Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre (152 page)

Read Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre Online

Authors: Jonathan Israel

Tags: #History, #Europe, #France, #Revolutionary, #Modern, #18th Century, #Philosophy, #Political, #Social

BOOK: Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre
7.3Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
7
.  Popkin,
You Are All Free
, 39–40.
8
.  
La Chronique de Paris
2, 69 (10 March 1790), 274.
9
.  Ibid., 1, 48 (10 Oct. 1789), 234.
10
.  Ibid., 2, 15 (15 Jan. 1790), 57.
11
.  Griffiths,
Le Centre perdu
, 200–202; Piquet,
L’Émancipation
, 53–55.
12
.  Gouges,
Œuvres
, 83–87; Verdier, “From Reform,” 190.
13
.  BL Pamphlet collection R-328/7, 1–2.
14
.  Brissot,
Le Patriote français
115 (1 Dec. 1789), 4, and 117 (3 Dec. 1789), 2.
15
.  Destutt de Tracy,
Premiers écrits
, 32–33; Granié,
De l’Assemblée
, 120; Régent,
La France
, 215.
16
.  Piquet,
L’Émancipation
, 59.
17
.  Bertrand de Molleville,
Mémoires secrets
, 2:244.
18
.  
Découverte d’une conspiration
(BL R-328/10), 3–17.
19
.  
Il est encore des Aristocrates
(BL R-328/11), 5.
20
.  Ibid., 6–7.
21
.  Brissot,
Mémoires (1734–1793)
, 2:96–97; Garrigus, “Opportunist,” 11; Hunt,
Inventing Human Rights
, 163.
22
.  Destutt de Tracy,
Premiers écrits
, 72.
23
.  Montesquieu,
De L’Esprit des Lois
, vol. 3, book 7, in
Œuvres complètes
, 620; Ghachem, “Montesquieu,” 12–14; Ehrard, “Audace,” 35–38; Piquet,
L’Émancipation
, 32–35; Israel,
Democratic Enlightenment
, 423–24.
24
.  Régent,
La France
, 219.
25
.  Brissot,
Mémoires (1734–1793)
, 2:96–99; Benot,
La révolution
, 67, 77–78; Garrigus, “Vincent Ogé,” 37, 49, 52, 61.
26
.  Brissot,
Patriote français
531 (21 Jan. 1791), 84.
27
.  See J. Garran de Coulon’s essay in
La Chronique du mois
(Jan. 1792), 88–108; Griffiths,
Le Centre perdu
, 202–3; Chill,
Power
, 7–8.
28
.  Popkin,
You Are All Free
, 78.
29
.  Garrigus, “Opportunist,” 7; Klooster,
Revolutions
, 98–99.
30
.  Hunt,
Inventing Human Rights
, 160, 163–64; Popkin,
You Are All Free
, 45–46.
31
.  Benot,
La révolution
, 126–27; Régent,
La France
, 242–43; Piquet,
L’Émancipation
, 206–7; Curran,
Anatomy
, 206.
32
.  Raimond,
Réflexions
, 35–36.
33
.  Malouet,
Mémoires
, 2:195.
34
.  Girey-Duré,
Patriote français
1278 (10 Feb. 1793), 164–65.
35
.  Blackburn,
Overthrow
, 197–99, 228–29; Régent,
La France
, 243–45.
36
.  Popkin,
You Are All Free
, 210–11; 234–35, 248–49; Garrigus, “Opportunist,” 11; Hunt,
Inventing Human Rights
, 165.
37
.  Popkin,
You Are All Free
, 250–51.
38
.  Raimond,
Réflexions
, 8, 10.
39
.  Popkin,
You Are All Free
, 338, 344.
40
.  BL R-328/12. [Momoro?],
Coup d’oeil sur la question
, 5.
41
.  Ibid., 4–5, 12.
42
.  Ibid., 8.
43
.  Benot,
La révolution
, 172, 174; Piquet,
L’Émancipation
, 391–98; McPhee,
Robespierre
, 173.
44
.  Crow,
Emulation
, 160–1.
45
.  Doyle,
Oxford History
, 412; Lawday,
Giant of the French Revolution
, 240; Popkin,
You Are All Free
, 356.
46
.  Toussaint Louverture,
Lettres
, 155–58; Klooster,
Revolutions
, 106.
47
.  Toussaint Louverture,
Lettres
, 165, 172; Régent,
La France
, 249–50.
48
.  Baggio, “Toussaint Louverture,” 98–99.
49
.  Régent,
La France
, 252; Spieler, “Abolition and Reenslavement,” 136–37, 145–46.
50
.  Spieler, “Abolition and Reenslavement,” 137, 146–48.
51
.  Blackburn,
Overthrow
, 230–32.
52
.  Klooster, “Rising Expectations,” 66–67.
53
.  Aizpurua, “Revolution,” 99.
54
.  Toussaint Louverture,
Lettres
, 369–70; Blackburn,
Overthrow
, 238.
55
.  Israel,
Democratic Enlightenment
, 504–33.
56
.  Jordaan, “Patriots, privateers,” 101–3; Fulgencio López,
Juan Bautista Picornell
, 75, 80–81, 85, 88, 135.
57
.  Fulgencio López,
Juan Bautista Picornell
, 91–92.
58
.  Ibid., 73, 75.
59
.  Ibid., 35, 80, 89.
60
.  Jordaan, “Patriots, privateers,” 154–55.
61
.  Klooster, “Rising Expectations,” 59–60.
62
.  Klooster,
Revolution
, 105, 107.

CHAPTER 16

Robespierre’s Putsch (June 1793)

1
.  Dumouriez to the Convention, Louvain, 12 March 1793, in
Archives Parlementaires
, 61:40–41 (1 April 1793).
2
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 61:44 (1 April 1793).
3
.  Ibid., 61:45 (1 April 1793).
4
.  Girey-Dupré,
Patriote français
1334 (8 April 1793), 391.
5
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 61:16 (31 March 1793).
6
.  
Journal de Perlet
3, no. 186 (26 March), 426.
7
.  [Saint Martin],
Journal des décrets
2 (1793), 7;
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 194 (3 April 1793), 18–19.
8
.  
La Décade philosophique
2 (20 Fructidor), 303–4.
9
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 60:603 (27 March 1793);
Journal de Perlet
3, no. 188 (28 March 1793), 443–45.
10
.  
Journal de Perlet
3, no. 187 (27 March), 435.
11
.  Robespierre,
Œuvres complètes
, 9:421.
12
.  Ibid., 9:359; Slavin,
Making
, 26–45.
13
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 60:606–8 (27 March 1793).
14
.  Robespierre,
Œuvres complètes
, 9:378–79, 9:410–16.
15
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 60:608 (27 March 1793).
16
.  Ibid.; Lawday,
Giant of the French Revolution
, 203.
17
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 60:668–69 (28 March 1793).
18
.  Hébert,
Père Duchesne
229 (8 April 1793), 1–4.
19
.  Ibid., 232 (11 April 1793), 1–3, 6–7.
20
.  Wahnich,
L’impossible citoyen
17–18; Whaley,
Radicals
, 2–3.
21
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 215 (24 April 1793), 188, and 216 (25 April), 199.
22
.  Robespierre,
Œuvres complètes
, 9:415–16, 421.
23
.  Ibid., 9:478, 9:526; Slavin,
Making
, 25.
24
.  Robespierre,
Œuvres complètes
, 9:359, 9:406, 9:526; BHP pamph. 957082,
Anecdotes curieuses
, 19–20; Fréron,
L’Orateur du peuple
7, no. 89 (21 Ventose Year II), 715–16; Michelet,
Histoire
, 7:218.
25
.  Girey-Dupré,
Patriote français
1356 (30 April 1793), 479–80.
26
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 207 (16 April 1793), 125; Mercier,
Paris
, 1:158–59; Slavin,
Making
, 14–15.
27
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 206 (15 April 1793), 113.
28
.  Robespierre,
Œuvres complètes
, 9:418;
Journal de Perlet
4 (13 April 1793); [Ferrand]
État actuel
, 4–7 (April), 98–102.
29
.  Louvet,
Mémoires
, 1:60–61, 85; Slavin, “Robespierre,” 145–46.
30
.  Fauchet,
Journal des Amis
, 1:33.
31
.  Robespierre,
Œuvres complètes
, 9:420.
32
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 212 (21 April 1793) and no. 213 (22 April 1793), 163–66, 170–71; Patrick,
The Men
, 111.
33
.  Palmer,
From Jacobin to Liberal
, 26.
34
.  Lewis-Beck, “Was There a Girondist Faction?,” 526; Cobb,
The French
, 238–44; Dupuy,
La république jacobine
, 38–39; Sonenscher,
Sans-Culottes
, 2, 7–8, 57.
35
.  Gaulmier,
Un grand témoin
, 147–48.
36
.  Ibid., 149.
37
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 213 (22 April 1793), 173.
38
.  Ibid., 175.
39
.  
Journal de Perlet
3, no. 188 (28 March 1793), 447.
40
.  Bellanger,
Histoire générale
, 1:503–4.
41
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 60:700 (29 March 1793);
Journal de Perlet
3, no. 190 (30 March 1793), 459–60.
42
.  
Journal de Perlet
3, no. 191 (31 March 1793), 470.
43
.  Marat,
Œuvres politiques
, 10:1611;
Journal de Perlet
3, no. 182 (22 March 1793), 393.
44
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 221 (30 April 1793) and 222 (1 May 1793), 235, 246; M. L. Kennedy,
Jacobin Clubs
, 184.
45
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 243 (22 May 1793), 413.
46
.  Ibid., no. 192 (1 April 1793), 4 and 193 (2 April 1793), 15; Friedland,
Political Actors
, 189–96; Darlow,
Staging the French Revolution
, 95, 117.
47
.  Kitromilides, “Itineraries,” 9–10.
48
.  Alger, “British Colony,” 679–80; Foner,
Tom Paine
, 242.
49
.  Nelson,
Thomas Paine
, 251–52.
50
.  Ibid.
51
.  
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 230 (9 May 1793), 312.
52
.  Ibid., no. 203 (12 April 1793); Gross,
Fair Shares
, 72–73.
53
.  Darrow, “Economic Terror,” 513.
54
.  Robespierre,
Œuvres complètes
, 9:378.
55
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques,
no. 144 (24 May 1793), 661.
56
.  Girey-Dupré,
Patriote français
1326 (31 March 1793), 361; Gough,
Newpaper Press
, 93, 96.
57
.  Guilhaumou,
Marseille
, 182–89; Scott,
Terror and Repression
, 110–15.
58
.  Girey-Dupré,
Patriote français
1357 (2 May 1793), 488;
Journal de Perlet
4, no. 242 (21 May 1793), 407.
59
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
139 (19 May 1793), 642; Guilhaumou,
Marseille
, 191–92; Johnson,
Midi in Revolution
, 234; Hanson,
Jacobin Republic
, 81–90.

Other books

Running Wild by Sara Jane Stone
Granny by Anthony Horowitz
Whatever Mother Says... by Wensley Clarkson
Liar Liar by R.L. Stine
Death's Lover by Marie Hall
September Moon by Trina M. Lee