which were
tight against my three pairs of socks.
I wondered, when I realized how
cold my toes were, if my boots
might not be inadequate for these
conditions as well. When I passed
into the warmth of the house, a
smiling handsome woman was
waiting for me, Alexander’s wife.
‘I’m Natasha, but call me Auntie,
everyone else does,’ she said, and
we walked into the kitchen and she
put the kettle on. The main feature of
the room was a huge brick oven, as
large as Alexander’s snowmobile,
which gave off a pleasant heat.
Three cats and a kitten were perched
on top of it, among assorted pots and
pans. They watched me with
unblinking eyes as I sat at the corner
of the table and drank my tea.
Alexander finally bustled in, his
glasses iced over. He sat on a stool
by the stove and lit one of his rough
cigarettes. He scooped up a couple
of shovels full of dusty coal and
threw them into the fire. Then he sat
back and looked at me. Why, he
asked, had I come?
I explained that I wanted to
experience the conditions that Father
Dmitry had lived in. I wanted to feel,
if only for a short time, the kind of
conditions that he had endured and
the kind of torments suffered by
prisoners who refused to offer due
homage to the Soviet state. We
talked about that for a while, our
conversation then wandering on to
the conditions Alexander and his
family lived in. His youngest
daughter Dasha had now joined us.
He told me about hunting and
fishing, and the two women chipped
in with comments and suggestions.
‘I used to hunt bears, but what
do you kill them for? I don’t see the
need to do this any more, it’s for
young men,’ he said.
The next morning dawned pale.
Lying in the warmth of the blankets,
I could hear the wind moaning
around the house, and I pulled on
my two pairs of long underpants,
three pairs of socks, vest, two T-
shirts and trousers before getting out
of bed. A pale orange stain on the
sky was the sun poking its head over
the horizon to see if the Arctic was
warm enough for it. Before my
window was a rolling unbroken,
unscarred sweep of snow. To the
right was a small stand of birch trees.
Beyond was a tractor, its contours
smoothed by a drift that made it
almost unrecognizable as a man-
made object. A little outhouse was
off to the left, with snow pushed up
its walls in an elegant sweep. When
the sun finally persuaded itself to get
out of bed, it was so weak I could
watch it with the naked eye, and the
bright patches it left on the snow
seemed to emphasize the cold rather
than alleviate it.
Alexander, when I walked into
the kitchen, welcomed me with a cup
of tea. He was sitting on his stool by
the stove, smoking.
‘I don’t know how to tell you
this but it’s warm, it’s only minus
27. But the wind is 15 metres a
second and it bites,’ he said. The
little black kitten was scratching in
the coal by his feet, and I saw that
the coal doubled as their litter tray. It
seemed an elegant solution to burn
the cats’ toilet waste, since they
could hardly go outside.
Before
we
ventured
out,
Alexander
examined
the
mountaineering
jacket,
and
pronounced it inadequate. I would
have bridled at the slur but, to be
honest, after the cold of the previous
evening, I had my doubts about it.
He handed me a stiff blue coat as
used by the railway workers, then,
on seeing my boots, silently handed
me a fur-lined pair. Before I put
them on, he made me wear padded
dungarees too. Fully dressed – with
a jumper, scarf and hat as well as the
collection of undergarments I’d
donned in bed – I could barely bend
in the middle. I felt like a knight in
squishy armour.
Outside in the bright morning,
the cold was still startling. My
cheeks tingled, and I tucked my
fingers into the palms of my gloves.
Boretsky, the old man in Inta,
had said that the prisoners in the
gulag wore two pairs of quilted
trousers to work outside, with a daily
ration of just 600 grams of bread.
Here I was, full of a substantial
breakfast, in two pairs of long
underpants, trousers and padded
dungarees, and I was already cold. It
suddenly seemed a miracle any of
them survived at all.
In a memoir published in 2011,
Fyodor
Mochulsky,
a
Soviet
diplomat, recorded the early part of
his career when he oversaw a
convict-labour
railway-building
camp near Abez. This was before the
railway was finished, so they had to
take a steamer from Arkhangelsk on
the White Sea to Naryan-Mar, then a
smaller ship up the River Pechora,
then a smaller ship still up the Usa.
The boat, with its cargo of building
materials and food and prisoners,
froze into the ice before they reached
Abez, and they had to walk the rest
of the way, sixteen days, over the icy
crust that had formed upon the
freezing mud. Mochulsky’s horse
plunged through the crust.
‘The
horse
was
thrashing
around, and sinking even deeper into
the marsh,’ he wrote. ‘We all shared
a very worrisome thought: how will
we
explain
that
our
horse
disappeared when we arrive at the
Gulag Camp Administration? . . .
This crime, we all knew, had a
corresponding legal statute: ten
years’ imprisonment in the camps.
By now, we had worked so hard to
get that horse out of the quagmire
that we were losing our strength. We
were in total despair.’
That
thought
seems
to
encapsulate the bureaucratic insanity
of the gulag. The horse was not
pitied as a terrified living thing, but
protected only to avoid punishment.
Perhaps more terrible is that he, a
free man, should accept a ten-year
prison term as an appropriate
punishment for losing a horse
through no fault of his own. The
guards were hardly more at liberty
than the prisoners. The habit of
giving and receiving orders was so
engrained in both that it formed an
internal prison they struggled to
escape from.
When Mochulsky reached his
final destination, a logging camp far
in the wilds, the convicts had no
houses or shelter of any kind. ‘They
had scraped the snow off of several
metres of frozen ground in the shape
of squares, and had placed crudely
cut branches down as makeshift
beds. On top of these branches lay
the prisoners, dressed in their
greatcoats and army boots, “resting”
after their twelve-hour workday.’
Mochulsky, who appears to have
written the memoir to excuse his
own role as a cog in the world’s
largest-ever
killing
machine,
recounted how he had mobilized the
prisoners to build barracks for
themselves and made them warm
over the winter, and that they were
grateful to him. That was the winter
of 1940–1, when hundreds of
thousands of prisoners died.
Perhaps more telling is an
encounter he had later in Abez, with
a teenage girl. A cashier, she had
received a three-year sentence for an
accounting irregularity, and had
been raped for the first time before
she even reached prison. In her first
night in prison she was gang-raped,
and was repeatedly assaulted by
fellow inmates in transit camps and
the camp barracks.
‘How could I help her? In the
context of the camp, other than
feeling bad for her, I could do
nothing.’
The prisoners here were units to
be worked to death. They died in
their thousands, and were not
remembered. That morning, as
Alexander folded the fur blanket
over me on the snowmobile’s trailer,
he told me we would go to see the
remains of such unfortunates: graves
we had not seen in the summer,
which had not won even the slight
recognition of those in what is called
the ‘memorial cemetery’, where
Karsavin and the others were
remembered as individuals, rather
than ignored as random lumps in the
tundra.
We set off along the bluff above
the river, stopping to admire a
recently finished church, which was
built in memory of a young man
who had died on a fishing trip. A
little further on, towards the railway
and the great bridge that had tamed
the River Usa, we stopped and
Alexander pointed to our right. He
said something, but I could not hear,
my ears being tightly swaddled in
my woolly hat and my coat’s great
hood.
I looked in the direction of his
outstretched index finger and could
see an obelisk against a clump of
birches. It looked like a grave, so I
stepped off the trailer to get a better
look. I instantly vanished into the
snow up to the tops of my thighs. I
pushed back with my left foot, but
just sank deeper. My heavy clothing
blocked me from turning round, and
I was forced to lie full length on the
snow’s crust, heave myself round,
then pull myself back on to the
trailer with my gloved hands.
‘What did I tell you?’ Alexander
shouted, and I realized that the
unheard words had been a warning
to stay on the trailer.
The obelisk, he told me, marked
the grave of a boss’s daughter. I
asked why it was all on its own,
away from the main graveyard. He
laughed, and coughed on the smoke
of his cigarette.
‘It’s not all on its own, there are
dozens of graves over there but the
rest are for prisoners so they’re
unmarked. They’re
disappearing
back into the ground. In a few years,
you’d never know they were there.’
We swooped down the bluff,
past the site where the North Stream
gas pipeline will ford the river, and
out on to the ice. In my attempt to
reach the obelisk, snow had pushed
down into my boots and was
beginning to melt. We zoomed