Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre (146 page)

Read Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre Online

Authors: Jonathan Israel

Tags: #History, #Europe, #France, #Revolutionary, #Modern, #18th Century, #Philosophy, #Political, #Social

BOOK: Revolutionary Ideas: An Intellectual History of the French Revolution From the Rights of Man to Robespierre
6.93Mb size Format: txt, pdf, ePub
11
.  Kates,
Cercle
, 170–71; Lawday,
Giant of the French Revolution
, 98–99.
12
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 201 (20 July 1791), 812–13.
13
.  Desmoulins,
Révolutions de France et de Brabant
86 (July 1791), 20–21; Lagrave, “Thomas Paine,” 60.
14
.  Desmoulins,
Révolutions de France et de Brabant
88 (August, 1791), 35.
15
.  Ibid. (July 1791), lxviii, 15; Audouin,
Journal universel
, no. 606 (21 July 1791), 120–48.
16
.  Desmoulins,
Révolutions de France et de Brabant
67 (July 1791), 1–2.
17
.  
La Chronique du mois
2 (April, 1792), 84.
18
.  Desmoulins,
Révolutions de France et de Brabant
67 (July 1791), 10, and 88 (August 1791), 6; Pasquino,
Sieyès et l’invention
, 83.
19
.  Desmoulins,
Révolutions de France et de Brabant
86 (July 1791), 27; Hermon-Belot,
L’Abbé Grégoire
, 178–79.
20
.  Desmoulins,
Révolutions de France et de Brabant
67 (July 1791), 4.
21
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 211 (30 July 1791), 853; M. L. Kennedy,
Jacobin Clubs
, 4, 221.
22
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 248 (6 September 1791), 1003.
23
.  Fréron,
L’Orateur du peuple
7, no. 6 (July 1791), 45.
24
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
639 (3 July 1791), 1628.
25
.  Chisick,
Production, Distribution
, 56–59; Bertaud,
Les Amis du roi
, 44.
26
.  Marat,
L’Ami du peuple,
no. 529 (10 Aug. 1791), 3324–26.
27
.  Condorcet and Paine,
Le Républicain
1:3–4; E. Badinter and R. Badinter,
Condorcet, 1743–1794
, 333–34.
28
.  “Lettre de Thomas Paine à M. l’Abbe Sieyès, Paris, 8 July 1791,” in Condorcet and Paine,
Le Républicain
3:52–56; Carra,
Annales Patriotiques
650 (14 July 1791), 1681; Nelson,
Thomas Paine
, 212; D. Williams,
Condorcet and Modernity
, 31, 33.
29
.  Pasquino,
Sieyès et l’invention
, 80–86; Gauchet,
La Revolution
, 80–85.
30
.  Sieyès,
Manuscrits, 1773–1799
, 445; Forsyth,
Reason and Revolution
, 176–78; E. Badinter and R. Badinter,
Condorcet, 1743–1794
, 335–36.
31
.  Condorcet and Paine,
Le Républicain
, 2:17, 2:22.
32
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 248 (6 Sept. 1791), 1003.
33
.  Ibid., no. 228 (16 August 1791), 921; Gueniffey, “Brissot,” 437; Bates, “Political Pathologies,” 446.
34
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
639 (3 July 1791), 1628.
35
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 207 (26 July 1791), 835–36.
36
.  Ibid., no. 211 (30 July 1791), 852 and no. 230 (18 August 1791), 927.
37
.  Ibid., no. 218 (6 August 1791), 879 and no. 220 (8 August 1791), 887.
38
.  Ibid., no. 220 (8 August 1791), 887; Hunt,
Family Romance
, 110, 114, 121; Whaley,
Radicals
, 53.
39
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 211 (30 July 1791), 852.
40
.  
La Chronique du mois
1 (1791), 28.
41
.  [Leger],
L’Auteur
, 16.
42
.  Ibid., 18, 34–35; Maslan,
Revolutionary Acts
, 58–60.
43
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 29:151 (2 Sept. 1791).
44
.  Ibid., 29:189–90 (3 Sept. 1791).
45
.  Ibid., 29:633–35 (14 Sept. 1791);
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 256 (14 Sept. 1791), 1038.
46
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 262 (20 Sept. 1791), 1060.
47
.  Williams,
Letters from France
, 2:2–3.
48
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 248 (6 Sept. 1791), 1004.
49
.  Louvet,
Mémoires
, 1:26; Dard,
Hérault de Sechelles
, 148.
50
.  Royou,
L’Ami du Roi
, 31 Oct. 1791, 1.
51
.  Dickinson, “Counter-Revolution in Britain,” 358–63.
52
.  Fréron,
L’Orateur du peuple
6, no. 2 (July 1791), 11–13.
53
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 218 (6 August 1791), 879; Royou,
L’Ami du Roi
, 13 Oct. 1791, 3–4.
54
.  Kennedy,
Jacobin Clubs
, 5–8, 366; Serna,
Antontelle, Aristocrate révolutionnaire
, 179–80; Monnier, “Républicanisme,” 101.
55
.  Louvet,
Mémoires
, 1:37; Hampson,
Life and Opinions
, 99–100.
56
.  Constant,
De la Terreur
, 353–54; Lefebvre,
French Revolution
, 208.
57
.  Rousseau,
Social Contract
, 138–40; Miller,
Rousseau
, 205.
58
.  Royou,
L’Ami du Roi
, 27 Oct. 1791, 1.
59
.  Mortier,
Anacharsis Cloots
, 348.
60
.  Maslan,
Revolutionary Acts
, 55.
61
.  M. L. Kennedy,
Jacobin Clubs
, 56.
62
.  Ibid., 51–52, 358; Pineau-Defois, “Une élite,” 110–11, 114, 117–18.
63
.  Mitchell,
French Legislative
, 208–9.
64
.  Royou,
L’Ami du Roi
, 5 Oct. 1791, 1; Mitchell,
French Legislative
, 15, 19–20, 22.
65
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 257 (15 September 1791), 1041.
66
.  Tackett, “Conspiracy Obsession,” 709; Mitchell,
French Legislative
, 19–20, 24, 274.
67
.  Mitchell,
French Legislative
, 29, 299.
68
.  M. L. Kennedy,
Jacobin Clubs
, 7–8.
69
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 260 (18 September 1791), 1047–52.
70
.  Raynal,
Histoire philosophique
, 10: 66–67.
71
.  
La Chronique du mois
2 (March, 1792), 3–6.
72
.  
Assemblée Nationale, Corps administratifs
4, no. 295 (22 July 1792), 414–16; Dorigny, “Condorcet,” 337.
73
.  Popkin, “From Dutch Republican,” 543; Israel,
Democratic Enlightenment
, 273–74, 524–26.
74
.  
Assemblée Nationale, Corps administratifs
4, no. 216 (4 May 1792), 267–69.
75
.  
La Chronique de Paris
, no. 257 (15 Sept. 1791), 1039; P. Jones,
Peasantry
, 87–88.
76
.  Royou,
L’Ami du Roi
, 26 Feb. 1792, 3.
77
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 41:470 (11 April 1792).
78
.  Ibid., 41:485 (11 April 1792); P. Jones,
Peasantry
, 91–92, 120.
79
.  P. Jones,
Peasantry
, 92–93.
80
.  Royou,
L’Ami du Roi
, 3 Oct. 1791, 1–2.
81
.  Ibid., 26 Feb. 1792, 3–4; Bertaud,
Les Amis du roi
, 229.
82
.  
La Chronique du mois
2 (April 1792), 87.
83
.  Ibid., 71–73.
84
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 34:309–17 (20 Oct. 1791); Mitchell,
French Legislative
, 43.
85
.  C. Jones,
Great Nation
, 446–48, 456; Bates, “Political Pathologies,” 451–52; Davidson,
How Revolutionary Were the Bourgeois Revolutions?
, 66–67.
86
.  
Archives Parlementaires
, 44:273–78 (29 May 1792); Louvet,
La Sentinelle
, no. 9 (1792), 1.
87
.  E. Badinter and R. Badinter,
Condorcet, 1743–1794
, 423–25; Whaley,
Radicals
, 60; May,
Madame Roland
, 217–19.
88
.  Roland,
Lettre écrite au Roi
, 11–12; Bertrand de Molleville,
Mémoires secrets
, 2:220–21, 231–32.
89
.  Mitchell,
French Legislative
, 3, 171–72, 212.

CHAPTER 9

The “General Revolution” Begins (1791–92)

1
.  Grüner, “Deutschland,” 378.
2
.  Wedekind, “Einleitung und Kommentar,” 37–38.
3
.  Rehberg,
Untersuchungen
, 1:98–99.
4
.  Ibid., 1:87; Pagden,
The Enlightenment
, 316.
5
.  
Journal de Paris
, no. 322 (18 Nov. 1790), 1307–8.
6
.  Malouet,
Mémoires
, 2:132; C. Jones,
Great Nation
, 456.
7
.  Popkin,
News
, 219; McPhee,
Robespierre
, 113–16.
8
.  Carra,
Annales patriotiques
642 (6 July), 1643, and 643 (7 July), 1651.
9
.  Furet,
Interpreting the French Revolution
, 65–66; Doyle,
Oxford History
, 176; Doyle,
Aristocracy and Its Enemies
, 263–64.
10
.  Mallet du Pan,
Considérations
, 41.
11
.  Royou,
L’Ami du Roi,
15 Oct. 1791, 1.
12
.  Furet,
Interpreting the French Revolution
, 126; Lawday,
Giant of the French Revolution
, 112–13.
13
.  
Relation exacte de ce qui s’est passé à Bruxelles
(March 1790), 4–7.
14
.  Dhont, “Conservatieve Brabantse omwenteling,” 433–44; Van den Bossche,
Enlightened Innovation
, 44–46.
15
.  Feller,
Journal historique et littéraire
1 (15 April 1793), 175–78; Van den Bossche,
Enlightened Innovation
, 177–80.
16
.  
La Feuille villageoise
1, no. 10 (2 Dec. 1790), 183–84.
17
.  Weber,
Georg Christian Gottlieb Wedekind
, 156–57.
18
.  Blanning,
Reform and Revolution
, 273.
19
.  Rehberg,
Untersuchungen
, 2:117.
20
.  Ibid., 1:126–27, 1:150–52.
21
.  Ibid., 1:178–79, 1:210.
22
.  Losfeld,
Philanthropisme
, 3-4.
23
.  Ibid., 214–15, 225–26, 229–30, 233.
24
.  Blanning,
Reform and Revolution
, 272–73; Voss, “Die Kurpfalz im Zeichen,” 16.
25
.  Ruiz, “Deutsche Jakobiner,” 135.
26
.  Pestalozzi,
Sämtliche Briefe
, 3:280.
27
.  Hölderlin,
Sämtliche Werke
, 670–71.
28
.  Weber,
Georg Christian Gottlieb Wedekind
, 165.
29
.  Gaulmier,
Un grand témoin
, 130–31.
30
.  Hardman,
Louis XVI
, 139, 142–45; C. Jones,
Great Nation
, 454–55.
31
.  Malouet,
Mémoires
, 2:128–29.
32
.  Hardman,
Louis XVI
, 147; E. Badinter and R. Badinter,
Condorcet, 1743–1794
, 361.

Other books

Redrum by Boston George
Orca by Steven Brust
Sam's Legacy by Jay Neugeboren
The Third Man by Graham Greene
The Redemption by S. L. Scott
Ripe for Scandal by Isobel Carr
Cactus Flower by Duncan, Alice