Two Dude Ranchers for Dawn [Cowboy City 1] (Siren Publishing Ménage and More) (11 page)

Ben sucked her bottom lip into his mouth as he slid his fingers between her legs, encouraging her to part them by pushing at her thighs with the side of his hand.

Garrett moved her hair away from her ear and pressed his lips against it. “Tell us what you want, darlin’.”

“I just want to please you both.”

“It would please us both to fuck you ’til you faint, but tonight’s about you, not us.”

He grabbed her chin, turning her face to his so he could kiss her. Ben leaned down and took one of her nipples into his mouth, his hand still teasing at her clit.

The next thing she knew, her feet were off the floor as Garrett swung her up into his arms and carried her out of the room. The bedroom was at the end of a narrow hall, and he kicked the door open, then walked across to the bed in the center of a large, sparsely decorated room, and placed her on it.

Dawn slid onto the middle of the mattress as Ben clicked on a lamp, casting the room in a soft glow, and joined her on the bed. Garrett got something from the drawer in the bedside cabinet then lay down on her other side.

Dawn knew they were waiting for her to make a move, but she didn’t know which way to turn or what to do first. She bit her lip, suppressing a bubble of nerves. She took a deep breath and closed her eyes, too much of a wimp to see how they might react to what she was about to say.

“What turns me on the most is being dominated a little, but I’m not into whips or chains or any of that stuff.”

She felt Garrett tense beside her, but Ben just laughed gently and turned to look down at her. “I think you just made someone’s day.” He jerked his head toward Garrett when he saw she didn’t understand what he meant. “He loves thinking he’s in control.”

Garrett turned to look at her, his expression unapologetic. “How far do you want us to go?”

Dawn didn’t have an answer to a question that both scared and excited her. “I–I don’t know. I’m not into pain.”

Ben rubbed her shoulder. “Don’t worry, neither is he. If he does something that hurts, it hurts good.”

“Like what?”

Dawn left the question hanging, praying that someone would take it as the invitation it was and show her.

“Like this.” Garrett pounced, startling her with the sudden movement and pinning her arms above her head. His free hand stroked her face and his fingers trailed across her lips and he slid one into her open mouth. “Suck it.”

She closed her lips around it, flicking her tongue over the tip and straining upward to keep hold of it as he pulled it away. Garrett trailed it over her chin and down her throat, leaving a wet trail. Dawn held her breath as his finger reached the curve of her breast and he drew circles around her nipple without actually touching it. She shuddered as the throbbing pulse in her pussy beat harder.

Garrett reached over to grab Ben by the back of the neck, dragging him closer and kissing him hard, then pushing his head down toward Dawn’s breasts. Ben followed the unspoken instruction, flicking his tongue out and barely grazing her aching peak at first, and then he closed his mouth over it, sucking hard. Dawn jerked beneath him, trying to get closer, fighting against Garrett’s hand forcing her to lie still.

“Hold on to the headboard, Dawn. If you let go, I’ll tie you to it, understand?”

She did as she was told, sure she wouldn’t have the willpower to comply for long. Her hands itched with the urge to grab one or both of their dicks. The thought of disobeying him excited her. What would he do if she did?

Garrett crawled down the bed and thrust her legs apart to kneel in the gap between her thighs. Her vision of him was blocked by Ben while he alternated between sucking her nipples and kissing her.

“So fucking beautiful,” she heard Garrett mutter to himself.

She tried to figure out what he was doing when he didn’t touch her immediately, but Ben kept distracting her. When Garrett’s hands gripped the back of her knees and he lifted her legs over his shoulders, Dawn knew for sure what was coming next.

She didn’t expect him to lift her bottom right off the bed and tilt her body at an angle that almost brought her up on to her shoulders. Ben stopped kissing her and turned to look at Garrett, moving out of the way so Dawn could watch, too. Garrett sucked two fingers into his mouth and then pushed them into her vagina, right to the knuckle.

“Give her your cock, Ben.”

Dawn squeezed her eyelids shut as Garrett pumped his fingers in and out of her, making her pant noisily and leaving her mouth open wide to receive Ben’s dick. When she felt the tip trail across her lips, she surged upward, sucking him in.

“Fuck.” She looked up at the sound of Ben’s voice to find him straddling her torso, his knees pressed into the bed on either side of her shoulders and his arms braced against the wall.

Dawn couldn’t see Garrett anymore, but she didn’t need to see him to know what he was about to do. He pulled his fingers out of her and wrapped his arms around her hips, pinning her ass against his chest. Then she felt his mouth close around her clit.

Her calves slipped from his shoulders, splaying her legs wide as they came to rest around his upper arms, exposing every inch of her flesh to him. Garrett grunted in approval and ran his tongue over her folds, dipping it into her pussy a few times to spread her wetness around. He latched on to her clit again and began to shake his head from side to side, taking her arousal to another level.

She tried to cry out, but Ben’s dick muffled the sound, so she groaned around it, making him shout out instead. Dawn tilted her head back to open her throat so she could take more of him in. His balls slapped against her chin when he thrust again, and he gasped in surprise when his cock slid right to the back of her throat.

Ben pulled out of her rapidly, and stared down at her, his abdomen trembling. She strained upward, desperate to finish him off, but he grinned and shook his head. “If I let myself come before you do, Garrett will kill me.”

“Damn right,” she heard Garrett say, his voice muffled against her skin.

He released his grip on her, letting her body fall back to the bed and reached over her to grab a bottle and a small black object that she couldn’t see clearly, from the nightstand. He held her gaze as he squeezed some lube into his hand and worked it around his index and middle finger. Dawn bit her lip, and Garrett smiled, as if pleased she knew what was coming.

“Get on all fours, honey.”

The lube felt cold against her ass but the sensation didn’t last long. Garrett worked his fingers into her, muttering his approval as she took him right in and Dawn felt the back of his fist graze the cheeks of her butt as he twisted his fingers around inside her.

He pulled them out and she felt something cold and hard press against her hole. Her ass stretched in a pleasurably painful way as he pushed the butt plug into her and Dawn’s pussy gave a hard spasm as her muscles clamped around the toy.

“You like that, huh?” Garrett asked.

Dawn heard Garrett open a condom, and she held her breath as she waited, eager for him to thrust his dick into her. Ben kneeled in front of her and offered her his cock again, bunching her hair in a hand so he could hold her head still and control how deeply she took him this time.

Garrett’s hands splayed across the back of her thighs, and his fingers bit into her skin as he spread her wide. His cock nudged at her entrance, giving her a warning of what was to come, and then he slid in, in one, breathtaking thrust.

Dawn’s muscles clamped around his shaft and the plug in her butt, convulsing in hard, almost painful spasms. She tore her mouth away from Ben’s body, scared she might bite down if the feelings Garrett was creating got any more intense. Ben crawled to her side and slid his head and shoulders under her torso and rubbed at her clitoris, adding to the torture Garrett was inflicting on her.

Garrett stilled for a second, and then she felt him shudder against her. “Fuck yes, Ben. Keep doing that.”

His hand knotted in her hair, and he pulled her head back hard, forcing her to stay still and accept his thrusts. The next time he pushed into her, Dawn felt the impact from the top of her head to the tips of her toes and she screamed out in pleasure.

“That’s it, show us how you like it,” Garrett said, giving her one hard jab with his cock after another.

Her eyes started to water as the friction on her G-spot made the walls of her cunt draw in tighter and tighter and she saw sparks behind her clenched eyelids. A rush of heat to her groin was the only warning she got that she was about to come, and the sharp sting on her ass when Garrett slapped her tipped her over the edge.

A series of spasms, each more intense than the last, rendered her helpless, and Dawn started to cry as the sensations overwhelmed her and she feared she couldn’t handle much more. Her orgasm crested, and she tumbled down the other side, gasping as one strong contraction after another made her pussy pulse around Garrett’s cock. When they faded away, leaving her shuddering in their wake, Garrett gently eased his dick out of her and removed the plug from her ass. Dawn collapsed onto the mattress, her muscles turned to jelly, and her chest heaved as she gasped for air.

The bed shook violently beside her, and she turned to find Garrett standing above a kneeling Ben, ramming his cock into his mouth. Dawn brushed her hair out of her eyes so she could watch them touch each other. Garrett’s thighs trembled as he thrust into Ben over and over again, and she looked up into his face, only to find him staring down at her.

Amazed that she still had the energy, Dawn rolled on to her knees and moved closer and pressed her lips to Garrett’s rib cage. Her hand closed around one of his firm buttocks and she felt the play of his muscles as he thrust into Ben’s mouth.

Ben released Garrett’s dick and turned to her, cupping her chin to bring her face around so he could kiss her. Garrett dropped down to kneel beside them, the three of them facing each other in the center of the bed.

“Aren’t you tired yet?” Garrett’s voice held a mixture of humor and amazement.

She shook her head. “Uh uh.” Dawn reached down and wrapped a hand around each of their dicks, and began to pull on them gently. “I’ve figured out what it is I want.”

Garrett gave her a shaky laugh as she pulled on his penis a little harder. “Oh, really?”

“I want both of you to fuck me, at the same time. I want you to come inside me, together.”

Ben’s body shuddered in response to her words, and Garrett groaned aloud. “Are you sure you can take both of us?”

“I think so.”

She’d had anal a few times before when Simon had pressured her into it, but had never actually wanted to do it, not until now. Dawn cast her gaze downward, scared that they’d refuse.

Garrett placed a finger under chin and made her look at him. “Don’t worry, darlin’. We’ll take it slow. The second you tell us to stop, we will. Right, Ben?”

“Absolutely.” Ben’s lazy drawl made a mockery of the rigid tension in his face, leaving her in no doubt about how much he was into the idea.

Dawn watched them each put on a condom, and she saw Garrett slip Ben the lube, even though she wasn’t meant to. She gave a little smile of relief. Dawn seriously doubted she could handle Garrett’s massive cock.

Ben rolled into the center of the bed, propped his torso up against the pillows, and pulled her on top of him, turning her so her back was toward him. She straddled his body and watched Garrett kneel in the gap between Ben’s thighs. Garrett pulled her forward for a kiss and she leaned into him, presenting her butt to Ben and tensing in anticipation.

He didn’t enter her as expected. His fingers trailed up her torso and he cupped her breast, nibbling at her back. Garrett continued to kiss her as his hand grazed across her clit, teasing her gently. She groaned into his mouth, amazed that her sensitive flesh responded so eagerly. His efforts intensified, encouraged by her throaty cries, and he brought her to the edge of another orgasm in what seemed like seconds.

“Ready?” she heard Ben ask, his voice barely audible over the sound of her groans.

“Yes.”

Dawn heard the tension in her voice and realized she was a little afraid. What if she couldn’t take them both?

“Relax, honey,” Garrett said, moving his hand against her slowly, just enough to keep her on the edge of climax. “Ben is gonna take it slow.”

Ben eased her legs forward, her feet pointing toward Garrett, and pushed her forward. Garrett lifted her at the waist, allowing Ben the access he needed. He slid a well-lubed finger into her ass and worked it inside, making her ready for him. Dawn’s vagina clenched at the sensation and she felt her thighs tremble.

“Now, Ben. Do it now.”

She felt his hands spread the cheeks of her butt, and then a pressure against the knot of her ass.

The slight burn she felt as he pushed the tip in was bearable, and he held still for a second, giving her time to get used to the feel of him. Ben’s hands replaced Garrett’s on her waist and he took her weight as Garrett rubbed her at clit again, harder than before, making Dawn’s pussy convulse and a little more of Ben slid in to her ass.

Ben spread his legs, pushing hers further apart and opening her wider. He thrust upward, filling her more, and pulled on her torso to encourage her to lie back against him. Garrett bent down and licked at her clit, pushing a finger inside her and frigging her as fast as he could while Ben’s hands closed around her breasts and he began to jerk into her.

Dawn closed her eyes, stunned at how good Ben’s cock felt inside her. She pushed back against him, taking the rest of him in, trembling each time his hips slapped her ass.

Garrett stopped touching her, and she opened her eyes to find him half kneeling over her, one leg straddling one of her and Ben’s thighs, his foot resting on the bed beside them. His handsome head dropped, and she saw him grasp his cock as he leaned over her body at an angle, taking his weight on one arm and the knee between her thighs as he put his penis at the entrance to her pussy.