Read Financial Markets Operations Management Online
Authors: Keith Dickinson
Non-centrally cleared (also known as bilaterally cleared) OTC derivatives transactions are executed either between buyer and seller or on a trading platform. The main difference from cleared OTCD transactions is that these OTCD contracts are processed and risk managed between the two trading counterparties. These are legally binding contracts that need to be fully documented.
Trading between any two parties is covered under a set of documents, as shown in
Table 9.12
.
TABLE 9.12
Documentation
Document | Description |
Master Agreement | Published by the International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA). The current version is the 2002 edition and it defines the terms and conditions under which both parties deal with each other. All transactions between the two parties are covered by this single agreement. |
Schedule | Used to customise the Master Agreement including amendments and additional terms. |
Confirmation | Confirmations are exchanged for each transaction and include relevant terms of the transaction. |
Definitions | ISDA publishes a series of booklets, defining each type of derivative transaction, and user guides. |
Credit Support Annex | An optional document, the CSA is used when both parties agree to use collateral to cover risk exposures. |
Within the set of documents shown in
Table 9.12
there are many variations, depending on the asset class of the derivative, the year the document was published and in which country the document applies. The International Swaps and Derivatives Association (ISDA), founded in 1985, has over 800 member institutions from 64 countries and has done much to improve the industry's operational structure, reduce counterparty credit risk and increase transparency.
There are six asset classes listed on the ISDA website:
A variety of publications including definitions, confirmation templates, etc. can be found for each of these six classes. Please go to the Asset Classes section of the ISDA website (
www2.isda.org/asset-classes
) and familiarise yourself with some of the documentation available.
There is an extensive library and bookstore available on the ISDA website, parts of which are available for members only. The remaining parts are open for general inspection and are categorised as shown in
Table 9.13
.
TABLE 9.13
ISDA publications
Category | Examples of Documents |
ISDA Master Agreement | Master Agreements (2002, 1992) plus MA user guides and MA translations. |
ISDA credit support documentation | Credit Support Annexes (CSAs) in English and New York law versions, user guides, amendments to CSAs, the 2001 ISDA margin provisions and collateral documentation. |
Cleared swap documentation | FIA-ISDA Cleared Derivatives Execution Agreement plus various addenda. |
ISDA definitions and confirmations | Sub-categorised by product type: commodity/energy, equity, inflation, property index, credit, FX, interest rate and currency and miscellaneous documents. |
ISDA operations and novation material | Novation definitions, best practice statements and user guides. |
ISDA protocols/EMU and Euro material | Documentation relevant to the economic and monetary union in Europe (1997), Euro definitions (1998) and the introduction of the Euro (2001 Euro Protocol). |
Regulatory documentation | Initiative documents relevant to DoddâFrank (USA) and EMIR (EU). |
Disclosure documents | Annexes from 2012 (plus 2013 updates) regarding disclosure relating to certain CTFC requirements. |
FpML and miscellaneous ISDA documents | FpML user guides, index of terms, terms for escrow float transactions and a pre-confirmation trade notification template (2001). |
Please go back to the Bookstore section of the ISDA website (
www.isda.org/publications/ pubguide.aspx
) and familiarise yourself with some of the documentation contained within the nine categories noted in
Table 9.13
.
It will be apparent from your review of the ISDA website just how much documentation is required in the OTC derivatives business. There is a high degree of focus in terms of product type, so organisations will only require the relevant documentation for their own business.
Due to the numerous types of OTCD and their complexities, space does not permit us to look at each of them in turn from an operational point of view. Rather, we will go through the overall process flows from trade capture to maturity, giving some examples along the way. Many of these processes are quite similar across the whole financial operations spectrum and we will concentrate on those that are particularly relevant to OTCD transactions.
As soon as the trades are entered into the trade capture system (either automatically or manually), the details of each trade should be verified. This can be complicated, depending on the type of derivative being entered, and every detail from the trade ticket (term sheet) should be carefully checked. Remember that these are bespoke transactions and not standardised like ETD or cash market products.
If we compare the trade details of a forward rate agreement (FRA) with an option (
Table 9.14
), we can see that the terminology can differ.
TABLE 9.14
Options vs FRAs
Option | FRA | |
Trade direction | Hold (buy) or write (sell) | Buy or sell |
Quantity | Number of contracts | Notional amount |
Asset | Underlying single name or basket or index | Currency of the notional amount |
Key dates | Trade date Expiry date(s) | Trade date Effective date Settlement date FRA period (term) |
Option style | European American Asian Bermudan Knock-in and Knock-out Quanto Composite Digital | N/A |
Option type | Call or put | N/A |
Cost/price | Premium | Interest rate (fixed) |
Settlement | Cash settled or physical delivery of the underlying | Discounted difference between fixed interest rate and reference rate (floating) calculated on the notional amount |
In its annual Operations Benchmarking Survey 2013,
14
ISDA noted that the most common errors across the five product categories
15
were caused by:
Counterparties can initially affirm the key economic details of their trades with each other before sending outgoing confirmations, chasing and reviewing incoming confirmations or investigating and reconciling confirmation discrepancies. A confirmation provides a more detailed view of a transaction at one point in time and should be sent as soon as possible.
In order to standardise the confirmation format, the ISDA has prepared a set of templates. Examples available on the ISDA's Bookstore include an eight-page confirmation of a non-deliverable cross-currency interest rate swap transaction and eighteen forms, of similar length, covering confirmations for the various types of equity-based transaction.
With the notable exception of equity derivatives, confirmations are sent electronically (see
Table 9.15
).
TABLE 9.15
Confirmations
Electronically Eligible | |||
Derivative Type | Electronically Confirmed | Not Electronically Confirmed | Not Electronically Eligible |
Interest rate | 86% | Â 7% | Â 7% |
Credit | 98% | Â 0% | Â 1% |
Equity | 30% | 10% | 60% |
Currency options | 69% | 15% | 16% |
Commodity | 66% | 20% | 13% |
Source:
ISDA Operations Benchmark Survey 2013.
Electronically transmitted confirmations are usually all sent by T+1, with non-electronically transmitted confirmations all sent by T+6 to
T+10. The average number of business days for which confirmations are outstanding tends to be in the region of 0.3 to 1.6 days late, with the notable exception of equity-based (6.1 days).
Depending on the derivatives contract, a settlement action may or may not take place. Some examples are shown in
Tables 9.16
,
9.17
and
9.18
.
TABLE 9.16
Settlement actions for an FRA
Forward Rate Agreement | Term Sheet | Action Required |
Notional amount | USD 10,000,000 | |
Deal type | Dealer buys 3 Ã 9 FRA | |
Trade date | Today | Book trade and confirm details with counterparty |
Settlement date | In three months' time | Two days prior to SD, observe reference rate, calculate discounted amount of interest receivable or payable. Prepare payment or pre-advice instructions |
Maturity date | In nine months' time | |
Contract period | A six-month period starting in three months' time | |
Reference rate | Six-month BBA USD LIBOR |
TABLE 9.17
Settlement actions for an OTC option
OTC Options | Term Sheet | Action Required |
Trade date | Today | Book trade and confirm details with counterparty |
Option type | Call | |
Option style | Bermudan with exercise opportunity every Wednesday by close of business. Holder's choice to exercise; physical delivery. | Every Wednesday, observe share price. If price is > break-even (USD 10.00), your dealer can exercise the option. Settlement will be for regular settlement: 10,000 shares DVP USD 90,000.00. |
Expiry | 10 weeks' time | |
Deal type | You hold 100 contracts of a single name equity (each contract = 100 shares) | |
Premium | USD 1.00 per share | On T+1, pay premium of USD 10,000 to writer. |
Strike price | USD 9.00 per share |
TABLE 9.18
Settlement actions for a bi-laterally cleared interest rate swap
IRS Bilaterally Cleared | Term Sheet | Action Required |
Notional | CCY 10,000,000 | |
Term | 5 years | |
Fixed | 5% p.a. payable annually | |
Floating | Six-month benchmark rate + 50 bp receivable semi-annually (Act/365) | |
Trade date | Today | Book trade and confirm details with counterparty. Observe 6m interest rate. |
Effective date | T+2 | |
Reset dates | Every six months â 2 days | Observe 6m interest rate for next reset period. |
Payment dates (fixed) | Every 12 months | Pay interest of 500,000.00 |
Payment dates (floating) | Every six months | Receive interest at previous reset rate plus 50 bp |