Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre (156 page)

Read Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre Online

Authors: Jonathan Israel

Tags: #History, #Europe, #France, #Revolutionary, #Modern, #18th Century, #Philosophy, #Political, #Social

BOOK: Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre
10.9Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub

115
.  Belissa, “Les Leçons de républicanisme,” 64–66.

116
.  Wahnich,
L’impossible citoyen
, 160–61; Doyle,
Aristocracy and Its Enemies
, 290.

117
.  Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 453.

118
.  Wahnich,
L’impossible citoyen
, 185; Buel,
Joel Barlow
, 179.

119
.  Buel,
Joel Barlow
, 179–80.

120
.  
Journal de Perlet
7, no. 434 (30 Nov. 1793), 485–86.

121
.  Sewell, “Sans-Culotte Rhetoric,” 257–61.

122
.  
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 461 (27 Dec. 1793), 214, no. 463 (29 Dec. 1793), 229–30, and no. 464 (30 Dec. 1793), 238.

123
.  Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 46, 148–49,181–83; Robisco,
Jean-Jacques Rousseau
, 233.

124
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 1492 (5 Nivose, Year II), 6516; Guilhaumou and Monnier, “Cordeliers,” 207.

125
.  Hampson,
Saint-Just
, 162–63.

126
.  
Gazette nationale
, no. 94 (24 Dec. 1793), 27;
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 459 (25 Dec. 1793), 198–200 and no. 460 (26 Dec. 1793), 208; Hampson,
Life and Opinions
, 218–19.

127
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 1492 (5 Novise, Year II), 6517–18;
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 456 (22 Dec. 1793), 171.

128
.  Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 108–9.

129
.  
Gazette nationale
, no. 94 (24 Dec. 1793), 26–27;
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 461 (27 Dec. 1793), 214–15.

130
.  
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 465 (31 Dec. 1793), 241.

131
.  Ibid., no. 460 (26 Dec. 1793), 204–5; Dupuy,
La république jacobine
, 242–43.

132
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 82:464 (29 Dec. 1793); Moore,
Moral Purity
, 69–76.

133
.  Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 89, 115; Sa’adah,
Shaping
, 182.

134
.  
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 45 (31 Dec. 1793), 241–43.

135
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:598–99 (7 Jan. 1794); Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 1509 (22 Nivose, Year II), 6652–53; Gershoy,
Betrand Barère
, 206.

136
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:601 (8 Jan. 1794); Hampson,
Saint-Just
, 163–64, 179; Sonenscher,
Sans-Culottes
, 405.

137
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:610 (12 Jan. 1794);
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 480 (15 Jan. 1794), 35.

138
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:605 (10 Jan. 1794); Moore,
Moral Purity
, 131.

139
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:605 (10 Jan. 1794).

140
.  
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 477 (12 Jan. 1794), 340; Chopelin-Blanc,
De l’apologétique
, 520–21, 534–37.

141
.  
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 478 (13 Jan. 1794), 348–49; Chopelin-Blanc,
De l’apologétique
, 510–11.

142
.  
Journal de Perlet
8, no. 483 (18 Jan. 1794), 388.

143
.  Ibid., no. 481 (26 Jan. 1794); Hampson,
Life and Opinions
, 194–95.

144
.  Doyle,
Oxford History
, 258.

CHAPTER 20

The Terror’s Last Months (March–July 1794)

1
.  Roederer,
Spirit of the Revolution
, 82.
2
.  Becamps,
Un Bordelais
, 74–75.
3
.  E. Kennedy,
Cultural History
, 405; Popkin, “Not Over After All,” 814.
4
.  Tulard,
Histoire et dictionnaire
, 1114; Doyle,
Aristocracy and Its Enemies
, 293; Andress,
The Terror
, 212–13.
5
.  Tulard,
Histoire et dictionnaire
, 798; Doyle,
Aristocracy and Its Enemies
, 293.
6
.  D’Abrantès,
Salons révolutionnaires
, 105.
7
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:674 (6 March 1794); Jacob,
Hébert
, 317; Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 460.
8
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
no. 1556 (9 Ventose, Year II), 7052; Jacob,
Hébert
, 317, 319.
9
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 1573 (26 Ventose, Year II), 7161–62.
10
.  Hampson,
Saint-Just
, 176–80.
11
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:683–84 (14 March 1794); Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 462–63.
12
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 5:686–87 (14 March 1794).
13
.  Jacob,
Hébert
, 333; Antheunis,
Le conventionnel belge
, 64–65; Tulard,
Histoire et dictionnaire
, 1075.
14
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 1577 (30 Ventose, Year II), 7194; Dupuy,
La république jacobine
, 252–53; Scurr,
Fatal Purity
, 277; Jacob,
Hébert
, 336.
15
.  Saint-Just,
Œuvres complètes
, 713; Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 90–91;
Gazette nationale
176 (16 March 1794), 706.
16
.  Linton,
Conspiracies Real and Imagined
, 138.
17
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 6:11–12 (21 March 1794).
18
.  Hampson,
Life and Opinions
, 202, 211; McPhee,
Robespierre
, 189; Linton,
Conspiracies Real and Imagined
, 137–41.
19
.  Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 110; Saint-Just,
Œuvres complètes
, 713; Wallon,
Histoire
, 1:37, 1:49, 1:53; Rosendaal,
Bataven!
, 413.
20
.  Andress,
The Terror
, 268; Rosendaal,
Bataven!
, 414–15; Klein,
Patriots republikanisme
, 249.
21
.  Jacob,
Hébert
, 350–51.
22
.  Ibid., 353; Gershoy,
Betrand Barère
, 213–14; Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 469, 481.
23
.  Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 96.
24
.  Ibid., 113; Sa’adah,
Shaping
, 181–82.
25
.  Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 96–97.
26
.  Ibid., 134–37.
27
.  Baudot,
Notes historiques
, 102, 130, 150, 156; Desmoulins,
Vieux Cordelier
, 61; Gueniffey,
La politique de la Terreur
, 30–31, 271–72.
28
.  Baudot,
Notes historiques
, 205.
29
.  Hampson,
Life and Opinions
, 221–23; McPhee,
Robespierre
, 190–91.
30
.  Baudot,
Notes historiques
, 215, 231; Antheunis,
Le conventionnel belge
, 67–68.
31
.  Staël,
Considerations
, 362; Guillois,
Salon de Madame Helvétius
, 83–84.
32
.  Robespierre,
Discours du 8 Thermidor
, 32.
33
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 6:36–37 (31 March 1794).
34
.  Ibid., 6:51 (5 April 1794).
35
.  Dard,
Hérault de Sechelles
, 357.
36
.  Vinot,
Saint-Just
, 277–79.
37
.  Saint-Just,
Œuvres complètes
, 718–25; Hampson,
Saint-Just
, 193, 195–96; Godineau,
Women of Paris
, 187–88.
38
.  Aulard,
La Société des Jacobins
, 6:43–52 (5 April 1794).
39
.  Wahnich,
L’Impossible citoyen
, 202.
40
.  Roederer,
Spirit of the Revolution
, 81–88.
41
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
1576 (29 Ventose, Year II), 7186, 7190.
42
.  Roederer,
Spirit of the Revolution
, 84.
43
.  De Baecque, “Pamphlets,” 166.
44
.  Zizek, “Plume de fer,” 627–28.
45
.  Popkin,
Right-Wing Press
, 17, 19.
46
.  Saint-Just,
Œuvres complètes
, 748;
La Décade philosophique
1 (10 Floreal), 35–37; Hampson,
Saint-Just
, 199.
47
.  Saint-Just,
Œuvres complètes
, 756–62;
La Décade philosophique
1 (10 Floreal), 39–40, 42; Doyle,
Aristocracy and Its Enemies
, 291.
48
.  
La Décade philosophique
1 (10 Floreal), 33.
49
.  Ibid., 76.
50
.  Ibid.
51
.  Ibid., 73–74.
52
.  Ibid., 77.
53
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 90:137 (7 May 1794); Ozouf,
Festivals
, 108–9.
54
.  Robespierre,
Discours du 18 Floreal
, 16.
55
.  Ibid., 20.
56
.  Ibid., 21.
57
.  Ibid., 36; E. Badinter and R. Badinter,
Condorcet, 1743–1794
, 575.
58
.  Robespierre,
Discours du 8 Thermidor
, 30; Saint-Just,
Œuvres complètes
, 716; Roederer,
De la philosophie
, 36.
59
.  Robespierre,
Discours du 8 Thermidor
, 31–32; Crow,
Emulation
, 175–76, 178.
60
.  Robespierre,
Discours du 8 Thermidor
, 33;
La Décade philosophique
1 (30 Floreal), 190.
61
.  Robespierre,
Discours du 8 Thermidor
, 43–44; Ozouf,
Festivals
, 108; Edelstein,
Terror
, 232–34.
62
.  Robespierre,
Discours du 8 Thermidor
, 20–21; Hampson,
Life and Opinions
, 273; Scurr,
Fatal Purity
, 289–92.
63
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 90:567–68 (23 May).
64
.  Ibid., 93:8–9, 13, 39 (9 July 1794).
65
.  Ibid., 90:576 (13 June).
66
.  Ibid., 93:37 (10 July 1794).
67
.  Ibid., 93:122 (13 July 1794).
68
.  Ibid., 91:302 (4 June 1794).
69
.  Ibid., 91:228 (2 June 1794).
70
.  Ibid., 93:301, 310–11 (19 July 1794).
71
.  Mongrédien,
French Music
, 39–40, 266; Gueniffey,
La politique de la Terreur
, 275, 301, 315.
72
.  
La Décade philosophique
1 (30 Prairial), 339–40; Baudot,
Notes historiques
, 4–5.
73
.  
La Décade philosophique
1 (30 Prairial), 341–42; Kitchin,
Journal
, 6, 17, 30–31, 34.
74
.  
La Décade philosophique
1 (30 Prairial), 342–46; Tallett, “Robespierre and Religion,” 102–6.
75
.  Baudot,
Notes historiques
, 4–5.
76
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 90:569 (23 May 1794), 93:59 (10 July1794), and 93:284 (18 July 1794).
77
.  Dupuy,
La république jacobine
, 264; Andress,
The Terror
, 311, 325, 330.
78
.  Gueniffey,
La politique de la Terreur
, 277–84.
79
.  
Annales Patriotiques
, no. 552 (7 July 1794), 2420.
80
.  Wollstonecraft,
Collected Letters
, 255.

Other books

Swerve by Michelle McGriff
Hearts in Motion by Edie Ramer
Vauxhall Vixen by Cindy Lee
Awakening Beauty by Bonnie Dee and Marie Treanor
The Rapist by Edgerton, Les
Starbright by Richland, Alexandra
Partners In Crime by Katy Munger