Read The Last Man in Russia: The Struggle to Save a Dying Nation Online
Authors: Oliver Bullough
Usa, heedless of the streams of ice-
cold water that run on top of the ice,
concealed by a thin crust of snow.
One
time
there
were
six
snowmobiles stuck in mid-river
where they had crashed into water
flowing under the snow and been
abandoned.
Even the two dogs seemed
subdued by the graves, and they sat
in the snow by the snowmobile,
waiting for us to move away.
The mood hung with us back to
the house, and the conversation
continued with Natasha in the
kitchen.
‘If someone comes back from
working on the railway, he’s cold,
he’ll sit and watch television and
drink vodka,’ she said. ‘People are
lazier than they used to be. Or else
now they are wiser, because they do
not do what we used to do.’
She reminisced about the colder
winters of her youth, and the heroic
amounts of work people did to stay
alive.
‘When I was small this was big,
the biggest village of the north,
2,000 people at least in the village
itself, and more in the hamlets
around. Now there’s no one there,’
she said, leaving their fate hanging
in the air, to be filled in by
Alexander.
‘Last
year
eleven
people
drowned, falling out of their boats,’
he said.
Natasha took over again: ‘They
weren’t all found. There was a lot of
water this year and strong winds,
and then there is this as well.’ She
tapped her jaw-line.
Do the women – I tapped my
jaw-line – as well, I asked?
‘They also. Everyone in Russia
drinks now.’
The mood was bleak, as the
conversation rolled on towards the
fate of the country.
‘I was like you once,’ said
Alexander.
‘I
believed
in
improvement and the future. I
condemned this and that and
everything, but I started to change.
Look at your son. He is small now
like a toy but he will become big and
you will care more about how he
will do at school, what he thinks and
so on, and this will become your
main concern. Your own successes
will be less important.’
Young people, he said, had no
concern for the victims of the gulag,
and no interest in the work he does
to try to keep the graveyard
respectable.
‘The younger generation collects
berries on the graves, they light fires.
Yes it happened, they say, these
people died, but it has nothing to do
with us. In March there will be a
new mayor in Inta and he will come
to the memorial cemetery. They
always do. But he will only come
once and never again. That’s what
they do,’ he said.
Did that mean that officials, the
state, had no interest in the graves?
‘The state has no relation to any
of this. They cannot afford to
provide us with gas, but they can
build themselves offices. Everything
is done through the arse, to screw
things up,’ he said, with an
unexpected profanity, the only one I
heard him use. ‘The state makes you
pay. If you don’t have to pay for the
railway, they will make you pay for
the mosquitoes that bite you. They
find a way to make you pay.’ And
that was why the collective farm had
closed, and with it had gone all work
but on the railway. ‘There was no
point in keeping the animals, you
have to make money. You have to
be able to pay for processing and
transport.’
There had been a geological
survey base in Soviet times but it
was found to be unprofitable, so it
was closed and all the equipment
sold off. Now it has been reopened.
‘We realized that in Russia all we
can do is drink vodka and sell oil, so
we need to find more oil. If we run
out we won’t even be able to buy
vodka, so these geologists are back,’
he said.
I asked him whether he was
depressed about being a Russian.
‘I haven’t called myself that for
thirty years. I don’t think about that.
As soon as you think about being a
Russian, you think about not being a
Jew,’ he said. ‘I remember Zinoviev,
the leader of the revolution, had a
Jewish name because people began
to talk about it after 1991, and to
wash all this dirty washing and to
talk about how the Jews were to
blame for everything, how all the
Jews were bad and all the Russians
were good and so on.’
He shrugged. He had escaped to
the pure clean north. He wanted
nothing to do with all that dirtiness.
At four the next morning, I was a
dumpy figure in the cold waiting for
the train south, towards the sun. The
thick clothes and darkness made all
of us on the platform look the same,
men or women, misshapen like clay
dolls.
Alexander told me as we waited
on the platform that ‘before’ 300
children had studied at the village
school. Now there were just ninety. I
thought about that word ‘before’.
Before, there was order. Before,
there were children. Before, there
was work. Before, people drank less.
Before, people lived beyond their
twenties.
In Two Years in Abez, Nikolai
Punin looked out at the grim view of
Abez. ‘If you asked me what hell
looked like, I would describe it just
like that: the total rule of the straight
line and the right angle. No free
spirit was left alive by their
obsession with tidiness, fences and
orderly
footpaths,
all
neatly
maintained and swept constantly.
Who said that hell is packed with
good intentions? Quite the opposite,
there were no good intentions, only
meaningless ones and that made
inmates lose all hope.’
A crowd of railway workers
boarded the train and, although I had
a ticket, it seemed I had to sit in the
cheapest compartment until I got to
Inta, where I could be assigned bed
linen. Hunched in my coat, hat and
scarf almost touching across my
face, I dozed.
The train’s approach to Inta was
heralded by the phone of a teenage
girl on the bench opposite me. There
had been no reception for the two-
hour journey through the forest, but
we were now within range of a
mobile tower in the town. Her ring
tone was a repeated English-
language chorus: ‘I am a sexy girl. I
like you fuck me well. I am a sexy
girl. I like you fuck me well. I am a
sexy girl.’ She grappled under her
coat to find it, pressed the green
button
and
began
a muttered
conversation with her mother. I
wondered if she knew what the
words of her ringtone meant.
The prevalence of such trashy
English-language
culture
is,
I
supposed, another sign of the
collapse of Russian confidence. The
dregs of Anglo-America had been
dumped on places like Inta, and been
taken up for want of anything else
vaguely vibrant. As I waited for us
to
pull
into
the
platform,
I
remembered other examples I had
seen up here. One taxi driver had
affixed a semi-transparent sunshade
across the top of his windscreen with
the English words: ‘Guns don’t kill
people, I kill people’ (I have
corrected his spelling).
Most startling of all, however,
had been a T-shirt – it must have
come from a Sekond Khend – I had
seen worn by a middle-aged man.
Below a picture of a grinning male
face, it bore the boast that ‘Five
billion potential grandchildren died
on your daughter’s face last night.’
What path did that take to get to its
final owner?
When, after Inta, I finally got my
bunk and snuggled down in the
warm, I mused over how it was that
English-language trash culture had
penetrated so far into Russia. After
World War Two, Western writers
feared that Russia’s totalitarian state
would conquer them all, but in fact
the reverse happened. Russia today
is like the opposite of
A Clockwork
Orange
, the dystopian novel by
Anthony Burgess. At that time the
Soviet Union seemed so powerful
that he imagined a future when
Western teenagers spoke a slang
peppered
with
Russian
words:
moloko
for milk;
droog
for friend;
horrorshow
for good. But that is not
how it turned out. It is not Western
hooligans using pidgin Russian as
slang, but out-of-control young
Russians speaking pidgin English.
You see it in the graffiti along the
railway
lines:
White
Pride,
Skinheads, Hooligans.
This penetration began in the
1960s, when the West pioneered
mass fashion and the Beatles.
Russians old enough to remember
talk about listening to foreign pop
music on home-made LPs fashioned
from X-ray film, which was solid
enough to keep the groove, although
it did not hold it for long. But
Western culture still had to sneak
through the chinks in the Iron
Curtain. That meant a random
selection of Western bands and
writers, protected by the communist
state
from
more
vigorous
competitors, flourished in the Soviet
Union when they withered and died
at home. Like flightless birds on an
inaccessible island, bands like King
Crimson, Jethro Tull and Judas
Priest
became
hugely
popular,
expanding to fill evolutionary niches
they had no access to in the West.
Minor band members still play solo
concerts in major Moscow venues
when they might struggle to fill the
back room of a pub in London.
Meanwhile,
bands
like
the
Rolling Stones are all but unknown.
Their records for some reason failed
to penetrate the Soviet counterculture
at the right time. As the train rattled
along, I plugged in the spoken
version of Stones guitarist Keith
Richards’s autobiography, and his
words helped the thought process
along.
‘We were not destroying the
virtue of the nation but they think we
are so eventually we’re drawn into a
war,’ said Keith at one point as he
described his arrest and conviction
on drugs charges.
If Keith thought that his one
night in Wormwood Scrubs was a
declaration of war by the authorities,
he should have looked at what was
happening in the Soviet Union. His
same post-war generation, his Soviet
contemporaries,
full
of
fiery
optimism, attempted to do what he
and his friends did and revitalize
culture, inject it with a bit of
dynamism. The first post-Stalin
dissidents were young people who
gathered at a statue of Vladimir
Mayakovsky in Moscow to read
their poems in the late 1950s and
early
1960s.
They
were
the
equivalent of the bohemians meeting
in coffee shops in Chelsea or in
Greenwich Village.
The Soviet state at first was not
quite sure how to respond. Boris
Pasternak was criticized for his
Western-style novel
Dr Zhivago
, but
he was not arrested, nor did he lose
his country home in Peredelkino, a
village where houses were reserved
for artists and writers.
Two of his disciples – Andrei
Sinyavsky and Yuli Daniel –
however, were to be made examples
of. And it was their arrest and