Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre (144 page)

Read Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre Online

Authors: Jonathan Israel

Tags: #History, #Europe, #France, #Revolutionary, #Modern, #18th Century, #Philosophy, #Political, #Social

BOOK: Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre
3.97Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
63
.  Brissot,
Mémoires (1734–1793)
, 2:85–86; Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 560 (5 June 1791), 8075–7.
64
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 559 (4 June 1791), 8069; Labbé,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 165.
65
.  
T. G. Raynal démasqué
, 6; Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 212–13; Israel,
Democratic Enlightenment
, 936.
66
.  Brissot,
Le Patriote français
665 (4 June 1791), 619–20 and 667 (6 June 1791), 626–27.
67
.  BN pamph. étampes, no. G162323 and 10978.
68
.  BL R 643/6,
Lettre du Citoyen Naigeon, 6 Germianl An V
, 2, 4; Israel,
Democratic Enlightenment
, 947.
69
.  Naigeon,
Encyclopédie méthodique
, 2:viii, xxiii–xxv.
70
.  Naigeon,
Adresse à l’Assemblée Nationale
, 100–102; Pellerin, “Naigeon,” 30, 32.
71
.  Staum,
Cabanis
, 29, 91.
72
.  Naigeon,
Encyclopédie méthodique
, 2:221–22.
73
.  Elyada, “Les récits,” 283–85.
74
.  Bonneville,
La Bouche de fer,
no. 42 (14 April 1791), 116.
75
.  Ibid., no. 42 (14 April 1791), 104–7; Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 200–202.
76
.  [Bonneville],
La Bouche de fer
no. 37 (1 April 1791), 20; Sorkin,
Religious Enlightenment
, 302.
77
.  [Bonneville],
La Bouche de fer
, no. 42 (14 April 1791), 108–14.
78
.  Ibid., no. 43 (16 April 1791), 122, 129.
79
.  Fauchet,
Journal des Amis
1, prospectus, 4–5.
80
.  [Bonneville],
La Bouche de fer
, no. 42 (14 April 1791), 101.
81
.  Chopelin-Banc,
De l’Apologétique
, 296–305; Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 204.
82
.  Elyada, “Le représentation,” 532–37.
83
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 27:378–83 (21 June 1791); Hardman,
Louis XVI
, 115; Hampson,
Will and Circumstance
, 155.
84
.  Elyada, “Les récits,” 286–88.
85
.  Ibid., 288–89; Elyada, “La représentation,” 528.
86
.  Marat,
L’Ami du peuple
, no. 497 (22 June 1791), 3068–69; Dingli,
Robespierre
, 135, 183–84; Barnave,
De la Révolution
, 144.
87
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 27:364, 27:366, 27:372 (21 June 1791);
Journal de Paris
, no. 177 (26 June 1791), 709.
88
.  
Journal du Club des Cordeliers
10 (4 Aug.1791), 86–87.
89
.  Ibid., 1 (28 June 1791), 1–2.
90
.  Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 580 (25 June 1791), 10034–35; Bertaud,
Les Amis du roi
, 209.
91
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
638 (2 July 1791), 1625; Durozoy,
La Gazette de Paris
, 22 June 1791, 1–2.
92
.  Fontana et al.,
Venise et la Révolution
, 584; Levasseur,
Mémoires de R. Levasseur
, 1:40; Prudhomme,
Histoire générale
, 1:11.
93
.  
Journal du Club des Cordeliers
1 (28 June 1791), 3.
94
.  Ibid., 2–3; Antheunis,
Le conventionnel belge
, 23–25.
95
.  
La Chronique de Paris
207 (26 July 1791), 835.
96
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
642 (6 July 1791), 1643 and 663 (7 July 1791), 1651.
97
.  Ibid., 645 (9 July 1791), 1656 and 666 (10 July 1791), 1661.
98
.  Ibid., 649 (13 July 1791), 1673; Monnier, “Républicanisme,” 104.
99
.  Roland,
Memoirs
, 82; D’Abrantès,
Salons révolutionnaires
, 90–91; Gueniffey, “Brissot,” 440, 450; Dingli,
Robespierre
, 163.

100
.  Kates,
Cercle Social
, 161; Hampson,
Life and Opinions
, 78–79; Nelson,
Thomas Paine
, 212–13.

101
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
645 (9 July 1791), 1655.

102
.  Ibid., 643 (7 July 1791), 1648, 1651; Lemny,
Jean-Louis Carra
, 208.

103
.  M. L. Kennedy,
Jacobin Clubs
, 280.

104
.  
Journal du Club des Cordeliers
, no. 7 (10 July 1791), 60; Whaley,
Radicals
, 41.

105
.  Doyle,
Oxford History
, 152–53; M. L. Kennedy,
Jacobin Clubs
, 282; Monnier, “Démocratie représentative,” 8.

106
.  Jordan,
Revolutionary Career
, 72.

107
.  Whaley,
Radicals
, 42.

108
.  Hébert,
Le Père Duchesne
59 (June 1791), 1 and no. 60, 2; Elyada, “La représentation,” 533, 537, 541, 544.

109
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
638 (2 July 1792), 1623; Desmoulins,
Révolutions de France et de Brabant
86 (July 1791), 5–6;
Journal du Club des Cordeliers
1 (28 June 1791), 7–8.

110
.  
Journal du Club des Cordeliers
1 (28 June 1791), 7; Fontana et al.,
Venise et la Révolution
, 586–87.

111
.  
Journal du Club des Cordeliers
7 (10 July 1792), 62, 64.

112
.  Brissot,
Discours sur la question
, 2–4.

113
.  Fréron,
L’Orateur du peuple
7, no. 2 (July 1791), 9.

114
.  Carra,
Annales Patriotiques
647 (11 July 1791), 1655;
La Chronique de Paris
193 (12 July 1791), 779, 781.

115
.  Bouissounouse,
Condorcet
, 233; Jones,
Great Nation
, 530; Jourdan, “Le culte de Rousseau,” 60–61.

116
.  Fontana et al.,
Venise et la Révolution
, 538; Staël,
Considerations
, 267; Scurr,
Fatal Purity
, 130–31.

117
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 193 (12 July 1791), 781; ibid., no. 262 (20 September), 1061.

118
.  Ibid., no. 192 (11 July 1791), 773 and 781–83; Carra,
Annales patriotiques
647 (11 July 1791), 1664.

119
.  Feller,
Journal historique et littéraire
(1792), 149.

120
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 29:736–37 (27 Aug, 1791).

121
.  Ginguené,
Petition to Assemblée nationale
, 27 Aug. 1791, 2; Ginguené,
Lettres
, 63–65.

122
.  Ginguené,
Petition to Assemblée nationale
, 5.

123
.  
Archives Parlementaires,
29:756 (27 Aug. 1791); Miller,
Rousseau
, 139, 241; Swenson,
On Jean-Jacques Rousseau
, 10.

124
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 29:755–56 (27 Aug. 1791); Jourdan, “Le culte de Rousseau,” 62–63.

125
.  Ginguené,
Lettres
, 30, 53.

126
.  Ibid., 80–82.

127
.  Ibid., 87–88, 131–45.

128
.  Ibid., 132.

129
.  Ginguené,
Petition to Assemblée nationale
, 3–4;
Archives Parlementaires
, 29:756 (27 Aug. 1791).

130
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 29:760–61 (27 Aug. 1791).

131
.  Ibid., 29:191 (4 Sept. 1791).

132
.  
La Chronique de Paris,
no. 211 (30 July 1791), 851.

133
.  Ibid., no. 195 (14 July 1791), 788, 790, and no. 196 (15 July 1791), 793.

134
.  Ibid., no. 207 (26 July 1791), 835–36.

135
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 28:325–26 (15 July 1791); Fitzsimmons,
Remaking of France
, 124–25.

136
.  Barnave,
Power, Property and History
, 27, 29, 33, 38.

137
.  Ibid., 101, 141.

138
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 28:330–31 (15 July 1791); Barnave,
Power, Property and History
, 19–20, 27; Furet, “Les Girondins,” 197.

139
.  Feller,
Journal historique et littéraire
(19 Aug. 1792), 148.

140
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 197 (16 July 1791), 798.

141
.  Doyle,
Oxford History
, 153.

142
.  
La Chronique de Paris,
no. 197 (16 July 1791), 796, and no. 207 (26 July 1791), 836; Roederer,
Spirit of the Revolution
, 37.

143
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 207 (26 July1791), 836; Burstin,
Révolution
, 256.

144
.  
Grande Petition presentée

par quarante mille citoyens
(15 July), 2.

145
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 197 (16 July 1791), 796–97.

146
.  
Grande Petition presentée

par quarante mille citoyens
(15 July).

147
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 208 (27 July 1791), 839.

148
.  Ibid., no. 199 (18 July 1791), 805; Applewhite,
Political Alignment
, 124–25.

149
.  
La Chronique de Paris,
no. 200 (19 July 1791), 809, and no. 202 (21 July 1791), 816.

150
.  Fontana et al.,
Venise et la Révolution
, 596–97; Barnave,
De la Révolution
, 146.

151
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 200 (19 July 1791), 809 and no. 207 (26 July 1791), 837.

152
.  
Journal du Club des Cordeliers
8 (19 July 1791), 68–69.

CHAPTER 7

War with the Church (1788–1792)

1
.  Ravitch, “Abbé Fauchet,” 251; Desan,
Reclaiming the Sacred
, 3; Petitfils,
Louis XVI
, 2:288.
2
.  Cérutti,
Mémoire pour le peuple françois
, 20–22.
3
.  McManners,
Church and Society
, 1:210–12, 215, 249, 287.
4
.  Forsyth,
Reason and Revolution
, 195.
5
.  Durozoy,
La Gazette de Paris
, 1 Jan. 1791, 1 and 15 Jan. 1791, 1–2.
6
.  Volney,
Les Ruines
, in Volney,
Œuvres complètes
, 1:268.
7
.  Tocqueville,
L’Ancien régime
, 202–4; Aston,
Religion and Revolution
, 3.
8
.  McPhee,
Robespierre
, 41, 83, 135, 174.
9
.  Quoted in Aston,
Religion and Revolution
, 132.
10
.  Royou,
L’Ami du Roi
, 23 Oct. 1791, 2.
11
.  Mirabeau,
Collection complète
, 3:42–44.
12
.  
La Chronique de Paris
2, 25 (25 Jan. 1790), 98; Fontana et al.,
Venise et la Révolution
, 158–59, 372.
13
.  Hertzberg,
French Enlightenment
, 351; Schlechter,
Obstinate Hebrews
, 55.
14
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 10:756–58 (23 Dec. 1789), speeches of Maury and de Lafarre; Jaher,
The Jews
, 69–70; Schechter,
Obstinate Hebrews
, 157; Girard,
La Révolution française
, 125–27.
15
.  
Journal des décrets
5, no. 10, 12–14; Fontana et al.,
Venise et la Révolution
, 371–72.
16
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 11:364–65 (28 Jan. 1790); Jaher,
The Jews
, 72.
17
.  Fontana et al.,
Venise et la Révolution
, 392.
18
.  Doyle,
Oxford History
, 411; Aston,
Religion and Revolution
, 252–54.
19
.  Michaud,
La Quotidienne
, no. 333 (9 Aug. 1793), 703.
20
.  E. Kennedy,
Cultural History
, 146.

Other books

Destiny Redeemed by Gabrielle Bisset
Gold Mountain by Karen J. Hasley
The Reluctant Wag by Costello, Mary
Death Diamonds of Bermudez by R. C. Farrington, Jason Farrington
Muerte en Hong Kong by John Gardner
Seeking Nirvana by V. L. Brock